Donít Let Patriotism Mar Olympics; NBC: Women Good, Men Bad; No Snow?: Global Warming; CNN Off Track on Amtrak; Alterís Obsession
1) Donít have much U.S. patriotism at the Olympics.
NBCís Matt Lauer pressed the President of the U.S. Olympic Committee to
agree: "We have to also be careful and draw a line not to let our
patriotism get in the way of the games in general."
2) "New York Times columnist Maureen Dowd hit on a
simple truth today," NBC anchor Tom Brokaw trumpeted Wednesday night
in devoting a story to her theme that in Enron "the dividing line
between those who appear to be in the wrong and those trying to stop
them" is "very clear. Most of the wrongdoers are men. Most of
the whistle-blowers are women."
3) A New York Times reporter described Finlandís 59
percent income tax rate, "even on lower income brackets," as
merely "relatively steep."
4) When Bryant Gumbel complained on the Early Show:
"We never get any snow," Mark McEwen suggested: "Do you
think it's global warming?" Gumbel enthusiastically agreed:
5) CNNís free ad for Amtrakís speed. CNNís Michael
Okwu recounted how it took him about the same three hours to travel
between CNN bureaus in Manhattan and Washington, DC on both Amtrak and the
Delta Shuttle as he gushed that Amtrak cost $100 less. But it sure helped
Amtrak that in both cities CNNís office is literally across the street
from the train station.
6) Newsweek reporter Jonathan Alter scolded Don Imus for
not questioning MRC President Brent Bozell over the failure of Bozellís
"little newsletter" to have denounced Jerry Falwell for an
intemperate post-September 11 remark. But in his obsession, Alter was
wrong in every charge he made about the MRCís newsletter.
7) Novelist Norman Mailer told the BBC the U.S. is
"living a halfway corrupt life." Mailer lamented to the London
Telegraph that "this patriotic fever can go too far," rued how
"America has an almost obscene infatuation with itself" and
asserted: "The right wing benefitted so much from September 11 that,
if I were still a conspiratorialist, I would believe they'd done it."
let our patriotism get in the way of" the Olympic games, NBCís Matt
Lauer cautioned on Thursdayís Today from Park City Utah, site of the
games set to open tonight. Lauer pressed the President of the U.S. Olympic
Committee to agree with his proposition: "We have to also be careful
and draw a line not to let our patriotism get in the way of the games in
MRC analyst Geoffrey Dickens caught this
exchange on the February 7 Today:
Lauer: "You are expecting even a greater
wave of patriotism here in the United States, in this particular time than
other countries have shown when they've hosted the games."
U.S. Olympic Committee President: "Well, you know, I don't know than
other countries but I, I certainly expect the stands to be rocking. I
expect the flags to be flying. And you know the expression of patriotism
is fine for any country that, that hosts the Olympics. We want to express
our nationalism as a part of the world's community and I expect to see
"But we have to also be careful and draw a line not to let our
patriotism get in the way of the games in general."
"Absolutely. It is supporting the athletes from around the world with
a particular emphasis on the U.S. athletes."
front page of the New York Times sets the news agenda for all of the
networks, but on Wednesday night NBC Nightly News took its cue not from a
Times news story on the front page or somewhere inside the paper, but from
a columnist. NBC devoted an entire story to the theme behind Maureen
Dowdís column on Enron which, as anchor Tom Brokaw endorsed it,
"hit on a simple truth today. The dividing line between those who
appear to be in the wrong and those trying to stop them. It's very clear.
Most of the wrongdoers are men. Most of the whistle-blowers are
Most, but not all.
Brokaw introduced the February 6 story on how
one sex has proven itself superior: "This unfolding Enron mess can be
difficult to follow. Even financial experts are baffled by how complicated
it is. But New York Times columnist Maureen Dowd hit on a simple truth
today. The dividing line between those who appear to be in the wrong and
those trying to stop them. It's very clear. Most of the wrongdoers are
men. Most of the whistle-blowers are women. NBC's Jim Avila from Houston
tonight on the Enron gender gap."
Avila outlined the
thesis: "The boys of Enron: grandfatherly Ken Lay, dot-comer Jeff
Skilling, financial wizard Andy Fastow and Andersen fall guy David Duncan,
the accountant who signed off on it all. Backed by a board of directors,
one woman shy of all male, now being fitted for Hollywood black
Prof. Garth Jowett, University of Houston: "Mr. Lay, rightly or wrongly in the
national media, is now being portrayed as the kind of chief robber
"The perfect Hollywood twist, the boys of Enron exposed by women.
From Bethany McClean, the first reporter to ask in Fortune magazine, 'Is
Enron stock overvalued?'"
Bethany McClean: "I'm innately skeptical, and especially of high-priced
"And in the lead whistle-blower role, Enron Vice President Sherron
Watkins, already depicted as a hero in the media despite refusing to grant
any interviews. People and Time magazine running photo spreads. Today's
Maureen Dowd column in the New York Times lauding her as the natural star
of the Enron movie. Her co-workers agree."
Williams, former Enron employee: "She is a hero in my, in my
"Supporting players all women, too. Maureen Castaneda, preparing to
move, accidentally discovered Enron's shredded documents."
Castaneda: "I thought the shredded material would be good packing
"Experts say Enron's gender gap is no coincidence. It's not that
women are necessarily more honest, but in today's corporate world have a
better view than ever before of what the real decision makers are
Prof. Hilarie Lieb, Northwestern University: "They could share this information
because they had access to this information, and it wasn't that long ago
that that wasn't the case."
"Hollywood is watching Enron carefully. A story writing itself every
day, combining heroes and villains in classic fashion. Michael Shamberg
produced 'Erin Brockovich.'"
Michael Shamberg: "I'd want to find both. I'd want to find the heroic person
as well as the bad guy, because it's sort of like a dance, and you need
concluded: "And in Texas today it's the women of Enron wearing all
the white hats."
But NBCís story was no more accurate than
the Erin Brockovich movie.
Thursdayís newspapers carried a preview of
congressional testimony to be delivered on Thursday by Enron lawyer Jordan
Mintz, a man, who maintains that he warned of financial shenanigans last
May, three months earlier than Sherron Watkins wrote her memo.
Washington Post reporters Susan Schmidt and
Peter Behr began a February 7, 2002 story: "A senior Enron Corp.
lawyer raised red flags more than a year ago about the corporation's
approval of supposedly arm's-length deals with partnerships managed by
Enron insiders, new documents show. He has told House investigators he was
lawyer, Jordan Mintz, also tried unsuccessfully last May to get then-Enron
chief executive Jeffrey K. Skilling to sign a series of approval sheets on
investments the Houston energy trader made with the partnerships in
The Post reporters elaborated: "Rep.
James C. Greenwood (R-Pa.), chairman of the [Energy Committeeís]
oversight and investigations subcommittee, said last night that the Mintz
memos tell more about the thinking of senior Enron executives than the
scathing internal report a special committee of Enron's board of directors
issued over the weekend. ĎI think this goes to state of mind,í he
Mintz had issued warnings more than a year
ago: "Mintz raised concerns about the partnerships that Fastow ran in
December 2000 in a memo to Causey and Buy about a proposed new entity
called LJM3, which was never formed. In another memo to the same two
officials last March, he recommended changes in the approval process for
deals between Enron and existing LJM partnerships."
of the New York Times, in a February 6 story an overseas reporter for the
newspaper described Finlandís 59 percent income tax rate, "even on
lower income brackets," as "relatively steep." One wonders
how high a tax rate would have to be for the Times to consider it just
The MRCís Tim Jones caught the description
deep in a story headlined, "Not in Finland Anymore? More Like
Nokialand." Reporter Alan Cowell in Helsinki, Finland looked at the
influence of Nokia, which employs 22,000 in Finland.
Cowell wrote: "Indeed, all Finland
listened in recent days when Jorma Ollila, Nokia's chairman and chief
executive, not only confirmed that growth had slowed last year, but also
wondered aloud about lowering Finland's relatively steep income-tax rate
(59 percent even on lower income brackets)."
Cowell rued: "In those comments, Finns
heard an executive whom they feared may be ready to pull out of the
country, jeopardizing the tax base that supports the state's extensive
welfare benefits. About 22,000 of Nokia's 54,000 employees worldwide are
in Finland -- but they include 11,000 of its main research and development
staff, as well as the top management who could work wherever the company
chooses to have its headquarters. Another 20,000 people are estimated to
work for companies that depend on Nokia for contracts."
For the story in full, those registered with
the New York Times can access it by going to: http://www.nytimes.com/2002/02/06/international/europe/06NOKI.html
Early Show crew all agreed on Wednesday morning that global warming is to
blame for the lack of snow in New York City.
MRC analyst Brian Boyd caught this exchange
during the 8:30am weather update on February 6:
Mark McEwen: "Up and down the East coast,
it's coming our way but we will probably see just rain in the big
complained: "We never get any snow."
"Do you think it's global warming?"
"Do you, Jane?"
"We're unanimous, we all think it's global warming."
Unanimously shortsighted. When temperatures
plunge one day to below zero will they worry about global cooling?
off track tribute to Amtrakís speed and efficiency. In a story aired
several times during the day on Thursday, CNNís Michael Okwu recounted
his experiment of comparing travel time between New York City and
Washington, DC on Amtrak versus the Delta Shuttle. Arriving at CNNís
Washington bureau via Amtrak in three hours, Okwu proclaimed: "Almost
the exact amount that it took us to leave from New York to get to
Washington, D.C. [via airplane], except we did it on the train for about
But while Okwu noted that on each end of the
trip it only took him five minutes to walk to the train station, he failed
to factor the very Amtrak-friendly locations of CNNís bureaus into his
evaluation. The CNN Washington bureau (at 820 First St. NE) is literally
across the street from Union Station and its New York bureau (5 Penn
Plaza) is in a building across the street from Penn Station in lower
While it certainly is true that having train
stations downtown, as opposed to airports in Queens and Arlington County,
Virginia, reduces travel time from the stations to a meeting at a
Manhattan or downtown DC office, most people do not leave to catch a train
from next door to the train station or have their destination across the
On CNNís American Morning, tri-host Jack
Cafferty set up CNNís experiment: "One of the most popular [Amtrak]
lines is the so-called ĎNortheast Corridor,í train service that
connects Boston with New York, with Washington, D.C. But now with the
planes flying again, which is better, the train or the plane? Our Michael
Okwu did a little comparison shopping."
Okwu recounted, as MRC analyst Ken Shepherd
checked the transcripts against the tape, how his day started at CNN
Manhattan bureau: "It's about 8 right now. We're hoping to make the
9:30 Delta shuttle, which should take us about -- I'd say, about, 20 to 25
minutes to get there, and we should be on our way. I'm pretty lucky,
rarely do I get a cab this fast, at this hour. The shuttle leaves from
LaGuardia, the closest airport to midtown Manhattan. Today, traffic is a
breeze. I reach the airport at 8:26. Well, that cost me about $20, with
tip. We're now about to make our 9:30 shuttle. And we got here in about 25
minutes. Let's hope that we can get into the airport and not have to face
too much security." As usual, I have an e-ticket waiting inside. A
five-minute wait in line, a quick check of the itinerary, and then the
usual questions -- was my bag with me at all times? Yes. The ticket costs
$205. The security is priceless. Our plane takes off 20 minutes late
because airline staff conducted random baggage and body searches at the
gate. It's 10:34."
Okwu questioned a passenger as they walked
inside Reagan National Airport in Virginia: "This fellow was on the
flight with me. Why do you take the plane instead of the train?"
Man: "It's faster. It's a lot faster."
Okwu cast doubt: "It's faster? It's much
Man: "It may be pricier, but I'm a corporate
traveler, so I want to get there as quickly as I can."
Okwu confirmed: "He's right. The plane's
pricier, but faster? We'll see. I arrive at the CNN offices at 10:55. From
the time I hailed the cab in New York, it's taken about three hours."
Fast forwarding to the afternoon, Okwu picked
up his story: "Our business is done in the Washington bureau, and now
I'm trying to make a 2:00 Acela Express on Amtrak back to New York.
Luckily, Union Station is just a five-minute walk from the bureau."
A pleased Okwu noted: "After a two-minute
wait, I pick up my ticket for Amtrak's new high-speed train. Cost, $145,
$60 cheaper than the plane ticket."
Okwu allowed a woman on the train to complain:
"The one thing that, I'll be honest with you, that troubles me, is
the lack of security on the train. Nobody checked my bags, no metal
reassured: "Amtrak says it spent more than $16 million this year on
security, much of it behind the scenes on train yards, bridges, tunnels,
plainclothes police. This traveler occasionally takes a morning flight to
take the 6am shuttle from National Airport, commute from my home, get
there the requisite number of hours beforehand doesn't save me anytime at
"We arrive at New York's Penn Station at 4:48pm. So now it is almost
5, and the CNN bureau is about a five-minute walk away from here. So that
means that it took us about three hours to get from Washington, D.C. to
New York City's midtown, almost the exact amount that it took us to leave
from New York to get to Washington, D.C., except we did it on the train
for about $100 less."
Now try the same trips assuming Okwu worked
for NBC News instead of CNN. Getting to LaGuardia from Rockefeller Plaza
would probably take the same amount of time, maybe a little less, and it
would take a bit longer for a cab ride from Reagan National Airport to
NBCís bureau on Nebraska Avenue. But the return trip on Amtrak would
take much longer. First, heíd have to get across DC from Nebraska Avenue
to Union Station and that would take a lot more than five minutes. More
like a good 30 via cab. Second, on the New York end, heíd have to make
his way through about 15 blocks of late afternoon Manhattan traffic from
Penn Station at 34th Street to Rockefeller Plaza up at 48th Street. And if
he worked for ABC News on West 66th Street, that would be about a 40 block
obsession. Appearing on MSNBCís simulcast of the Imus in the Morning
radio show on Wednesday, Newsweek reporter Jonathan Alter scolded Imus for
not questioning MRC President Brent Bozell, who appeared earlier in the
show, over the failure of Bozellís "little newsletter" to have
castigated Jerry Falwell for an intemperate post-September 11 remark.
But in his obsession with something which
occurred four months ago, Alter was wrong about every charge he made.
On the February 6 show, Alter whined to Don
Imus: "I have a problem with the questioning of Brent, in this
context. He did one of his little newsletters about all the people who he
thought were engaged in Blame America First thinking about 9-11. And it
was a good effort by him because there were some people who their first
reaction in September and October was Ďthis is our fault, we had this
coming.í It made me pretty sick to read it as well. But offender number
one was Jerry Falwell. Remember that?"
"And in his newsletter, you know, he goes after Tom Brokaw and Peter
Jennings and me and lots and lots of other people for various offenses.
And heís got this particular ĎBlame America Firstí category. Who is
missing? Jerry Falwell, because he swings from the right side of the
Where to begin with Alterís errors? Let me
First, the MRC never published a "Blame
America First" newsletter. He was referring to the October 1 edition
of Notable Quotables, titled "Terrorist Attack on America." The
subtitle, "Media Coverage: The
Good, the Bad, and the Ugly."
Second, the issue did not contain any quote
from Peter Jennings. It did feature a quote from Tom Brokaw -- but in
"the Good" category. In fact, far from somehow impugning
Jennings, last October the MRC published a Media Reality Check documenting
how some had mis-reported what he said on September 11.
Third, at the top of every NQ the MRC
describes it as "a bi-weekly compilation of the latest outrageous,
sometimes humorous, quotes in the liberal media" -- not in the
As noted in the December 18 CyberAlert after
Alter denounced the MRC on MSNBC.com for not castigating Falwell:
"Jesse Jackson, many left-wing professors and some far-left
politicians also made some pretty stupid comments, but we didnít quote
them either because they are not in the mainstream media. And, unlike
Sontag, are not part of New Yorkís literary community given a forum in
an establishment magazine or, unlike Maher, do not host a broadcast
network show dealing with politics. The 700 Club doesnít pretend to be
an unbiased news show so the MRC does not monitor it, just as we never
quoted what Jackson said on his old CNN show since we were able to
differentiate it from the rest of the CNN schedule. But Iím sure this is
obvious to everyone but Alter."
Indeed, following Alterís reasoning the MRC
should criticize Alter for not quoting Katie Couric in a story on
congressional reaction to Bushís State of the Union address.
To read all the quotes in the MRCís special
October 1 four-page edition of Notable Quotables, "Terrorist Attack
on America. Media Coverage: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly," go to: http://archive.mrc.org/notablequotables/2001/nq20011001.asp
To access the Adobe Acrobat PDF of the hard
copy version, go to:
To read Alterís December 14 MSNBC piece, go
actual case of blaming America first. Novelist Norman Mailer denounced
President Bushís "axis of evil" line, telling the BBC
"that is opposed to a wake-up call, that's an anodyne." Mailer,
who lives on Cape Cod, claimed the U.S. is "living a halfway corrupt
life...in terms of world affairs and economics," so "if you are
half evil, nothing soothes you more than to think that the person you are
opposed to is totally evil."
Talking to a London Telegraph reporter, Mailer
lamented how "this patriotic fever can go too far," and bemoaned
how "America has an almost obscene infatuation with itself."
Mailer asserted: "The right wing benefitted so much from September 11
that, if I were still a conspiratorialist, I would believe they'd done
In the past couple of days both
OpinionJournal.comís "Best of the Web" and FNCís Brit Hume
have cited some of Mailerís latest screeds, but below is the worst of
the worst from his two interviews.
-- A February 4 BBC Newsnight interview with
Kristy Wark (sounds like the name of a character on Star Trek). Wark asked
about Bushís "axis of evil." Mailer propounded:
make a speech without using the word Ďevilí 13 or 15 or 22 times. But
where is the evil? They can't even locate Osama Bin Laden? They don't know
if he is alive or dead. Fighting evil is a way of dulling people's minds.
It's as if in America, because we have so few roots, an Israeli in
America, you can find the place where they were born. They even redid the
hospital where the person was born, because we rebuild and rebuild, and we
make things uglier and uglier every time we rebuild. Given that, there are
no roots, compared to European countries we have very few roots. You need
something to believe, and patriotism becomes it."
"Finally, do you think that America has had a wake-up call about how
others in the world view America?"
"Probably not, so long as they keep saying, "Evil, evil,
evil". That is opposed to a wake-up call, that's an anodyne. It's to
soothe feelings here. If you are going along and you are living a halfway
corrupt life, as certainly America has been doing in terms of world
affairs and economics. I don't have to bring in Enron to make my point,
then, if you are half evil, nothing soothes you more than to think that
the person you are opposed to is totally evil. If the person you are
opposed to is half evil also, as indeed I am sure they are, then what you
have is the old human mix, which is full of complication, and every
question can keep you up all night. For that reason, the attempt in
America has been to close the wound quickly, and if it putrefies later,
some other doctor will take care of that."
For the complete transcript:
For a picture of Mailer:
-- An interview with Michael Sheldon in the
February 6 London Telegraph. An excerpt:
"What happened on September 11 was horrific, but this patriotic
fever can go too far," he says. "America has an almost obscene
infatuation with itself. Has there ever been a big, powerful country that
is as patriotic as America? And patriotic in the tinniest way, with so
much flag waving? You'd really think we were some poor little republic,
and that if one person lost his religion for one hour, the whole thing
would crumble. America is the real religion in this country."
These days, such talk will definitely start a fight in many American
cities, yet Mailer is not averse to throwing the first punch. With a
mischievous smile, he says: "The Right wing benefitted so much from
September 11 that, if I were still a conspiratorialist, I would believe
they'd done it."
Like Mark Twain before him, Mailer has a way of saying outrageous
things in a perfectly charming manner. At home, he is a congenial host who
never raises his voice, and who seems as warm and mellow as a lazy cat at
the fireside. To look at his beaming face, you would never suspect that he
is the same man who, in 1960, was committed for a short period to a mental
hospital after repeatedly stabbing the second of his six wives.
END of Excerpt
The entire article is online, but youíll
have to register with the Telegraph to read it:
I doubt that if he were alive today Mark Twain
would buy into Mailerís suggestion that the "right wing" has
improperly benefitted from September 11.