McCain Voters Prefer Gore: Bush’s Fault; Granny D, NBC Hero; Gentle Bus
1) Bush won, but CBS still focused on his "difficult day
on the stump" denying he’s anti-Catholic. The exit poll found 42
percent of McCain voters plan to vote for Gore this fall, a finding CBS and
NBC portrayed as a sign of Bush’s weakness.
2) Today devoted an entire interview to quizzing Jeb Bush
about his brother’s visit to Bob Jones University and to McCain’s charge
that "he is being lured too far to the right to win."
3) "I love Granny D!" exclaimed Today’s Matt Lauer
of the woman who walked cross the nation in a gimmick to push campaign finance
"reform." Katie Couric roared: "She's great!" Tuesday
night Bob Dotson claimed she "has felt the nation hugging her
4) ABC’s Cokie Roberts let slip that McCain didn’t face
tough questions from reporters he invited aboard his bus.
week’s MagazineWatch, about the March 6 Time, Newsweek and U.S. News, is now
online. Topics covered in the edition compiled by MRC analyst Paul Smith:
1. In the wake of the Diallo police-shooting trial, Time writer Jack E. White
nominated race-baiting Al Sharpton as a "moral leader" -- if he
could only admit that he’s lied and railroaded an innocent man for years.
2. Newsweek’s Evan Thomas and Michael Isikoff blew John McCain another wet
kiss, concluding he’s "different enough from the average pol to seem at
once human and heroic." But Newsweek’s Howard Fineman and Time’s
Nancy Gibbs noted McCain’s lying about his knowledge of his campaign’s
"Catholic Voter Alert" calls in Michigan.
3. U.S. News & World Report writer Roger Simon upbraided the Bush
"geniuses" that "sent him to Bob Jones University in South
Carolina, which is like wrapping him in the Confederate flag and setting him
on fire." U.S. News columnist Michael Barone predicted a future for
President McCain: "Look for campaign finance reform to go the way of
Jimmy Carter's energy bill or the Clinton health care plan."
4. In "Washington Whispers," U.S. News scribe Paul Bedard belittled
J.C. Watts for lamenting the liberal media for the Leadership Institute.
To read these items, go to:
double digit blow out win for Bush over McCain in Virginia," proclaimed
Dan Rather at the top of the 7pm ET CBS Evening News Tuesday night. Actually,
Bush won by nine points: 53 to 44 percent over John McCain. Despite his win,
CBS focused on the negative for Bush, as Phil Jones stressed how "he’s
had a very difficult day on the stump. It’s the same old question, did his
appearance at Bob Jones University in South Carolina...mean that he’s
anti-Catholic." CBS also ran a story on McCain’s latest attacks on the
Religious Right for promoting the "politics of division" while ABC
looked at how he’s trying to convince Republicans he has a better shot of
beating Gore and NBC focused on his "damage control" effort after
his blasts the day before.
CBS and NBC cited an exit poll finding that 42 percent
of McCain voters plan to vote for Gore in the fall if Bush wins the Republican
nomination. But instead of seeing this as confirmation that McCain’s
"big tent" is being raised by liberals with no loyalty to the GOP,
CBS’s Bob Schieffer and NBC’s Tim Russert portrayed it as a sign of
After weeks of being tarred as going to the far right,
ABC’s Dean Reynolds portrayed Bush’s advocacy of a tax cut as a sign
he’s moving to the center: "Governor Bush has been moving toward the
political center, emphasizing such things as tax cuts and education."
In non-campaign news, NBC Nightly News led with shooting
of a first grader in Michigan by another six-year-old. Anchor Tom Brokaw
asserted: "The community is stunned and already there’s a new chorus of
demands to do something about guns in America." In his subsequent story
Jim Avila said nothing about any calls for gun control, so the "new
chorus" must be the same old one from inside 30 Rockefeller Plaza.
Here’s a rundown of Tuesday night, February 29,
campaign coverage on the three broadcast networks:
-- ABC’s World News Tonight led with the Michigan
school shooting but soon got to the campaign in the 6:30pm ET feed shown in
Washington, DC before the polls closed.
From the Bush campaign trail reporter Dean Reynolds
checked in, as transcribed by MRC analyst Jessica Anderson: "Governor
Bush is hoping that good news at the polls today will show that Senator
McCain's charges of religious intolerance in the Republican Party have
fizzled. Bush was in full response mode this morning in Cleveland. At a
Catholic family center, the Governor took pains to show his courtship of
conservative Protestants does not mean he is anti-Catholic, as Senator McCain
is suggesting now in Virginia and may try to do next week in Ohio."
Bush: "He says
he's going to run a clean campaign, yet he's got calls going into the
Commonwealth of Virginia calling me an anti-Catholic bigot, which is -- yeah,
he ought not to be doing it. Of course he ought to apologize."
said McCain is trying to demonize him in the eyes of Catholic voters."
After another Bush soundbite, Reynolds added: "At a rally near Columbus later, Bush said
McCain's attack on Christian conservative leaders shows he is more interested
in excluding people from the party than including them."
Reynolds concluded: "After being hammered for days
as the captive of narrow minds, Governor Bush has been moving toward the
political center, emphasizing such things as tax cuts and education. He'll
take a good showing today as a sign that he's moving in the right
Next, Linda Douglass hinted at the Virginia loss for
"Now that the open
primary in Virginia is over, it's even clearer to John McCain here in
California that he's got to home in on Republicans, because if he doesn't
start winning with Republicans, he cannot win the nomination. So he told
Republicans here that, after all, they have lost the last two presidential
elections and he told them that only he can save them from losing a third.
Hopscotching through the conservative agricultural heart of California, McCain
argued George Bush is simply not a strong candidate."
Republicans nominate the weaker candidate, Al Gore will be able to continue
the big money, special interest politics of truth-twisting that has shamed his
party and America for seven long years."
made clear that if he is the nominee, he will be willing to savage Al Gore. He
said he learned how to do battle with Gore when they served in the House
McCain: "I faced
him down in debates. I know him and I know his lack of principles and will
eagerly put him on the defensive. In this presidential race, I will beat Al
Gore like a drum; George Bush cannot."
Douglass concluded by
describing his attacks on the Religious Right as an effort to "reach
out" to moderates: "Now McCain continued to rail against television
evangelist Pat Robertson. That, of course, is all part of an effort to reach
out to moderates and independent and Democratic voters. They can cross over to
vote here in California, but their votes will not count toward choosing
-- CBS Evening News went right to the results at 7pm ET
with Bob Schieffer running through a bunch of exit poll numbers from Virginia,
including how McCain captured just 25 percent of the Republican vote and when
asked who attacked who unfairly, in contrast to the media line, 51 percent of
Virginians blamed McCain compared to only 33 percent who named Bush.
But Schieffer found a downside in Bush’s victory:
"Most of what we did see in this poll was very good news for Bush, but
there is one finding that will be disturbing to him and to Republicans in
general: More than 40 percent of the people who voted for McCain today said
they would vote for Democrat Al Gore rather than vote for Bush in the general
election. That shows you Bush still has plenty of work to do."
Yeah, in getting fewer partisan Democrats to vote in
From California, Bill Whitaker highlighted not
McCain’s electoral troubles but his continued attacks on a part of
Reagan’s coalition, reporting that McCain’s quest is "nothing less
than a fight for the soul of the Republican Party."
"These people have led our party out of the mainstream of America. They
are exclusive and not inclusive. They practice politics of division not
addition. I want people to come into our party. I want them there."
"What started as a quest to reform the system now is a full-fledged
crusade to re-create the GOP," but "the problem for McCain is the
GOP leadership and its most devoted voters don’t want to be reformed and
consider his call to non-Republicans a hostile takeover."
McCain got another soundbite to hammer away: "Do we
want to head in an inclusive reform direction or do we want to head in the
direction of exclusivity and permanent minority status?"
Whitaker did conclude
by pointing out that "if he ends up alienating more voters than he draws
in, not only might he lose but he could leave the GOP damaged and hurt to face
the Democrats in November."
Phil Jones, in the CBS News Washington bureau, narrated
a story on Bush which stressed the negative: "Governor Bush needed this
good news from Virginia but he’s had a very difficult day on the stump.
It’s the same old question, did his appearance at Bob Jones University in
South Carolina, which is anti-Catholic, mean that he’s anti-Catholic."
Jones explained how at a Catholic family center in Ohio
Bush apologized again and accused McCain of a spiteful campaign. Uniquely
picking up on Pat Robertson’s reaction to McCain expressed by phone on his
700 Club TV show, Jones followed the McCain/liberal spin and labeled Robertson
a "problem" for Bush: "Pat
Robertson, another political-religious problem for Bush, emerged on his 700
Club broadcast today, reporting in from a business trip to Mexico."
-- NBC Nightly News
at 7pm ET. Tim Russert ran through some exit poll numbers. After relaying how
82 percent of Democrats voted for McCain in Virginia, Russert found trouble
for Republicans in how many McCain voters will back Gore in the fall:
"And one important
number Tom that should cause a lot of pause to Republicans and put a smile on
Democrats: 42 percent of the people who voted for John McCain today said they
would support Al Gore in November."
Lisa Myers checked in from the Bush camp where she saw
"a huge sigh of relief." She went on to detail how he spent the day
repairing damage with Catholics, noting that a new poll showed Bush up 17
points in Ohio and even ahead among Buckeye Catholics.
From the McCain campaign trail Anne Thompson looked at
his fight to win in Washington (which he lost) and in California next week.
She uniquely raised his debate pull-out, "Also today: Damage control for
McCain, mounting criticism for his decision to skip Thursday’s Republican
debate in California." She added, however, that he offered to appear via
satellite at the forum to be shown by CNN.
brought aboard George W. Bush’s brother, Jeb Bush, on Tuesday morning to
quiz him about his brother’s speech at Bob Jones University. Asked if he’d
speak there, Jeb Bush, who is the Governor of Florida, replied "I
would," explaining getting your message out to thousands of students, who
don’t necessarily follow the beliefs of college leaders, is worthwhile.
Ann Curry set up the taped interview piece: "On
Close Up this morning the Bush brothers. Texas Governor George W. Bush has
faced heavy criticism for his visit earlier this month for his visit to Bob
Jones University. A Christian school in South Carolina that bans interracial
dating and whose founder once called the Catholic Church a satanic cult. This
morning our national correspondent Jamie Gangel has an exclusive interview
with the Governor's brother, Florida Governor Jeb Bush. For him the
controversy has become very personal and not just because his brother is under
attack. Jeb Bush himself is Catholic and his wife is from Mexico. So we began
by asking him to answer the toughest charges critics are leveling against his
Here are Jamie Gangel’s one-track series of questions,
as transcribed by MRC analyst Geoffrey Dickens:
-- "Is your
brother an anti-Catholic bigot who doesn't believe in interracial dating or
-- "Why do you
think it's become such a big issue?"
-- "Are you
offended by the teachings of Bob Jones University?"
-- "You don't
think he made a mistake speaking there?"
-- "Would you
speak at Bob Jones University?"
-- "But it is
costing George W. Bush. Because he took so many weeks to respond his polls
have plummeted in states like New York. And John McCain is continuing his
attacks. Let me give you a couple of the things that John McCain has said. He
has called your brother a willing surrogate of the Christian Coalition and
that he is being lured too far to the right to win."
-- "Doesn't this
hurt, undermine your brother's claim that he is a new Republican, that he is
reaching out to minorities, Democrats and other moderates?"
-- "But how much
does Bob Jones hurt him? How much does the political fallout?"
-- "Do you think
he is still going to win the nomination?"
-- "Do you think
he can still win in November?"
D," media hero. Literally. Tuesday morning 90-year-old Doris Haddock
ended in Washington, DC her cross-country walk to gain publicity for her quest
to impose more regulations and limitations on free speech, known in the media
world as "campaign finance reform." After she appeared on Today,
co-host Matt Lauer proclaimed: "I love Granny D!" Colleague Katie
Couric, who did not challenge her views once in her softball interview and
labeled her an "amazing role model," abandoned any pretense of
objectivity, chiming in: "She's great!"
Tuesday night NBC Nightly News made another media
contribution to Haddock’s liberal cause, the kind of advocacy her favored
McCain-Feingold bill will leave unfettered, as reporter Bob Dotson claimed
"Haddock has felt the nation hugging her shoulders" and oozed about
how while "most of us only witness history she went out and made
it." How that is, given nothing has happened to advance her cause in the
House or Senate, he did not say.
On the February 29 Today Couric set up the interview:
"Last January Doris Haddock began a crusade to gather support for
campaign finance reform. Better known as Granny D, this 90 year old great
grandmother of 12 has walked 10 miles a day, six days a week across the entire
country. After almost 14 months on the road her 3000 mile journey ends today.
She joins us this morning from Arlington National Cemetery just a few steps
from her final destination. the U.S. Capitol. Granny D, may I call you Granny
D, good morning."
Here are Couric’s promotional questions:
-- "Nice to see
you. Well wow! You must be so excited that you finished this incredible cross
country trek. It's taken you over a year how are you feeling now that it's
about to end?"
-- "I bet it's
been an incredible experience for you because you've met with so many
supporters and you've really heard from so many people who agree with what
-- Couric, after
Haddock said she "traveled as a pilgrim" and found people happy to
give her meals and a place to sleep: "Ahh, that's nice. How did you
become so passionate about this particular issue?" Haddock answered that
she wants her grandchildren raised "in a democracy."
-- "You feel particularly strongly about so called
soft money. Campaign contributions from wealthy people or corporations that go
through the party's national committees, correct?"
Haddock claimed it’s
already illegal: "That's right. That's soft money and it is illegal. It
has been ever since 1907 when Theodore Roosevelt was able to pass a law saying
no corporation money in politics. And in 1947 the same law was passed for the
unions and so they are accepting illegal money and that is not a
-- "Do you think you're having an impact do you
think this walk is making people pay attention or that any change will result
Haddock noted that she
walked with McCain and Bradley, but complained that though local papers have
celebrated her trip: "I haven’t done too well with the national
media." Most people with a political cause can only dream of this kind of
softball promotion of their cause. Back on January 24 she got another national
network platform as Good Morning America co-host Charles Gibson endorsed her
cause: "This is very worthy work that you do, bringing attention to
campaign finance reform."
-- "Well you've been
an amazing role model. You have a corset with metal ribs under your clothes
because you suffer from arthritis. You have two hearing aides, you have
emphysema, so this is quite a feat. Even when it snowed you got out cross
country skis and continued your trek."
-- After Haddock recalled how scary it was to walk in the
middle of roads after it snowed, Couric bucked her up: "I bet it was. But
you hung in there because you're a tough woman. Granny D, Doris Haddock,
thanks so much for talking with us and congratulations."
Haddock: "My Web
site is Grannyd.com. And I have three Senators that I'm dedicating my mileage
to. Senator Abraham, Senator Kyl and Senator DeWine."
Granny D. Thanks again for mentioning your Web site because I was gonna do
MRC analyst Geoffrey Dickens noticed how the Today team
gushed about Haddock. After a commercial break late in the 7:30am half hour,
as the Today team sat on the coach, they discussed the interview:
Matt Lauer: "I
love Granny D!"
Couric: "Isn't she
hilarious? I mean not hilarious, she's great!"
Lauer: "And I
loved when she at the end there said, 'And my Web site is.' We don't hear
that, that often and it's fantastic. And it is nice as you said that she is
someone who believed in something strongly enough to spend 14 months of her
life doing this."
clearly she's very, very knowledgeable about the issue. She's not paying lip
service. She's really, knows what she's talking about."
Lauer: "Good for
She hasn’t "done too well" with the national
Tuesday night Tom Brokaw introduced the last story on
NBC Nightly News: "John McCain and Bill Bradley have spent a lot of time
in this election year talking about campaign finance reform, but it turns out
there are rookies on the subject. A ninety-year-old grandmother has spent the
last year walking and talking about just that -- all across the country,
Bob Dotson, as transcribed by MRC analyst Brad Wilmouth,
began: "A ninety-year-old striding into Washington today leading an army
of reformers. Doris Haddock has been gathering this crowd from Los Angeles to
Washington, walking 3,000 miles on arthritic legs, determined to stop big
business and unions from donating to political parties."
Dotson added: "Haddock, a retired secretary, hopes
her hike across America might change that. It’s why she started this trek --
to leave her twelve great grandchildren what she calls a ‘better
After recounting some problems she had along the way,
Dotson oozed about how "Haddock has felt the nation hugging her
shoulders, shaking her hands, cheering her along." He concluded by
glowing: "Her trek has not changed the way campaigns are financed, but
Doris Haddock does see growing support. Most of us only witness history. She
went out and made it."
With the help of a media enthused about her cause.
++ See Katie Couric’s love-in with Granny D. On
Wednesday MRC Webmaster Andy Szul will post, in a RealPlayer format, a clip of
the Today interview. Go to: http://archive.mrc.org
bus. John McCain spent weeks on his so-called "Straight Talk
Express" bus talking to reporters who attributed his positive press to
this level of open access. But apparently the reporters spent more time
exchanging jokes and stories with McCain than posing tough questions. Or, so
it seems, ABC’s Cokie Roberts let slip on Monday’s Charlie Rose show on
She appeared with her husband, Steve Roberts, to plug
their new book about marriage, From This Day Forward, but Rose soon steered
the conversion on the February 28 show toward the campaign. He asked about the
press tilt in favor of McCain, leading Cokie Roberts to bring up McCain’s
appearance the day before on ABC’s This Week:
"Yesterday I think
he felt that it was not terribly pleasant."
Rose: "What did
you say to him that you thought was so unpleasant?"
Roberts: "No, we
were just asking tough questions and I think he’s gotten out of the
Surrounded by reporters all day for two months and no
tough questions. Amazing.