top
|
1. Nets Frame Partial-Birth Ruling Around Loss of 'Abortion Rights' The ABC, CBS and NBC evening newscasts on Tuesday night all ran full stories on the Supreme Court's 5-4 ruling upholding the Partial Birth Abortion Act, but while each included arguments from justices in the majority, featured a soundbite from pro-life lawyer Jay Sekulow and offered at least a brief description of the procedure, they all framed the stories in ways favorable to those on the losing side. All led into competing soundbites by putting abortion supporters on the side of "rights" -- describing "abortion rights supporters" versus "abortion opponents" -- characterized the ruling as imposing a further "restriction" on abortion instead of as expanding protection for the unborn, and creatively distanced themselves from the "partial-birth" abortion term. NBC's Chip Reid related that "abortion rights activists worry this may be only the start of a campaign to limit abortion rights." With "5-4 ruling upholds federal ban on so-called 'partial-birth abortion'" on screen, ABC anchor Charles Gibson brought in ideology as he announced that "the court's new conservative majority today upheld a nationwide ban on a controversial procedure, one that critics call 'partial-birth abortion.'" 2. GMA's Champion Scolds Viewers for Contributing to Global Warming On Wednesday's Good Morning America, Sam Champion, ABC's weatherman and liberal environmentalist, escalated his campaign to encourage Americans to fight global warming. In addition to lecturing viewers about their contribution to climate change, he, once again, engaged in identification bias. Champion's segment featured a representative from the Natural Resources Defense Council, a liberal environmental group. The organization's ideology, not surprisingly, went completely unmentioned. However, the weatherman began the piece by standing in front of a bank of televisions and scolding viewers for their energy output: "Did you know that even with the flip of a switch, we all contribute to global warming? Well, I know it sounds a little intense. But there are some small things you can do to change that, like paying attention to your carbon footprint...If you think you have nothing to do with global warming, think again. From the car you drive, to the house you live in, it all contributes to the problem." 3. Walters 'Sad' O'Donnell Concedes Gun Control Cause is 'Futile' ABC News correspondent Barbara Walters, on Wednesday's The View, revealed she's "sad" that Rosie O'Donnell has given up on passing tougher gun control laws. Praising O'Donnell for how "you're passionate, you care," Walters, who was not on Tuesday's show, fretted that "for me to hear you yesterday...numb, saying we're never going to get a gun control law, kind of giving up made me sad. I don't want to see you do that." On Tuesday, O'Donnell had regretted how despite the outrage over Columbine and the subsequent Million Mom March, "sensible gun legislation" didn't pass and so, in the wake of the Virginia Tech massacre, "I'm numb about it." She complained: "I think there will never be gun control in America. And I think having tried to fight it for five years of my life it was a futile attempt." Joy Behar wondered: "You throw up your hands hun?" O'Donnell: "I sort of do." On Wednesday's show, O'Donnell also took on FNC, charging it is "slanted and right biased" and delivers "right wing propaganda." Nets Frame Partial-Birth Ruling Around Loss of 'Abortion Rights' The ABC, CBS and NBC evening newscasts on Tuesday night all ran full stories on the Supreme Court's 5-4 ruling upholding the Partial Birth Abortion Act, but while each included arguments from justices in the majority, featured a soundbite from pro-life lawyer Jay Sekulow and offered at least a brief description of the procedure, they all framed the stories in ways favorable to those on the losing side. All led into competing soundbites by putting abortion supporters on the side of "rights" -- describing "abortion rights supporters" versus "abortion opponents" -- characterized the ruling as imposing a further "restriction" on abortion instead of as expanding protection for the unborn, and creatively distanced themselves from the "partial-birth" abortion term. ABC's Charles Gibson saw "a long-sought victory for abortion opponents" before Jan Crawford Greenburg fretted that "abortion rights activists were devastated." CBS's Wyatt Andrews highlighted how "abortion rights supporters bitterly protested" since "the ban is now the first abortion restriction ever approved with no exception for the health of the mother." NBC's Chip Reid related that "abortion rights activists worry this may be only the start of a campaign to limit abortion rights." "So-called" partial-birth hot potato: With "5-4 ruling upholds federal ban on so-called 'partial-birth abortion'" on screen, ABC anchor Gibson brought in ideology as he announced that "the court's new conservative majority today upheld a nationwide ban on a controversial procedure, one that critics call 'partial-birth abortion.'" Jan Crawford Greenburg cited how "the court said the government could ban a specific type of abortion procedure." Over on the CBS Evening News, Katie Couric referred to "a controversial late-term abortion procedure" and Wyatt Andrews reported on "what Congress called 'partial-birth abortions.'" NBC's Chip Reid asserted that the court "upheld a federal law banning a late-term abortion procedure that opponents call 'partial-birth abortion.'" [This item was posted Wednesday night on the MRC's blog, NewsBusters.org: newsbusters.org ] The ABC and CBS stories were the least balanced since, after giving about equal time to quotes from justices on both sides and advocates on each side, the two networks added another pro-partial-birth abortion perspective. ABC's Greenburg featured the view of an "abortion provider" and CBS's Andrews showcased a woman, whose baby would have suffered and died after birth, who had a partial-birth abortion and, in tears, declared: "It's wrong for this law to exist at all. Nobody could agonize over the decision more than my husband and I did." Transcripts of the three April 18 stories for which I made partial transcripts that Brad Wilmouth completed: . # ABC's World News. Charles Gibson, in opening teaser: "Abortion ban: The Supreme Court upholds a ban on the procedure known as 'partial-birth abortion,' its most sweeping decision since Roe v. Wade." With "5-4 ruling upholds federal ban on so-called 'partial-birth abortion'" on screen, Gibson set up the subsequent story: "Now to the Supreme Court and a very important decision on abortion. In a 5-4 landmark decision, the court's new conservative majority today upheld a nationwide ban on a controversial procedure, one that critics call 'partial-birth abortion.' It was a long-sought victory for abortion opponents. And it sets the stage for even more legal battles to come. ABC's Jan Crawford Greenburg joins us from the court tonight. Jan?"
Jan Crawford Greenburg: "Charlie, today's decision represents a seismic shift. For the first time since Roe versus Wade, the court said the government could ban a specific type of abortion procedure. And for the first time, it upheld an abortion law that did not contain an exception for a woman's health. Scores of women gathered at the Supreme Court to protest. Abortion rights activists were devastated."
Couric introduced the story: "Now to another big story tonight, a Supreme Court ruling on abortion. The justices, sharply divided, today upheld the new federal ban on a controversial late-term abortion procedure, a procedure opponents and the law itself refer to as 'partial-birth abortion.' In the 5-4 decision, Chief Justice Roberts and Associate Justices Scalia, Thomas, Alito and Kennedy all voted to uphold the ban. In the majority opinion, Justice Kennedy wrote that opponents of the ban 'have not demonstrated that the act imposes an undue burden on a woman's right to abortion.' We'll begin our coverage of this ruling with Wyatt Andrews."
Wyatt Andrews: "It's the first federal ban on any kind of abortion since the court established the right to an abortion in Roe vs. Wade. For abortion opponents, it's the biggest legal victory in 34 years."
Chip Reid: "Well, good evening, Brian. For the first time in the 34 years since Roe v. Wade, the Supreme Court today upheld a ban of a specific abortion procedure. Activists on both sides are calling the decision monumental. At the Supreme Court today, a stunning defeat for supporters of abortion rights."
GMA's Champion Scolds Viewers for Contributing to Global Warming On Wednesday's Good Morning America, Sam Champion, ABC's weatherman and liberal environmentalist, escalated his campaign to encourage Americans to fight global warming. In addition to lecturing viewers about their contribution to climate change, he, once again, engaged in identification bias. Champion's segment featured a representative from the Natural Resources Defense Council, a liberal environmental group. The organization's ideology, not surprisingly, went completely unmentioned. However, the weatherman began the piece by standing in front of a bank of televisions and scolding viewers for their energy output: "Did you know that even with the flip of a switch, we all contribute to global warming? Well, I know it sounds a little intense. But there are some small things you can do to change that, like paying attention to your carbon footprint...If you think you have nothing to do with global warming, think again. From the car you drive, to the house you live in, it all contributes to the problem." Champion didn't mention how much energy the television screens behind him were contributing to global warming. After introducing the piece, which aired at 8:35am on April 18, the ABC host segued into a discussion of carbon footprints, which is the sum total of an individual's energy output, and how one family, the Flanagans, have decided to reduce it. Allen Hershkowitz, a representative of the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) dropped by their house to instruct the Flanagan family on how to accomplish such a goal. [This item, by Scott Whitlock, was posted Wednesday on the MRC's blog, NewsBusters.org: newsbusters.org ] Champion made no mention of the group's extreme liberal agenda. (For instance, they have advocated arms control (see: www.nrdc.org ) and harshly complained that the Bush administration hasn't adopted left-wing solutions to global warming: http://www.nrdc.org/globalWarming/bushinx.asp )
Champion: "The average American household produces over 35,000 pounds of carbon dioxide each year. Added together, that's 20 percent of the greenhouse gases our entire country produces. Kristen and Kevin Flanagan wanted to reduce their part of those greenhouse gases. So they set out to calculate their family's carbon footprint. With six kids, it was a daunting task." Hershkowitz has been a strong proponent of using Hollywood to encourage Americans to adopt liberal environmental policies. Unsurprisingly, this is the same strategy that Sam Champion adopted: newsbusters.org The GMA weatherman closed the report by having Hershkowitz tour the Flanagan household and instruct them on how to fight global warming:
Allen Hershkowitz: "Automobiles contribute more carbon emissions than everything else in your home combined." Viewers shouldn't expect any break in the climate change advocacy. On Friday, April 20, GMA will use Earth Day to lobby for the cause of global warming fearmongering.
Walters 'Sad' O'Donnell Concedes Gun Control Cause is 'Futile' ABC News correspondent Barbara Walters, on Wednesday's The View, revealed she's "sad" that Rosie O'Donnell has given up on passing tougher gun control laws. Praising O'Donnell for how "you're passionate, you care," Walters, who was not on Tuesday's show, fretted that "for me to hear you yesterday...numb, saying we're never going to get a gun control law, kind of giving up made me sad. I don't want to see you do that." On Tuesday, O'Donnell had regretted how despite the outrage over Columbine and the subsequent Million Mom March, "sensible gun legislation" didn't pass and so, in the wake of the Virginia Tech massacre, "I'm numb about it." She complained: "I think there will never be gun control in America. And I think having tried to fight it for five years of my life it was a futile attempt." Joy Behar wondered: "You throw up your hands hun?" O'Donnell: "I sort of do." On Wednesday's show, O'Donnell also took on FNC. After Barbara Walters displayed the front page of the New York Post with a photo of Larry Birkhead and his son displayed above the Virginia Tech story, O'Donnell ranted about how Fox News and the New York Post are part of an agenda to distract the American people from what is really happening: "They have an agenda to make you not really interested in the real things in this country, but rather Dannielynn." Having no sense of irony that all four co-hosts on Wednesday's edition of The View were liberals, O'Donnell screamed that FNC is "slanted and right biased" and delivers "right wing propaganda." She even claimed FNC is "lying" when they say they're fair and balanced.
[A video clip of O'Donnell on Tuesday, April 17, regretting the futility of her battle for gun control will be added to the posted version of this CyberAlert. But in the meantime, to view the Real or Windows Media video or to listen to the MP3 audio, check a NewsBusters postings by Justin McCarthy: newsbusters.org ]
Rosie O'Donnell: "Well, and you know, since 1999, Columbine, what happened? All the mothers got together in America, we formed the Million Mom March. We marched on Washington, estimates of almost two million mothers there. We protested. We picketed against the NRA, and for the government to make sensible gun legislation. And what has happened since then? Nothing. Nothing. I'm shocked that I'm numb about it. I'm shocked that, you know, Columbine, which took me out at the knees, literally where I thought I would never recover and went on anti-depressants, I thought, I don't know how, I had a child like you do, I was your age with a baby, and the concept of sending them away to school from the nest of the dangers that lurk out there. But somehow this one, I'm almost numb to it. I think well, here we go again."
The former solo daytime host has been a long-time opponent of gun-rights, famously losing her reputation as the "Queen of Nice" after blowing up at actor Tom Selleck in 1999 over his support of the National Rifle Association. For a RealPlayer clip of that, check the May 21, 1999 CyberAlert: www.mediaresearch.org
On Wednesday's (April 18) show, Walters, who was not part of Tuesday's program, rued O'Donnell's disillusionment: Token non-liberal Elisabeth Hasselbeck was off for the day. Instead of a right-of-center substitute, guest co-host Aisha Tyler, clearly in the liberal camp, started swinging strong for gun control: "What's amazing to me is that the gun lobby is talking about, well, it's not legal guns that kill people, it's when people get guns illegally. But this is someone who bought a gun legally. It took them five minutes to run a background check. He had been committed to a mental hospital for two days for observation and that didn't pop up on his record. He was clearly to everyone around him mentally disturbed. And, it's not about, like you said, it's not about keeping guns out of the hands of hunters. But when a kid this upset, this out of it, can walk into and buy two guns and 50 rounds of bullets and nobody asks a question." Walters briefly mentioned the argument that if other students had guns, perhaps they could have defended themselves from harm. That argument was snidely dismissed by the panel.
Walters: "And now some of them are saying, if the students only had guns they could have defended-" Walters expressed hope that 2008 presidential candidates would fight for stronger gun control measures: "But maybe, maybe this will make a difference in, in, with the candidates. Maybe it will be part of what is their, their program along with healthcare, that platform. After Walters displayed the front page of the New York Post with a photo of Larry Birkhead and his son, Rosie ranted about how Fox News and the New York Post, both owned by Rupert Murdoch, are part of an agenda to distract the American people from what is really happening. Walters defended Fox News, noting they have done "around the clock" coverage of the Virginia Tech massacre. Having no sense of irony that all four co-hosts were liberal, Rosie interrupted screaming that FNC is "slanted and right biased" and "right wing propaganda." She even claimed Fox is "lying" when they say they're fair and balanced. Walters actually acknowledged that The View is "slanted in another way."
O'Donnell: "Right, but let's just say this: The New York Post is owned by Rupert Murdoch, who owns the Fox News channel. So, if you want to be distracted by what's really happening in Washington, pick up the Post or watch Fox News because they have an agenda to make you not really interested in the real things in this country, but rather Dannielynn."
-- Brent Baker
Home | News Division
| Bozell Columns | CyberAlerts |
|