Murderers Doing Work of Congress & Right; Cronkite Denounces Starr
1) Dan Rather's alliteration:
"Republican-led Congress's fast-approaching impeach-the-President
inquiry." Only FNC picked up on NPR's hit on Starr's ethics for
advising Gil Davis in 1994.
2) Tuesday night Sam Donaldson
gave a clause to the GOP take on education spending and CBS's Scott Pelley
actually raised the ethics of Clinton fundraising for a Judiciary
3) Those who murdered the gay
student were "doing the work of the Congress," claimed ABC's
Bill Maher. Katie Couric cited a "climate of anti-Gay hate"
that's "fostered by" the "political right."
4) Walter Cronkite claimed
Starr's probe is "more divisive" than Vietnam as he's hounding
Clinton with "excessive zeal."
charging of Eric Rudolph for the 1996 bombing in Olympic Park led ABC's
World News Tonight and CBS Evening News on Wednesday night. CNN and NBC
went first with the imminent budget deal and a report that Ken Starr
advised Paula Jones lawyer Gil Davis in 1994 topped FNC's Fox Report. (The
budget deal was announced later, at about 11pm ET.) CBS and FNC delivered
full reports on the budget deal, but ABC held it to a few seconds. Though
every network mentioned how Clinton won on getting money for 100,000 new
teachers, none asked if that number is any less illusory than the 100,000
offered an alliteration-filled introduction to a story on Henry Hyde's
plans. The CBS and FNC anchors read an excerpt from Monica Lewinsky's
goodbye letter to her neighbors at 700 New Hampshire Ave. NW, aka The
Watergate. Dan Rather also warned viewers about a new inequality: the
Here are a few
notes and quotes from the Wednesday night, October 14, evening shows:
-- ABC's World
News Tonight led with Eric Rudolph being charged with the Olympic Park
bombing in Atlanta. After explaining how he's thought to be still hiding
in the woods of North Carolina and running soundbites of locals saying
they wouldn't turn him in, ABC's John Miller concluded:
"One investigator summed up the frustrating
eight month hunt this way: First we appealed to people's civic duty by
showing a wanted poster. Then to greed by adding a million dollar award.
Now, we're appealing to people's conscience."
Jennings read this short item about the budget deal: "In Washington
today the White House and Republican leaders say they're in the process of
completing the $500 billion spending bill which will keep the government
running for another year. The White House is claiming it has won on a
major sticking point: a billion dollar measure to hire 100,000 new
teachers. Republicans point out that they win because the money's going to
be controlled by local governments and not by federal bureaucracy."
-- CBS Evening
News. Bob Schieffer explained how this kind of last-minute showdown
happens almost every year, noting that this year Clinton got the $1.1
billion he wanted for 100,000 new teachers. Pointing out how Democrats
condemned the "do-nothing" Congress Schieffer highlighted a
supporting CBS News/New York Times poll which found 72 percent can't name
anything Congress has accomplished this year.
piece by Scott Pelley on Henry Hyde's plans to accelerate the process, Dan
"There are late-breaking developments as
well tonight in the Republican-led Congress's fast-approaching
Pelley explained that Hyde wants to prepare
a stipulation list, asking the President to agree with the grand jury
testimony of witnesses like Vernon Jordan and Monica Lewinsky. Hyde is
also looking at consolidating the charges, but Pelley warned, Hyde says if
Clinton refuses to stipulate the end of the year deadline could slip.
Later in the show
Rather found a new inequality to worry about -- the impact of fewer women
than men being interested in computers. Over a graphic reading "Cyber
Ceiling," he ominously announced: "There is new research out
today on a gender gap in the world of computer technology. Whatever the
reasons, there is one virtual certainty. As CBS's Diana Olick reports, in
cyber space women face a disadvantage in high-paying, high-tech
-- CNN's The
World Today led with Jonathan Karl on the imminent budget deal. Or tried
to. Viewers saw repeated delays in the airing of pre-taped segments as
Karl stood live staring at the camera. He reported that Clinton got money
for teachers, but not funds for school renovations. Highlighting how both
sides agreed to $20 billion in "emergency spending" for farm
aid, defense, troops in Bosnia and the Year 2000 computer problem, Karl
uniquely pointed out: "It's the highest level of emergency spending
since such funds were used to pay for the Persian Gulf War. The emergency
category is not covered by last year's balanced budget agreement, making
it a tempting place for added spending..."
Next, Bob Franken
explained how Henry Hyde, to keep on schedule, wants to scale back the
number of charges by consolidating the 15 charges into fewer
"core" charges, such as perjury and obstruction of justice.
-- FNC's Fox
Report at 7pm ET led with a piece by David Shuster on how Starr consulted
with Gil Davis in 1994. Surprisingly, though probably due to its late
afternoon disclosure, the story by NPR's Nina Totenberg was not picked up
by any of the other networks. Shuster did not mention Totenberg, just
cited NPR and reported that Davis now says Starr advised him on six
occasions in 1994. Shuster continued: "Even though Starr was not
investigating the President in 1994 when he was advising the lawyers for
Jones, some legal experts say he had an ethical obligation to reveal any
potential conflicts of interest."
But Shuster also delivered Starr's side,
explaining that a spokesman said it "was not a big deal four and a
half years ago and is an old news story now. Gil Davis agrees. Late today
he told Fox News that Starr had no interest in the Paula Jones allegations
and was only willing to give advice on the question of whether a President
could be sued while in office. Davis said it's ridiculous to suggest Starr
should have even remembered the four- and-a-half year old
Up next, Carl
Cameron summarized how Hyde wishes to consolidate the charges, not drop
any as the Washington Post reported Wednesday morning.
Nightly News led with the budget deal as David Bloom observed:
"....and even Republicans concede that when it came to the biggest
hurdle, money for education, they decided it was better to go home and
campaign than stay and fight an embattled, but still popular
President." Bloom explained how Clinton got his $1.1 billion for
100,000 teachers, but not his $5 billion for school construction. Clinton
victories also included how the "Republicans abandoned their plan for
a $80 billion tax cut, meaning the budget surplus is largely saved for
Social Security." Bloom listed how Clinton lost this year on tobacco,
a patients bill of right and campaign finance reform.
night the deal with Serbian leader Slobodan Milosevic which put off
airstrikes topped the ABC and CNN evening shows. CBS led with Japan's
parliament voting to bail out its small banks and NBC went first with
layoffs at Merrill Lynch.
highlights from the Tuesday, October 13, broadcast evening shows:
-- ABC's World
News Tonight. After ignoring Republican and conservative arguments all
weekend (see the October 13 CyberAlert), on Tuesday Sam Donaldson gave a
clause to the GOP view on education spending. In a story on how Clinton
picked a fight over education because polls show his stand is popular,
Donaldson recounted how he first proposed 100,000 teachers in his State of
the Union address. Since then he's vetoed Republican bills "because
the Republicans often attached private school voucher proposals to which
the President objected." Now, Donaldson noted in finally giving the
Republican take a few syllables, Republicans will "gladly provide the
$1.1 billion for more teachers if it goes directly to local districts,
without passing through federal programs as the President wants."
-- CBS Evening News. Scott Pelley looked at the
"shotgun wedding" which brought Democratic Maryland Governor
Parris Glendening to an event with Clinton, a man he refused to stand near
a month ago. "What a difference a poll makes," observed Pelley
in explaining how Democrats who were attacking Clinton weeks ago now see
it as beneficial to be with him. Pelley added this point cited by
conservatives: "It's a strange election season that also raises
ethical issues for the party. Last night Mr. Clinton raised a million
dollars in part for Charles Schumer, a member of the very committee that
will vote on impeachment."
-- NBC Nightly News. No mention of the budget or
scandal, other than the "Nightly Numbers" screen, which featured
the salary hike for Linda Tripp by the Defense Department to $90,767 from
murder of gay college student Matthew Shepard in Wyoming hasn't led to
widespread media claims of conservative culpability as happened after the
Oklahoma City bombing. While the networks have aired many stories
featuring activists advocating the need for a federal "hate
crime" law, but no one with a different point of view, they have
largely refrained from maligning an entire segment of the population or
conservative leaders for the individual actions of a few.
But there have
been exceptions. Specifically, ABC's Bill Maher and NBC's Katie Couric.
-- On Monday
night's Politically Incorrect host Bill Maher segued into the murder:
"And as far as the gay thing goes, you know, the Taliban -- I mean
the Republican Party..."
clearly implicated Newt Gingrich and Trent Lott in the murder: "I
voted for Dole and I was pretty much behind that revolution in '94, back
when they were all about economics. But I started talking about this on
Friday. You know, between Bill Clinton and their hatred of gays, you know,
it's no wonder that things like this happen. When you create an atmosphere
that is so anti-sexual in this country, you know, yes, the borderline
personalities like these idiots are going to hear it and pick up on it and
say, 'Oh, you know what.'"
jumped in at that point, but later Maher blamed Congress for what the
accused did: "When they hear Senators and Congressmen and people who
they respect in an elevated position say that, you know, being gay is next
to, you know, being the devil, of course, then they think, 'Well, you
know, it's okay. I'm sort of doing the work of the Congress.'"
-- NBC News picked
up and ran with the left-wing's shots at conservatives, MRC analyst
Geoffrey Dickens noticed on Tuesday. Opening the October 13 Today, co-host
Katie Couric announced:
"Then the fallout from the death of Matthew
Shepard. The tragic beating of the college student in Wyoming has some
activists in this country saying there is a climate of anti-gay hate
that's been fostered by a provocative advertising campaign by the
political right in this country. We're gonna get into that debate after
news and weather."
subsequent segment, Couric stated: "On Close Up this morning, the
beating death of Matthew Shepard. As investigators try to learn more about
the reasons behind the murder of the openly gay University of Wyoming
student NBC correspondent David Gregory reports it is sending shockwaves
through the gay community."
Gregory gave credence to the blaming of those not
"Even as friends of Matthew Shepard held a
candlelight vigil in his honor gay rights groups rushed to condemn the
killing. Portraying Shepard as a casualty of a new cultural war against
gays and lesbians, a war declared this summer by a coalition of religious
right groups including the Christian Coalition which funded advertisements
in major newspapers and commercials on TV promoting a campaign to convert
homosexuals to heterosexuality. The ads were controversial for portraying
gays and lesbians as sinners who had made poor choices despite the growing
belief that homosexuality may be genetic. And the campaign followed the
divisive comments of Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott who said in an
interview that homosexuals should be helped like alcoholics, sex addicts
Trent Lott: "And you should not try to
mistreat them or treat them as outcasts you should try to, you know, show
them, a way to deal with that problem."
Gregory: "Have the ads fostered a climate of
anti-gay hate that leads to incidents like the killing of Matthew Shepard?
Gay rights activists say the ads convey a message that gay people are
Kim Mills, Human Rights Campaign: "And those
folks who are, kind of, on the cusp may just fall over into the wrong part
of the world and go out and do terrible things."
Kristi Hamrick, Family Research Council: "It
is absolutely ridiculous to say that a loving message from 'The Truth and
Love Campaign,' has had anything to do with this kind of violence because
the centerpiece of this is that we care about you, we care about what
happens to you."
Gregory: "But the question remains. Have
these campaigns to quote, 'save gays and lesbians,' made them easy targets
instead or is what happened to Matthew Shepard in Wyoming last week a
random act of hate that would have happened anyway? For Today, David
Gregory, NBC News, Washington."
allowed Elizabeth Birch of the Human Rights Campaign to elaborate on how
the Christian Right is to blame and Janet Folger, Executive Director of
the Center for Reclaiming America, to defend the ads her group created.
The only thing
defective is the reasoning of the liberals to whom NBC conveyed
credibility. Even if you buy into the argument that the ads somehow
incited murder, quite a stretch, how do we know the murderers ever saw the
the story, the MRC's Geoffrey Dickens talked with Kristen Hansen of the
Family Research Council, part of the coalition behind the ads. Hansen
explained that while the ads did appear in papers available in Wyoming,
such as the Wall Street Journal and USA Today, the group has yet to buy a
TV spot. Those accused are of college-age, the adult age group
least-likely to read a newspaper. But they could have seen the ad on TV.
How, if no ads were bought? In network stories condemning the ad campaign
which featured an ad excerpt, like Gregory's on Tuesday's Today.
Gregory, Today producers and the Human Rights Campaign really think the
ads are culpable, they should demand arrest warrants for accessory to
murder for every network employee involved in airing the ads.
In August the Clinton family joined Walter Cronkite aboard his boat in
Martha's Vineyard. Now Cronkite wants to get Ken Starr out on his boat so
he can vent his anger at him for a probe that is "more divisive"
than Vietnam. Out promoting his co-anchoring of CNN's coverage of John
Glenn's return to space, Cronkite labeled the Clinton scandal "a
private affair," reminiscing favorably about when the media ignored
-- Here's a
portion of Cronkite's October 13 interview with Mark McEwen on CBS's This
Morning, as transcribed by MRC analyst Jessica Anderson:
McEwen: "In earlier days, the
President's private life with rumors of things that went on with the
President and other people, that life was kept private. Was it a better
time then? Were we better served by the way reporters handled it then, or
are we better served now, where it seems like everything is fair game in
Cronkite: "Oh, I think we were far better
served then. The rule of thumb at that time, among us reporters who
covered the White House and Congress, and state legislatures for that
matter, the rule of thumb was that unless an individual's personal
peccadilloes got in the way of performing the job, and seriously in a way,
provable, provably that they were not able to perform their job, or
endangered the public's welfare by what they were doing outside, we didn't
pay any attention to it. Private lives were private lives, and I think
that still ought to be the case. I don't think we should be digging into
other people's private lives at all."
McEwen: "Should President Clinton step
Cronkite: "No, I don't think so. It
certainly would ease the affairs of state, perhaps, if he did, but on the
other hand, I don't see why he should feel forced to do that because of
his performance, which is certainly abominable and nothing that we can
approve, but on the other hand, it does seem to me it's a private
Wednesday's USA Today Peter Johnson summarized some comments Cronkite
uttered later on Tuesday at a lunch with reporters in New York City:
"Tuesday, Cronkite stopped short of calling special prosecutor
Kenneth Starr a zealot, but he said Starr's probe of President Clinton's
sex life may prove to be 'more divisive' than Vietnam.
only question is 'how long can the American public stand it,' said
Cronkite, 81, accusing Starr of 'considerable excessive zeal' in hounding
Clinton about his affair with Monica Lewinsky. 'It's a desperate, sad
situation,' he said....
still refuses to discuss the sail [with Clinton in August], but says he'd
'like to get Kenneth Starr out on the boat,' presumably to give him a
piece of his mind."
trusted man in America" can always be trusted to spout the
conventional liberal thinking. -- Brent Baker
Support the MRC, an educational foundation dependent upon contributions
which make CyberAlert possible, by providing a tax-deductible
donation. Use the secure donations page set up for CyberAlert
readers and subscribers:
>>>To subscribe to CyberAlert, send a
blank e-mail to:
@topica.com. Or, you can go to:
Either way you will receive a confirmation message titled: "RESPONSE
REQUIRED: Confirm your subscription to firstname.lastname@example.org."
After you reply, either by going to the listed Web page link or by simply
hitting reply, you will receive a message confirming that you have been
added to the MRC CyberAlert list. If you confirm by using the Web page
link you will be given a chance to "register" with Topica. You DO
NOT have to do this; at that point you are already subscribed to
To unsubscribe, send a blank e-mail to:
Send problems and comments to: email@example.com.
can learn what has been posted each day on the MRC's Web site by
subscribing to the "MRC Web Site News" distributed every weekday
afternoon. To subscribe, send a blank e-mail to: firstname.lastname@example.org.
Or, go to: http://www.mrc.org/newsletters.<<<
Home | News Division
| Bozell Columns | CyberAlerts
Media Reality Check | Notable Quotables | Contact
the MRC | Subscribe