top


The 2,587th CyberAlert. Tracking Liberal Media Bias Since 1996
1:25pm EST, Friday February 15, 2008 (Vol. Thirteen; No. 32)
Back To Today's CyberAlert | Free Subscription

1. Olbermann Accuses 'Fascist' Bush of Engaging in 'Terrorism'
On Thursday's Countdown show, MSNBC host Keith Olbermann delivered his latest "Special Comment" rant against President Bush, this time attacking him for threatening to veto an extension of the Protect America Act unless it includes provisions to give immunity from lawsuits to telecom companies who have cooperated with government surveillance in the past. Calling the President a "liar" who was "slinging crap" and using "a form of terrorism against his own people" to gain support, Olbermann accused President Bush of fascism: "If you believe in the seamless mutuality of government and big business, come out and say it! There is a dictionary definition, one word that describes that toxic blend. You're a fascist! Get them to print you a T-shirt with fascist on it! What else is this but fascism?"

2. CBS Early Show Delivers Valentine to 'Obama's Way with Words'
On Thursday's CBS Early Show, co-host Harry Smith introduced a fawning segment on Barack Obama: "On the campaign trail, Barack Obama is often treated like a rock star. People wait hours just to hear him speak." The segment did not focus on campaign strategy or policy, but rather it focused entirely on Obama's rhetoric as correspondent Tracy Smith touted MSNBC's Chris Matthews being "thrilled" by a speech from the Senator from Illinois: "They come in droves, by the tens of thousands at times, to hear Barack Obama speak...With soaring rhetoric, Obama is moving his audiences not just politically, but emotionally. Even some political commentators who've seen it all can't help but gush." Then the clip of Matthews was played: You hear Barack Obama's speech, my -- I felt this thrill going up my leg. I mean, I don't have that too often."

3. Only ABC Marks One Year Anniversary of Successful Surge in Iraq
If the surge in Iraq did not work, you can be sure the networks would all use its one-year anniversary to highlight its failure, but on Thursday night only ABC's World News, of the three broadcast network evening newscasts, marked the anniversary. With "Surge Success" on screen, anchor Charles Gibson noted "it was one year ago today that the surge began in Iraq -- the troop buildup ordered by the President when so many of his critics were calling for a draw down of troops. 30,000 additional troops started arriving a year ago." From Iraq, Clarissa Ward began over matching video: "If you're looking for one measure of the impact of the surge, look at General David Petraeus, walking through a Baghdad neighborhood with no body armor and no helmet. It's one year since the beginning of what's known here as 'Operation Fardh al-Qanoon.' According to the U.S. military, violence is down 60 percent. One key to the success, reconciliation."

4. Fonda Utters C-Word, Letterman's 'Top Ten Jane Fonda Excuses'
Prompted by Jane Fonda uttering the "C-word" on Thursday's Today show, from the February 14 Late Show with David Letterman, the "Top Ten Jane Fonda Excuses."


 

Olbermann Accuses 'Fascist' Bush of Engaging
in 'Terrorism'

     On Thursday's Countdown show, MSNBC host Keith Olbermann delivered his latest "Special Comment" rant against President Bush, this time attacking him for threatening to veto an extension of the Protect America Act unless it includes provisions to give immunity from lawsuits to telecom companies who have cooperated with government surveillance in the past.

     Calling the President a "liar" who was "slinging crap" and using "a form of terrorism against his own people" to gain support, Olbermann accused President Bush of fascism: "If you believe in the seamless mutuality of government and big business, come out and say it! There is a dictionary definition, one word that describes that toxic blend. You're a fascist! Get them to print you a T-shirt with fascist on it! What else is this but fascism?"

     Olbermann also had blunt words for Congressional Republicans who staged a walkout, as the Countdown host called them "crash dummies" who should "keep walking out of the country." Olbermann: "And your minions like John Boehner, your Republican congressional crash dummies who just happened to decide to walk out of Congress when a podium-full of microphones await them, they should just keep walking, out of Congress and, if possible, out of the country."

     [This item, by the MRC's Brad Wilmouth, was posted late Thursday night on the MRC's blog, NewsBusters.org: newsbusters.org ]

     As Olbermann began his February 14 "Special Comment," he quoted the President's contention that "if the bill was good enough" to be passed last summer, "why not pass the bill again?" and then invoked the past legality of slavery and, referring to Executive Order 9066, the internment of Japanese-Americans during World War II:

Now, as promised, a "Special Comment." A part of what I will say was said here first on January 31. Unfortunately it is both sadder and truer now than it was then. "Who's to blame?" Mr. Bush also said this afternoon, "Look, these folks in Congress passed a good bill late last summer. The problem is, they let the bill expire. My attitude is: If the bill was good enough then, why not pass the bill again?" You know, like the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution. Or Executive Order 9066. Or The Alien and Sedition Acts. Or slavery.

     The MSNBC host soon accused the Bush administration of spying on Americans "under this flimsy guise" of seeking out terrorists:

It is bad enough, sir, that you were demanding an ex post facto law which could still clear the AT&Ts and the Verizons from responsibility for their systematic, aggressive and blatant collaboration with your illegal and unjustified spying on Americans under this flimsy guise of looking for any terrorists who might be stupid enough to make a collect call or send a mass e-mail.

     Olbermann accused President Bush of fascism as he attacked the President's State of the Union reference to protecting telecom companies "believed" to have aided the administration:

But when you demanded it again during the State of the Union address, you wouldn't even confirm that they'd actually done anything for which they deserved to be cleared. "The Congress must pass liability protection for companies believed to have assisted in the efforts to defend America."

Believed? Don't you know? Don't you even have the guts Dick Cheney showed in admitting they did collaborate with you? Does this endless presidency of loopholes and even fine print extend here, too? If you believe in the seamless mutuality of government and big business, come out and say it! There is a dictionary definition, one word that describes that toxic blend. You're a fascist! Get them to print you a T-shirt with fascist on it!

     Olbermann added, "What else is this but fascism?" before recounting the appearance of an AT&T employee on his show who talked about his role in such surveillance, comparing it to "Big Brother" The MSNBC host went on to label Bush a "liar." Olbermann: "And if there's one thing we know about Big Brother, Mr. Bush, it's that he -- well, you -- are a liar."

     Citing Bush's contention that passage of the bill was important in protecting Americans against terrorism, the Countdown host soon continued: "This is crap. And you sling it with an audacity and a speed unrivaled even by the greatest political felons of our history."

     Olbermann soon labeled congressional Republicans who staged a walkout as "crash dummies" who "should just keep walking ... out of the country." Olbermann: "And your minions like John Boehner, your Republican congressional crash dummies who just happened to decide to walk out of Congress when a podium-full of microphones await them, they should just keep walking, out of Congress and, if possible, out of the country."

     The MSNBC host soon continued: "The lot of you are the symbolic descendants of the despotic middle managers of some banana republic to whom 'freedom' is an ironic brand name, a word you reach for when you want to get away with its opposite."

     Olbermann concluded his rant by accusing the President of a "form of terrorism against his own people," and contended that people like him will not "fear" speaking out against the President:

As recently ago as 2006, we spoke words like these with trepidation. The idea that even the most cynical and untrustworthy of the politicians in our history, George W. Bush, would use the literal form of terrorism against his own people was dangerous territory. It seemed to tempt fate, to heighten fear. We will not fear any longer. We will not fear the international terrorists, and we will thwart them. We will not fear the recognition of the manipulation of our yearning for safety. We will call it what it is: terrorism. We will not fear identifying the vulgar hypocrites in our government. We will name them. And we will not fear George W. Bush. Nor will we fear because George W. Bush wants us to fear.

     For the complete transcript of Olbermann's "Special Comment" from the February 14 Countdown show on MSNBC, check Brad's NewsBusters posting: newsbusters.org

 

CBS Early Show Delivers Valentine to
'Obama's Way with Words'

     On Thursday's CBS Early Show, co-host Harry Smith introduced a fawning segment on Barack Obama: "On the campaign trail, Barack Obama is often treated like a rock star. People wait hours just to hear him speak." The segment did not focus on campaign strategy or policy, but rather it focused entirely on Obama's rhetoric as correspondent Tracy Smith touted MSNBC's Chris Matthews being "thrilled" by a speech from the Senator from Illinois: "They come in droves, by the tens of thousands at times, to hear Barack Obama speak...With soaring rhetoric, Obama is moving his audiences not just politically, but emotionally. Even some political commentators who've seen it all can't help but gush." Then the clip of Matthews was played: You hear Barack Obama's speech, my -- I felt this thrill going up my leg. I mean, I don't have that too often."

     [This item, by the MRC's Kyle Drennen, was posted Thursday afternoon on the MRC's blog, NewsBusters.org: newsbusters.org ]

     With "Obama's Way with Words" as the on-screen header, Tracy Smith continued by drawing the cliched comparison of Obama to JFK: "The stoic eloquence channels John F. Kennedy...Perhaps it's no surprise that legendary JFK speech writer, Ted Sorensen, supports Obama. He speaks regularly with the campaign's speech writing team." Time magazine's Joe Klein was also quoted: "Kennedy had this wonderful rise ironic sense, just as Obama does. Most of them are cool customers, which works really well on television."

     Tracy Smith did include a brief response to Obama's rhetoric from presumptive Republican nominee, John McCain: "To encourage a country with only rhetoric, rather than sound and proven ideas, the trust and the strength and courage of free people is not a promise of hope. It's a platitude."

     Following Tracy Smith's report, Harry Smith continued the segment by interviewing pollster Frank Luntz and made sure that everyone new Luntz was a Republican: "Joining us is long time Republican Strategist and Pollster Frank Luntz, author of the book Words that Work...You've worked so much with Republicans. I want to get the bona fides out here because you have been impressed by Barack Obama's use of words, have you not?"

     Luntz's response added to the gushy segment: "More than impressed, I've been mesmerized."

     Outdoing even Harry Smith's awe of Obama, Luntz exclaimed: "Obama says come on in. We will not divide by race, we will not divide by age, we will not divide by partisanship. And he talks about Republicans supporting him." Smith interjected: "Yeah. He calls them 'Obamacans.'" Luntz continued: "Yeah, it's unprecedented."

     Smith went on to discuss the youth vote for Obama: "There's the thing, though. We look at these pictures, we see all of these young people. Do these young people, who love their lattes, as you said just a second ago, will they drop their lattes and actually go to the polls? Will they do -- will -- is he electable with those people?" Luntz responded: "There's an organization called 'Declare Yourself,' Norman Lear created this a few years ago. Do you realize that young people make up 12, 14, in some states, as much as 18% of the primary electorate? Not only will they drop their lattes, they'll take their ipods out and listen to him. And how great is it that for the first time in my lifetime the youth of America are energized, emboldened, and they can't wait to vote."

     At this point, as the segment concluded, Smith made sure to mention that Luntz was a Republican one last time: "This comes from a Republican pollster." Luntz responded: "Although, I would argue that I've kind of left that career behind me."

     Here is the full transcript of the segment:

     7:01AM TEASER, MAGGIE RODRIGUEZ: Also, ahead this half hour, a closer look at the words of Barack Obama. How they're inspiring millions, even being put to music. We'll here why McCain and Clinton are worried about this and what Michelle Obama says about it.

     7:16AM SEGMENT, HARRY SMITH: On the campaign trail, Barack Obama is often treated like a rock star. People wait hours just to hear him speak. Here's Early Show National Correspondent Tracy Smith.

     TRACY SMITH: They come in droves, by the tens of thousands at times, to hear Barack Obama speak.
     BARACK OBAMA: They are ready for something new.
     SMITH: With soaring rhetoric, Obama is moving his audiences not just politically, but emotionally. Even some political commentators who've seen it all can't help but gush.
     CHRIS MATTHEWS: You hear Barack Obama's speech, my -- I felt this thrill going up my leg. I mean, I don't have that too often.
     OBAMA: We are the ones we've been waiting for.
     SMITH: The stoic eloquence channels John F. Kennedy.
     JOHN KENNEDY: Ask not what your country can do for you.
     OBAMA: We'll invest in you. You invest in your country.
     SMITH: Perhaps it's no surprise that legendary JFK speech writer, Ted Sorensen, supports Obama. He speaks regularly with the campaign's speech writing team.
     JOE KLEIN: Kennedy had this wonderful rise ironic sense, just as Obama does. Most of them are cool customers, which works really well on television.
     SMITH: Obama's mantra, 'yes, we can,' has even gone hip-hop with this music video, viewed more than 3 million times on YouTube.
     UNIDENTIFIED SINGERS: Yes we can. Oh, yes we can, yes with can, yes, we can, the opportunity and prosperity.
     SMITH: And John McCain, should he face Obama in the general election, has an answer to the eloquence already.
     JOHN MCCAIN: To encourage a country with only rhetoric, rather than sound and proven ideas, the trust and the strength and courage of free people is not a promise of hope. It's a platitude.
     SMITH: Tracy Smith, CBS News, New York.
    
     HARRY SMITH: Joining us is long time Republican Strategist and Pollster Frank Luntz, author of the book 'Words that Work.' Good morning.
     FRANK LUNTZ: Good morning.
     SMITH: You've worked so much with Republicans. I want to get the bona fides out here because you have been impressed by Barack Obama's use of words, have you not?
     LUNTZ: More than impressed, I've been mesmerized. You saw at the end of that clip the word 'hope.' I've never seen a candidate whose slogan and language is bigger than his own name and the buttons and the bumper stickers. It's interesting that people compare him to John Kennedy. It's Bobby Kennedy that he's channeling.
     SMITH: Really?
     LUNTZ: The message. And when you go to an event and you see so many thousands of 18,19, 20-year-olds, the only time they ever cared until this point was if they couldn't get their latte at Starbucks. I want to read you a segment.
     SMITH: Alright.
     LUNTZ: I did this book 'Words that Work.' It was the last thing I added to the book because I thought this was the best language I'd ever heard: 'Let us dedicate ourselves to what the Greeks wrote so many years ago, to tame the savageness of man and make gentle the life of this world.' That was Bobby Kennedy the night Martin Luther King was killed.
     SMITH: Right.
     LUNTZ: That's what Barack Obama is saying today. Hillary Clinton is very overt in her attacks against the Republicans. 'We're not going to let ourselves get swift boated.' Obama says come on in. We will not divide by race, we will not divide by age, we will not divide by partisanship. And he talks about Republicans supporting him.
     SMITH: Yeah. He calls them 'Obamacans.'
     LUNTZ: Yeah, it's unprecedented. And --
     SMITH: Let me ask you -- let me ask you this. Because you're hearing already, Hillary goes after Obama and says it's all about platitudes, it's all about promises, John McCain already going after Obama, it's all about the words, where are the deeds? Does -- they are very concerned about his words.
     LUNTZ: They are, but what they don't understand is that for a whole lot of Americans, the candidates' attributes and character traits are even more important than where they stand. If they trust them, if they believe them. If this is someone who's a visionary. Now here's the key attribute that Americans want in 2008, someone who says what they mean and means what they say. If Obama were to ever be shown as a hypocrite, to say one thing and then say something completely different, then he's in trouble. But if he maintains that visionary, that -- in essence, that hope and uplifting rhetoric, he survives and thrives.
     SMITH: There's the thing, though. We look at these pictures, we see all of these young people. Do these young people, who love their lattes, as you said just a second ago, will they drop their lattes and actually go to the polls? Will they do -- will -- is he electable with those people?
     LUNTZ: There's an organization called 'Declare Yourself,' Norman Lear created this a few years ago. Do you realize that young people make up 12, 14, in some states, as much as 18% of the primary electorate? Not only will they drop their lattes, they'll take their ipods out and listen to him. And how great is it that for the first time in my lifetime the youth of America are energized, emboldened, and they can't wait to vote.
     SMITH: This comes from a Republican pollster.
     LUNTZ: Although, I would argue that I've kind of left that career behind me.
     SMITH: Alright, for another time.
     LUNTZ: For another time.
     SMITH: Frank Luntz, thank you so much for joining us this morning. Very interesting stuff.
     SMITH: In our next hour, what Michelle Obama says about her husband's words.

 

Only ABC Marks One Year Anniversary of
Successful Surge in Iraq

     If the surge in Iraq did not work, you can be sure the networks would all use its one-year anniversary to highlight its failure, but on Thursday night only ABC's World News, of the three broadcast network evening newscasts, marked the anniversary. With "Surge Success" on screen, anchor Charles Gibson noted "it was one year ago today that the surge began in Iraq -- the troop buildup ordered by the President when so many of his critics were calling for a draw down of troops. 30,000 additional troops started arriving a year ago." From Iraq, Clarissa Ward began over matching video:
     "If you're looking for one measure of the impact of the surge, look at General David Petraeus, walking through a Baghdad neighborhood with no body armor and no helmet. It's one year since the beginning of what's known here as 'Operation Fardh al-Qanoon.' According to the U.S. military, violence is down 60 percent. One key to the success, reconciliation."

     Ward proceeded to outline how residents of one Baghdad neighborhood "who had fled have flooded back in droves. "There is work," this mechanic told me. "Shops have reopened." But the Iraqi government has yet to capitalize on the relative peace. The hope is that the passing of the budget this week will spur the Iraqi government to act."

     Ward concluded with how Petraeus is "normally very guarded in his assessment of the surge," but "now expresses cautious optimism." Petraeus asserted: "I have to tell you that having been here for a number of years, this is very encouraging, actually. This is potentially a big moment."

     Thursday's CBS Evening News didn't have time for Iraq, but did make room for a five-minute long taped Katie Couric interview with Michelle Obama and the NBC Nightly News skipped the anniversary, but did end with a story on two-year old girl brought from Iraq (by Marines via a Tennessee church pastor) to Vanderbilt Hospital for a life-saving operation.

     [This item, by the MRC's Brent Baker, was posted Friday on the MRC's blog, NewsBusters.org: newsbusters.org ]

     The February 14 CyberAlert item, "ABC Uniquely Lists 'Crucial' New Laws Passed by Iraq's Parliament," recounted:

Unlike the Wednesday CBS and NBC evening newscasts, ABC's World News highlighted a favorable development in Iraqi political progress as anchor Charles Gibson gave 20 seconds to: "Overseas, in Iraq, a breakthrough for the country's government that has been so often criticized. Iraq's parliament approved three contentious, but crucial, new laws long sought by Washington. The laws set a budget for 2008, grant amnesty to thousands of detainees and define the relationship between the central government and the provinces."

     That's online at: www.mrc.org

     Media interest in Iraq has declined as conditions have improved. The February 4 CyberAlert item by the MRC's Rich Noyes, "As U.S. Troops Succeed, Media Retreat from Iraq War Story," reported:

...over the last five months, the broadcast networks have consistently reduced their coverage of Iraq, as if the story of American success in Iraq is less worthy of attention than their old mantra of American failure in Iraq.

Media Research Center analysts tracked all coverage of the Iraq war on the ABC, CBS and NBC evening newscasts from September 1 through January 31, and we documented a steady decline in TV coverage of Iraq that has coincided with the improving situation in Iraq. Back in September, the three evening newscasts together broadcast 178 stories about the war in Iraq; in January, that number fell to just 47, a nearly fourfold decrease....

     For that CyberAlert rundown in full: www.mrc.org

     The MRC's Brad Wilmouth corrected the closed-captioning against the video to provide this transcript of the story on the February 14 World News with Charles Gibson on ABC:

     CHARLES GIBSON: It was one year ago today that the surge began in Iraq -- the troop buildup ordered by the President when so many of his critics were calling for a draw down of troops. 30,000 additional troops started arriving a year ago. Most remain. For our "Closer Look" tonight, we take stock of a year's changes. And the U.S. commander, General David Petraeus, found a way to demonstrate the changes. Clarissa Ward reports from Baghdad.

     CLARISSA WARD: If you're looking for one measure of the impact of the surge, look at General David Petraeus, walking through a Baghdad neighborhood with no body armor and no helmet. It's one year since the beginning of what's known here as "Operation Fardh al-Qanoon." According to the U.S. military, violence is down 60 percent. One key to the success, reconciliation.
     GENERAL DAVID PETRAEUS: And a big part of the effort over the last year has been to determine who is reconcilable? Who literally is willing to put down his rifle and talk? Who is willing to shout instead of shoot?
     WARD: This is the Jihad neighborhood of Baghdad. It used to be one of the most violent areas of the city. One year into Operation Fardh al-Qanoon, and that level has dropped dramatically. But there is still a desperate need to restore basic services. Before Shiite militiamen wreaked havoc in the streets. Then, U.S. and Iraqi troops moved into the neighborhood, earning the trust of local people, finding those men willing to put down their guns. In recent months, residents of Jihad who had fled have flooded back in droves. "There is work," this mechanic told me. "Shops have reopened." But the Iraqi government has yet to capitalize on the relative peace. The hope is that the passing of the budget this week will spur the Iraqi government to act.
     PETRAEUS: So that they can start going about the jobs that are so essential, like patching the roads that we bounced down today, improving electricity, fixing water systems.
     WARD: Normally very guarded in his assessment of the surge, the General now expresses cautious optimism.
     PETRAEUS: I have to tell you that having been here for a number of years, this is very encouraging, actually. This is potentially a big moment.
     WARD: A big moment the General wants to make the most of. Clarissa Ward, ABC News, Baghdad.

 

Fonda Utters C-Word, Letterman's 'Top
Ten Jane Fonda Excuses'

     Prompted by Jane Fonda uttering the "C-word" on Thursday's Today show, from the February 14 Late Show with David Letterman, the "Top Ten Jane Fonda Excuses." Late Show home page: www.cbs.com

10. It was nickel beer at IHOP

9. Seemed like something people would want to hear first thing in the morning

8. Katie Couric used to say it all the time

7. It's not such a bad word when you think about it

6. Roker likes it when I talk dirty

5. It was today's entry on my word-of-the-day calendar

4. Too many years listening to Ted Turner

3. Ain't been right since injection from Roger Clemens' trainer

2. That pinhead Lauer dared me

1. Trying to be romantic on Valentine's day


     If you are interested on the Fonda incident, which occurred during a discussion about her role in the Vagina Monologues, the MRC's Justin McCarthy posted it on the MRC's NewsBusters blog, with video rendered by the MRC's Ken Shepherd, all in an item highlighted by the Drudge Report. For "Jane Fonda Uses the C-Word on Today," with a video clip, go to: newsbusters.org

-- Brent Baker

 


Sign up for CyberAlerts:
     Keep track of the latest instances of media bias and alerts to stories the major media are ignoring. Sign up to receive CyberAlerts via e-mail.

Subscribe!
Enter your email to join MRC CyberAlert today!

 

questions and comments about CyberAlert subscription

     You can also learn what has been posted each day on the MRC’s Web site by subscribing to the “MRC Web Site News” distributed every weekday afternoon. To subscribe, go to: http://www.mrc.org/cybersub.asp#webnews

 


Home | News Division | Bozell Columns | CyberAlerts 
Media Reality Check | Notable Quotables | Contact the MRC | Subscribe

Founded in 1987, the MRC is a 501(c) (3) non-profit research and education foundation
 that does not support or oppose any political party or candidate for office.

Privacy Statement

Media Research Center
325 S. Patrick Street
Alexandria, VA 22314