"S" Word Avoided; CBS Says Public Doesn't Care; Shooting Tied to Reagan
1) Every network but ABC too
squeamish to tell viewers what Clinton supposedly left on Lewinsky's
dress. Euphemism central: "physical evidence," "DNA
evidence;" "stains" and "body fluids."
2) CBS argued no one cares
about Clinton's affair and most oppose impeachment no matter what, but
NBC sees danger for Clinton in the poll numbers. Clinton and Starr are
actually equally disliked.
3) The Capitol shooting:
It's Reagan's fault. NBC's Katie Couric tied it to mental health
budget cuts begun in the Reagan years.
4) Hollywood stands by its
man. On Saturday Baldwin and Basinger host a Clinton fundraiser. Stallone
gave him boxing gloves.
All the networks Thursday night led with the testing of Lewinsky's
dress, how she had given it to her mother to hide so when the FBI searched
her apartment in January they did not find it, and how she turned over
answering machine tapes with messages from Clinton.
All but FNC offered new poll numbers on how the
public is reacting to Clinton's decision to testify. But only one
network actually said what is supposedly on the dress as the others
employed vague references to "physical evidence," "body
fluids" or a "stain." More on that in this item. In item #2
below some contrasts in what the competing network polls found, plus some
results the networks did not air.
But first, a brief
rundown on other Monicagate, or given the dress Fellategate, topics
covered Thursday night, July 30 in addition to the dress and polls:
-- On ABC's World News Tonight Sam Donaldson
played Clinton's "stern, unequivocal denial" from January when
he declared: "I did not have sexual relations with that woman, Miss
Lewinsky." Donaldson suggested Clinton has three options for August
17: a) repeat his denial; b) recant and ask for understanding; or c)
modify, admit closer relationship but deny a sexual relationship.
-- CNN's The
World Today. After Wolf Blitzer on the dress, Pierre Thomas looked at the
evidentiary impact of the dress and audio tapes and then Candy Crowley
took the temperature of Capitol Hill where she found no interest in
commenting or pursuing the scandal. John King summarized CNN's poll
before Jonathan Karl profiled Marcia Lewis. Karl relayed allegations about
her credit card habits and desire for expensive cars, charges based on
papers filed by her husband in divorce proceedings ten years ago.
-- On FNC's Fox
Report Jim Angle reported in from Clinton's trip to North Carolina to
highlight river clean up and like Donaldson he played Clinton's
"that woman" soundbite. Later, Eric Burns evaluated Linda
Tripp's complaints about being vilified in the news and entertainment
Now, to how each
network Thursday night described what Lewinsky maintains is on her dress.
In many cases if you didn't know already you'd not know after watching
the network stories.
-- CBS Evening
News. Dan Rather assured viewers that "Our check and double checked,
determined to be accurate coverage begins with CBS White House
correspondent Scott Pelley." But then Pelley may have been accurate,
but he was hardly specific:
"The dress was an issue for investigators at
the very beginning. They learned of it when Linda Tripp told them that
Lewinsky showed her a black cocktail dress and boasted that it was stained
with the President's body fluids."
-- CNN's The
World Today. Wolf Blitzer disclosed: "CNN has learned President
Clinton was unaware that Monica Lewinsky was turning over possible
physical evidence of an alleged sexual relationship when he agreed to
testify. Two sources familiar with Lewinsky's immunity agreement say the
former intern handed over a dress that Lewinsky claims may contain that
Blitzer later said Clinton felt
"blindsided" by the new evidence, but never specifically
-- FNC's 7pm ET
Fox Report. David Shuster opened his top of the show piece: "These
are good days for prosecutor Kenneth Starr. As part of Starr's deal with
Monica Lewinsky this week his investigators received a dress that she
allegedly kept as a type of souvenir. Sources close to Lewinsky say she
has told prosecutors President Clinton stained the dress during a sexual
encounter at the White House."
Julie Kirtz filed a story on how Drudge first
reported a dress existed that was "stained during a sexual
encounter" and then ABC picked up the charge a few days later but a
search by the FBI did not locate the dress. Kirtz pointed out that Steven
Brill had ridiculed the story.
-- NBC Nightly
News. Anchor Brian Williams was a vague as possible: "Former White
House intern Monica Lewinsky, the next big witness here who today met yet
again with members of Ken Starr's staff, has apparently turned over
evidence that might bolster the case against the President."
Lisa Myers explained that the FBI lab has a dress
Lewinsky "turned over as evidence of her relationship." Without
broaching where the DNA came from, Myers elaborated: "Of all the
evidence in this case so far, the navy cocktail dress, possibly containing
the President's DNA, is the most explosive. First the lab will determine
what substance is on the dress, if any, and whether there is enough to
make a DNA finding." Later, she narrowed the source down a bit:
"Experts say the FBI lab could know within a day if there are bodily
fluids on the dress."
-- Only ABC's
World News Tonight actually told viewers what Lewinsky claims Clinton left
on her dress. Jackie Judd reported: "Legal sources say Lewinsky told
prosecutors the dress was stained with semen and would offer proof of a
sexual relationship with Clinton."
Amazing how grown
men and women, at least network news executives, are so afraid of that
ABC and CBS highlighted their own polls Thursday night showing high
approval for Clinton and how they proved the public really doesn't care
about the Lewinsky scandal and that he certainly should not be impeached
over it. CBS went to St. Louis and Hollywood to demonstrate how most
don't care if Clinton had an affair. The question facing Starr is
whether the President committed perjury, but CBS didn't ask about that.
NBC discovered similar numbers with similar questions, but NBC's Claire
Shipman concluded the NBC News poll shows the President "may need to
reconsider his strategy" and offer an explanation.
ABC anchor Charlie
Gibson announced on World News Tonight:
"According to a new poll, from ABC News,
more Americans than ever believe President Clinton did have an affair with
Monica Lewinsky, but fewer think he should pay for it with his job.
According to the poll conducted last night, 68 percent now say they think
the President did have an affair, up 15 points from January. Only 39
percent say he should be impeached if he lied under oath about it,
that's down 16 points since January. Only 42 percent now think the
President should be impeached if he suggested ways Monica Lewinsky could
conceal the affair. And overall 66 percent agreed with the statement that
they are unhappy about Clinton's behavior in the Lewinsky affair but it
has nothing to do with his job as President."
Over on the CBS
Evening News Dan Rather highlighted how "The President was in North
Carolina today, where despite all his legal and political troubles, he got
a warm welcome. The President and Vice President Gore were there to
announce a restoration and preservation program for 14 American
rivers." Rather continued: "A new CBS News poll out
tonight finds President Clinton's job approval rating still riding high
at 61 percent, little changed from the week before [when it was 64
percent]. And what do Americans think about the investigation of the
For the answer CBS went to Jerry Bowen at a
baseball park in St. Louis. He revealed that the CBS poll discovered 71
percent think that Clinton had an affair with Lewinsky, but "like St.
Louis fans more interested in McGwire chasing Maris's record than
allegation the President was chasing Monica, the poll found most
Americans, 67 percent, don't think it's important to know if the
President had an affair."
Following clips of a St. Louis woman followed by
a California woman saying Clinton's personal life is irrelevant to his
job, Bowen argued that the women are like "54 percent of Americans in
the poll who find the President credible, more credible than either
Lewinsky [on-screen 36 percent] or Linda Tripp [on-screen 36 percent], he
is someone the grand jury should believe."
Bowen noted that Americans are evenly divided on
if Clinton encouraged Lewinsky to lie, "but a majority said if he did
that would be important for the public to know." (The poll results on
the cbs.com Web site reveal a wide 60 to 34 percent split on that
As if Hollywood reflects America, Bowen continued
his crusade: "In Los Angeles, screenwriter Monty Nicholson (sp?) said
that should not force Mr. Clinton from office."
Monty: "It's tawdry, it's sad, it
reflects very, very badly on the White House, but I don't think it
reflects anything as far as a criminal proceeding."
Back to St Louis Bowen managed to find one person
who cared if Clinton lied before returning to the first woman he showed:
"Most Americans would not favor Mr. Clinton's resignation or
impeachment, even of the allegations prove true. More than half favor a
simple apology or just forgetting about it." After the woman's
soundbite about how a CEO would just get a divorce and not be fired, Bowen
concluded by conceding: "That's how they score it now, but this is
one game of hardball that's not over."
In stark contrast,
NBC painted Clinton as in some trouble with the public. Noting Clinton's
policy of denial and refusal to offer an explanation, on NBC Nightly News
Claire Shipman asserted:
"The latest NBC News poll shows that the
President may need to reconsider his strategy. His approval rating is
still high at 68 percent, but 56 percent of those polled think he should
address the American people. 42 percent believe Monica Lewinsky's
version of events while only 29 percent believe Clinton's. Moreover, 43
percent think trying to cover up an affair may be an impeachable offense,
up from 39 percent last month."
delivered a contrasting spin, Shipman left out two very interesting
numbers reported in the results listed on the msnbc.com Web site:
-- In conflict with the CBS theme that lying
about sex is no big deal, NBC found the public considers "lying about
sex as serious as lying about any other matter, 54 to 39 percent."
-- Clinton and Starr are disliked equally:
"Given a list of figures in the case and asked whom they dislike
most, 32 percent of respondents chose Tripp. Clinton's share was 22
percent, followed by 21 percent for Starr and 13 for Lewinsky."
Capitol shooting: It's Reagan's fault. As sure as sunrise follows
sunset, whenever anything bad happens that someone can tie to federal
spending eventually a member of the media will blame it on Ronald Reagan.
Now that Bryant Gumbel is no longer o TV everyday and the CBS brass has
reigned him in on his CBS show it took a bit longer than usual this time,
but five days after the shooting NBC's Today and Katie Couric came
In the second half
hour on Wednesday, July 29, Kelly O'Donnell provided a set-up piece on
schizophrenia and how "Russell Weston Jr. is among an estimated two
and a half million Americans who have this chronic mental disorder which
often involves delusions and in extreme cases can lead to violence."
Observing that John Hinkley and the Unabomber were schizophrenic,
O'Donnell wondered: "Could any of it have been prevented? Did the
mental health system do enough?"
Dr. Dave Davis, forensic psychiatrist: "The
problem is with monitoring these people that there's no way to monitor
them or keep up with them because they're free to not be treated."
O'Donnell: "Free of the forced commitment
to institutions that was common a generation ago. During the Reagan era
federal spending for mental health dropped about 25 percent. Funding has
continued to go down ever since. Today as many as half of the homeless are
believed to be the untreated mentally ill."
In the segment
O'Donnell set up Katie Couric questioned two psychologists. Her final
inquiry, as transcribed by MRC analyst Geoffrey Dickens:
"Quickly, we're almost out of time, but it
seems to me that money is an issue. That funding was cut 25 percent during
the Reagan administration. It's gone down ever since. Don't we need to
funnel more money into helping these people? The fact that half of the
homeless population may be untreated mentally ill is a real tragedy
don't you think Dr. Bernstein?"
Of course, it was
really liberals who pushed through laws in the late '70s making it much
harder for states to involuntarily commit the mental ill. With fewer
patients to care for funding naturally fell. But the shooting is the
responsibility of the one man who pulled the trigger.
As the quote from the Hollywood screenwriter in item #2 above
demonstrated, that community will always stand by Clinton. Tomorrow, they
will show their support again with a big fundraiser on Long Island.
As reported by
Annie Groer and Ann Gerhart in their Reliable Source column in the July 2
Washington Post, actor Alec Baldwin "and his wife, Kim Basinger, are
throwing open the doors of their Amagansett home to President Clinton for
a DNC fundraiser Aug. 1. The gathering, advertised as a 'summer lawn
party,' is expected to draw Robert DeNiro, Helen Hunt and other glittery
people among the 100 or so guests. Tickets: $250 to $1,000. It's just one
of the stops Clinton will make on a dining-for-dollars weekend in the
Basinger will be the second actors to host a fundraiser for Clinton in
under a month. Three weeks ago actor Sylvester Stallone provided his home
for a big Democratic fundraiser. As detailed by Tom Fielder and Manny
Garcia in the July 10 Miami Herald:
"President Clinton was the guest of honor,
but Sylvester Stallone stole some scenes Thursday night as a
$5,000-a-plate dinner at Stallone's Miami mansion raised more than
$800,000 for Democratic coffers.
"Dressed all in black, Stallone compared the
President with his character in Rocky. Holding up his battered boxing
gloves from the first Rocky movie, he presented them to Clinton, saying
they 'exemplify the character in an uphill battle that doggedly asks for
one more round and keeps punching and punching and finally gets his
"Clinton responded: 'I think I have
established that I can take a punch. Now the time has come to show I can
deliver one,' he said to cheers."
Hollywood will at
least make sure the Democrats have all the money they need to buy TV
advertising to throw those punches at Republicans and conservatives. -- Brent Baker
Support the MRC, an educational foundation dependent upon contributions
which make CyberAlert possible, by providing a tax-deductible
donation. Use the secure donations page set up for CyberAlert
readers and subscribers:
>>>To subscribe to CyberAlert, send a
blank e-mail to:
@topica.com. Or, you can go to:
Either way you will receive a confirmation message titled: "RESPONSE
REQUIRED: Confirm your subscription to firstname.lastname@example.org."
After you reply, either by going to the listed Web page link or by simply
hitting reply, you will receive a message confirming that you have been
added to the MRC CyberAlert list. If you confirm by using the Web page
link you will be given a chance to "register" with Topica. You DO
NOT have to do this; at that point you are already subscribed to
To unsubscribe, send a blank e-mail to:
Send problems and comments to: email@example.com.
can learn what has been posted each day on the MRC's Web site by
subscribing to the "MRC Web Site News" distributed every weekday
afternoon. To subscribe, send a blank e-mail to: firstname.lastname@example.org.
Or, go to: http://www.mrc.org/newsletters.<<<
Home | News Division
| Bozell Columns | CyberAlerts
Media Reality Check | Notable Quotables | Contact
the MRC | Subscribe