Clinton as Ray’s Victim; Rather Avoided What Clinton Conceded; Gumbel Scolded Ronnie White for Being Too Nice; Clinton’s Chair
1) Dan Rather was impressed by
how Al Gore’s post-election behavior "told us much about his
character." NBC’s post-Inaugural ceremony coverage focused on
Clinton with eight liberal/Democratic guests compared to just one guest
favorable toward Bush.
2) ABC’s George Stephanopoulos pushed Bush left:
"He’ll be able to fulfill that central promise of unifying the
country only if he’s willing to compromise on some of the big
issues."
3) ABC painted Clinton as a victim of an independent
counsel who forced him into a deal. Charles Gibson wanted to know why
"did the special prosecutor insist upon" the deal being made on
Clinton’s last day in office. Peter Jennings empathized: "It’s
been a very difficult last 24 hours for him, having to make a deal with
the independent counsel..."
4) In a 106 word introduction of Friday’s lead story,
CBS’s Dan Rather didn’t mention how Clinton had conceded giving
"false" answers. Instead, Rather adopted the Clinton spin as he
referred to "a plea arrangement to avoid any possible prosecution or
disbarment in two sex cases." FNC’s Jim Angle called it "the
political equivalent of a deathbed confession."
5) Three unrelated quotes of note: Cokie Roberts declared
she does "not want" Jesse Jackson’s "voice silenced"
since "he’s an important voice"; Time’s Jack White adjudged
"John Ashcroft came across as a major league liar"; and Barbara
Walters wished "to hang around long enough to interview the first
woman President."
6) Bryant Gumbel found Ronnie White too timid in taking on
John Ashcroft. "You liken your appearance yesterday to when you stood
up to racist bullies at the age of ten, yet you said you don't believe
Senator Ashcroft is a racist, why?" And: "What do you think
Senator Ashcroft's distortion of your record and tarnishing of your good
name says about his character?"
7) Read this one. It’s too good to miss but I don’t
want to give away the new revelation about Clinton’s chair, a disclosure
buried on Friday’s 20/20. Imagine Clinton sitting in his chair as Monica
did her thing. And now add this element....
1
Some
observations from live Inaugural coverage: Dan Rather was impressed by how
Al Gore’s post-election behavior "told us much about his
character," NBC’s Maria Shriver wanted to know what Bush would do
"to reach out to the millions of people who felt disenfranchised by
this election, who don’t feel that he’s their President yet?" And
it was hard to tell by NBC’s coverage that a Republican had become
President since the network’s coverage focused on Clinton with eight
liberal/Democratic guests after Bush’s speech compared to just one guest
favorable toward Bush.
-- CBS News. As Gore walked onto the Inaugural
platform the CBS crew discussed how he believes he really won the
election. Bob Schieffer oozed: "I think Dan he was no more gracious
at any point in the campaign than the night when he conceded the
election." Dan Rather agreed:
"Well, he’s been very gracious since then. If, as many people
argue, the mark of a man, or a woman, is how well they handle adversity,
then one can say that Al Gore told us much about his character in these
weeks, now more than a month, since he was declared the loser."
-- NBC News. Before the ceremony began, from the
platform Maria Shriver, whom NBC parachutes in for all big events,
demanded of about-to-become National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice:
"What does he have to accomplish here today to reach out to the
millions of people who felt disenfranchised by this election, who don’t
feel that he’s their President yet?"
Before and after the ceremony liberal historian
Doris Kearns Goodwin was unavoidable on NBC News, but afterward she was
joined by a coterie of liberals, the MRC’s Tim Graham noticed.
Immediately after Bush’s speech, Andrea Mitchell talked to lawyer Ted Olson about it, but he was the last
Republican to appear for the next hour.
In addition to former Clinton operative David Gergen,
between 12:30 and 1:30pm ET, when NBC’s Washington, DC station cut away
for local coverage, NBC News viewers heard:
> Maria Shriver
interview Democratic Senators John Kerry and Bob Graham.
> Tom Brokaw
interview Hugh Price of the Urban League, who he claimed is "known as
a moderate leader in the African-American community," and Eugene
Rivers of the Ten Point Foundation.
> Brokaw with
Paul Begala.
> David Bloom at
Andrews Air Force Base covering Clinton talk with Terry McAuliffe.
> Brokaw bring
aboard Democratic Senator Bob Kerrey to assess Clinton.
> Brokaw
interview, inside NBC’s Capital Hill studio, Clinton biographer David
Maraniss and Clinton team lawyer Greg Craig.
NBC was as much enthralled with Bill Clinton as Bill
Clinton is enthralled with himself.
2
ABC
political analyst George Stephanopoulos pushed Bush to add a "fifth
C," compromise: "He’ll be able to fulfill that central promise
of unifying the country only if he’s willing to compromise on some of
the big issues."
On Saturday’s World News Tonight Stephanopoulos
argued: "You heard the four Cs there: civility, courage, character
and compassion. What you didn’t see was a fifth C: compromise. With a
50-50 Senate and a tiny margin in the House and a majority in the country
who actually voted against President Bush he’ll be able to fulfill that
central promise of unifying the country only if he’s willing to
compromise on some of the big issues: education, health care, tax cuts.
We’ll see if he’s willing to do that in the coming days."
Stephanopoulos repeated a similar formulation on
Sunday’s This Week.
3
Clinton
as victim. Saturday morning ABC’s Charles Gibson and Peter Jennings,
instead of proclaiming how Bill Clinton had finally conceded that he had
lied, treated Bill Clinton as a victim of the independent counsel.
As Clinton sat down on the Inaugural platform at
about 11:40am ET Jennings empathized: "It’s been a very difficult
last 24 hours for him, having to make a deal with the independent counsel
in order to have the investigation of his honesty regarding Monica
Lewinsky go away, at least go away legally."
Earlier, at the start of a special Saturday Good
Morning America, Charles Gibson asked outgoing White House chief of staff
John Podesta: "The last day, the last full day Friday, the specter of
scandal raised again because the President signed an agreement with the
special prosecutor saying he knowingly gave false and misleading answers
in the Lewinsky matter and accepted some punishments. I’m curious about
the timing of all this, John. Why did it come on the last day? Did the
special prosecutor insist upon that?"
Podesta agreed that Robert Ray pushed for the deal
so "we weren’t in complete control of that." Reminiscent of
the standard Clinton spin, Podesta maintained that Clinton just wanted to
move on to do good things for the country as an ex-President. But Gibson
was only interested in discrediting Ray, as he followed up by assuming Ray
had done wrong: "But doesn’t the timing bother you? I mean it gives
you the specter of this right at the end."
4
What did
Bill Clinton admit that he did? You wouldn’t really know if you relied
Friday night on CBS’s Dan Rather. In his 106 word introductory set up to
the show’s lead story he didn’t bother mention, as did ABC’s Peter
Jennings and NBC’s Tom Brokaw, how Clinton conceded giving
"false" answers. Rather referred only to "a plea
arrangement to avoid any possible prosecution or disbarment in two sex
cases." The Clinton spin from Rather up to the last night.
But none labeled Clinton a liar, nor were they as
blunt as FNC’s Jim Angle, who on Friday’s Special Report with Brit
Hume laid out the reality, calling the deal "the political equivalent
of a deathbed confession. Mr. Clinton only made this deal with Ray when he
learned from the independent counsel that he was facing certain indictment
and, very likely, disbarment in Arkansas. Faced with that, he finally
decided to strike a deal. He was given until his last day in office. He
took it right up until the last full day in office."
Rather opened the January 19 CBS Evening News:
"Good evening. Once again there has never been anything like this in
American history. A dramatic close today to the Clinton presidency: a plea
arrangement to avoid any possible prosecution or disbarment in two sex
cases. And it shook up this capital city just as it's preparing for the
inauguration of a new President, George W. Bush, making one final round of
appearances today before he takes office at noon tomorrow. We'll have much
more about the inauguration in a moment. But first, CBS News correspondent
John Roberts at the White House has details of the Clinton deal with the
independent counsel and what it means."
Only well into the report by Roberts did viewers
finally learn that three years after the "deposition in the Paula
Jones case, President Clinton for the first time today admitted that
testimony he gave regarding his relationship with Monica Lewinsky was
knowingly evasive and misleading....Mr. Clinton today offered this finely
parsed public contrition: 'I tried to walk a line between acting lawfully
and testifying falsely,' he said. 'But I now recognize that I did not
fully accomplish this goal, and that certain of my responses to questions
about Ms. Lewinsky were false.'"
ABC’s Peter Jennings delayed the lead a bit but he
did stress how Clinton "finally admitted that he didn't tell the
truth under oath." Jennings opened World News Tonight:
"Good evening.
This would have been a big day in Washington under any circumstances. The
last night in the White House for President Clinton and his family, the
eve of another Bush era. The first son to follow a father into the White
House since the 1820s. And yet this day will surely be remembered because
Bill Clinton finally admitted that he didn't tell the truth under oath
about Monica Lewinsky. The scandal pursues him to the end. Mr. Clinton and
the independent counsel Bob Ray have finally made a deal. Mr. Clinton owns
up and he doesn't get indicted, though there are consequences."
NBC’s Tom Brokaw opened the NBC Nightly News:
"President Clinton, who became a one-man legal, moral and ethical
melodrama during his final term, will not be indicted once he leaves
office but he will pay a price. In an agreement worked out by his lawyer
with the special prosecutor, the President will lose his law license for
five years, pay a fine, and he had to issue a statement acknowledging that
he knowingly gave false answers. All of this on the eve of the
inauguration of George W. Bush who was eager to have this matter finished
before he took office."
5
Three
unrelated quotes of note from the weekend: ABC’s Cokie Roberts declared
she does "not want" Jesse Jackson’s "voice silenced"
since "he’s an important voice in public debate"; Time’s
Jack White adjudged "John Ashcroft came across as a major league
liar"; and Barbara Walters wished "to hang around long enough to
interview the first woman President."
-- ABC’s Cokie Roberts, during the This Week
roundtable, on Jesse Jackson conceding he has a "love child":
"Obviously this is something he is feeling shame about and should,
but I do not want to have his voice silenced in public debate. I think
he’s an important voice in public debate and I think that having it now
lose some authority is too bad."
I guess she was sorry there weren’t more anti-Bush
demonstrators on Saturday.
-- Time magazine national correspondent Jack White
on Saturday’s post-Inaugural taped Inside Washington: "John
Ashcroft came across as a major league liar. He lied about the Missouri
school desegregation case that he was involved in, he lied about not
knowing about the policies, the racial policies of Bob Jones University,
he has lied about not knowing what kind of magazine Southern Partisan is,
that he gave a terrible interview to. And he’s lied about any number of
other things. If people were concerned about a lack of honesty in the
previous administration, why are they perpetrating it in this
administration?"
-- Barbara Walters wrapped up Friday’s 20/20,
which featured her interviews with George and Laura Bush: "Well
that’s our program tonight, except for this parting thought. I realize
that George W. Bush is the seventh President I have interviewed, starting
with Richard Nixon. And I hope to hang around long enough to interview the
first woman President, whoever she may be."
2005 is less just four years away for President
Rodham.
6
Missouri
state Supreme Court judge Ronnie White was not sufficiently aggressive for
Bryant Gumbel in denouncing John Ashcroft. On Friday’s The Early Show,
the morning after White testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee,
Gumbel pressed him about why he did not call for the Senate to reject
Ashcroft. Gumbel assumed Ashcroft was guilty of bad behavior: "What
do you think Senator Ashcroft's distortion of your record and tarnishing
of your good name says about his character?"
The same question could be posed many mornings to
Gumbel.
Gumbel seemed bewildered: "You liken your
appearance yesterday to when you stood up to racist bullies at the age of
ten, yet you said you don't believe Senator Ashcroft is a racist,
why?"
MRC analyst Brian Boyd took down part of the January
19 exchange. Here are Gumbel’s questions and some of White’s answers
when needed to put Gumbel’s retorts in context:
-- "On this morning after how do you feel about
your appearance before the Judiciary Committee?"
-- "Do you feel
vindicated for what you were denied two years ago?"
-- "Did it feel
funny to sit there before Senators like Strom Thurmond, Orrin Hatch, who
had been a part of voting you down in the full Senate two years ago?"
-- "To the
surprise of many you never explicitly or directly objected to Senator
Ashcroft's nomination for Attorney General, why not?"
-- "What do you think Senator Ashcroft's
distortion of your record and tarnishing of your good name says about his
character?"
White: "See
that gets very close to my saying that he should either be fit or unfit
for U. S. Attorney General. But I do think I could give information about
how he labeled me as pro-criminal, having a criminal bent, having a
criminal slant, and also talking about how I was soft on crime when the
numbers surely didn't show that."
Gumbel: "So he
falsely labeled?"
White:
"Right."
Gumbel: "It was
a distortion?"
White: "It was
a distortion."
Gumbel: "Was it
a lie?"
White: "I think
it was less than truthful. [Gumbel laughs] Part of the problem that
Senator Ashcroft and I had is the name calling and I've resisted the
temptation to engage in that, Bryant."
-- "You certainly have. You liken your
appearance yesterday to when you stood up to racist bullies at the age of
ten, yet you said you don't believe Senator Ashcroft is a racist,
why?"
-- "How do you
think or hope Senator Ashcroft heard your testimony yesterday?"
-- "If as seems
likely, Senator Ashcroft is confirmed, again we're getting close to that
line you don't want to cross, I understand that, what do you think he will
do from his position as Attorney General?"
-- "You could still, and correct me if I'm
wrong here, you could still be re-nominated for the federal bench couldn't
you?"
White: "I could
be re-nominated by President Clinton up until tomorrow afternoon, or which
is probably unlikely, I could be nominated by President-elect Bush."
Gumbel: "You
think unlikely, you think in light of your testimony yesterday and in
light of past errors that Senator Ashcroft may now be aware of that it's
unlikely?"
White: "I
really don't know, Bryant. That would cause me to speculate on something
that I just don't know."
-- Gumbel: "Final note, not that he will or
would but if former Senator Ashcroft offered his apology to you would you
accept it?"
White: "Sure, I think
that would go a long way to ending this rift between us. Here in Missouri
we all know each other and even though we're on opposite sides of issues
it's sort of like a small family and that would help."
Gumbel: "Your
Show Me State, you showed them something yesterday."
Nice of Gumbel to cheer
on the anti-conservative team.
7
Now an
exchange that came without warning during a seemingly innocuous feature
story on Friday’s 20/20 which recounted anecdotes from White House
photographers about how previous Presidents spent their last day in the
White House. (The report was from ABC’s Tom Jarriel, though I can’t
recall if it’s spelled Jarriel or Jariel.)
We pick up his story as he described how the Oval
Office was transformed for Clinton on the afternoon of January 20, 1993.
Jarriel: "The desk Clinton has selected is put
in place. New drapes are hung. The new President’s chair arrives,
transported from Arkansas with Clinton’s own comfort features."
Over a shot of the chair,
White House photographer Pete Souza disclosed: "It’s a vibrating
chair."
Jarriel:
"Clinton has a vibrating chair?"
Souza: "Well he
did when he first came into office. I don’t know if it, if it stayed
throughout his presidency or not."
Jarriel then moved on.
I sure hope George W. Bush got a new chair.