Gone; Study Shows Dole's Policies Denounced
Four items today, following a
note, a correction and a humorous error from NBC's Today:
-- To better track these
CyberAlerts, as of today I've begun to put a number at the top. Today's is
the 103rd e-mail.
-- Yesterday I corrected my
spelling of U.S. Rep. Helen Chenoweth. I should have left well enough
alone. In making that correction, I mistakenly moved her to Iowa. She's
-- Speaking of errors, here's
Today news anchor Matt Lauer during the 7am news Monday morning: "The
next to last Monday of the presidential campaign finds Bob Dole in
Southern California and Bill Clinton in St. Louis. In Virginia Sunday the
President campaigned with Senator Chuck Robb, who's involved in a very
tough re-election battle."
That must be news to Robb. He
beat Oliver North two years ago. He's not up for re-election until 2000.
1) None of the
broadcast networks on Monday night reported anything about the latest on
the John Huang front. But on MSNBC a reporter noted that the Clinton team
believes it's too late for Huang to hurt them. That might explain why DNC
Chairman Chris Dodd felt comfortable enough Monday morning to joke with
Don Imus that he can't tell the truth about DNC fundraising until after
2) The ABC, CBS and
NBC evening shows Monday downplayed the campaign. None aired any story
from a reporter in the field. Instead, each had the anchor introduce
soundbites from Clinton and Dole. But in so doing, Dan Rather forwarded
the liberal definition of what affirmative action means.
3) The latest
figures from the Center for Media and Public Affairs' ongoing tracking of
positive and negative coverage shows that Dole's complaints about liberal
bias may have some merit -- his policies have received many more negative
comments than have Clinton's policies. And just eight percent of
evaluations touched on Clinton's character.
4) The October
MediaWatch study detailing how, during late September and early October,
the networks ignored or virtually ignored a series of developments and
revelations about Clinton scandals
ABC's World News Tonight, CBS Evening News and NBC Nightly News all failed
to mention John Huang Monday night October 28, though there was a
development. On MSNBC's The News with Brian Williams, reporter Jim
Miklaszewski noted in his story on Clinton's day:
"Today a U.S. District judget ordered DNC
fundraiser John Huang to give a videotaped deposition tomorrow in a civil
lawsuit. Huang had been avoiding a court subpoena, but Clinton advisers
report the White House pressured the DNC to force Huang to cooperate,
confident that anything Huang said now would likely have little or no
impact on the election just a week and a day away."
Especially when it's ignored by the broadcast networks. William Adams of
Talk Daily, a faxed digest of leading radio talk shows, passed along some
interesting comments that Chris Dodd made on Monday's Don Imus radio show.
Dodd said: "Eight more days and I can start telling you the truth
again [laughter] It's killing me, I'll tell you. I gotta lie [through] my
teeth to you every time I come on this show."
Concluding the interview, Imus stated:
"Senator Dodd, I'm sure we'll talk to you throughout the next"
[Dodd jumps in before Imus finishes]
Dodd: "When I can start telling the
Imus, continuing: "two or three years during
the impeachment proceedings and stuff."
Here's how Dan Rather on Monday night (October 28) introduced a soundbite
from Bob Dole explaining his support for the California Civil Rights
Initiative: "This is the final full week of the presidential
campaign. Bob Dole campaigned in California, a state that is absolutely
must-win for him. Dole opened up a new, more aggressive line of attack
against affirmative action programs designed to fight discriminaton
against women and minorities."
The Center for Media and Public Affairs counts the number of positive and
negative statements aired in campaign stories by the three broadcast
network evening shows. Their latest numbers, covering May 15 to September
"Ever since he left the Senate to campaign full-time, Mr. Dole has
been heavily criticized for his economic policies (81% negative), his
social policies (78% negative), and his conduct as a candidate (81%
"Since Labor Day...the gap between the two men's media images has
widened -- 54 percent good press for Clinton vs. only 30 percent good
press for Dole. (We calculate good press by tallying every positive or
negative evaluation of a candidate's record, policies, personal character
and behavior on the campaign trail. Our tallies include all on-air
opinions expressed by reporters and sources who are not affiliated with a
candidate or party. 'Good press' does NOT include any opinions about a
candidate's prospects in the horse race, which we tally separately.)"
"In September, fully 91 percent of sources said the economy was
healthy....In September 1992, 98 percent of all sources on the evening
news criticized the state of the economy."
"Mr. Clinton received mostly bad press on the 'character issue' (74
percent negative)....But discussions of the President's character amounted
to only eight percent of all evaluations of him, while more than half
(54%) focusd on his conduct as President or his stands on specific policy
issues. And the majority of those judgments have been favorable."
For those of you who don't get MediaWatch, below is the October Study, put
together by the MRC's Tim Graham. If you'd like a copy of the is sue and a
subscription order form, send an e-mail to MRC Circulation Manager Pete
Reichel: firstname.lastname@example.org -- Brent Baker
Revelation After Revelation
Reported by Newspapers, But Never Make TV News Networks Blackout Clinton's
Bad News On September 26, the House ethics committee announced it would
expand an investigation of Speaker Newt Gingrich's college course
"Renewing American Civilization." ABC, CBS, CNN and NBC reported
the story, ultimately adding up to eleven broadcast network morning and
evening segments in five days.
The next morning, NBC's Today led
off with an interview with NBC Washington Bureau Chief Tim Russert, who
proclaimed: "It's awful, it's serious, it's potentially
devastating." On October 8, Today's Matt Lauer asked Gingrich six
questions about ethics, including two about whether Gingrich would resign.
But a MediaWatch review of recent scoops on the Clinton administration's
character shows a much different approach to stories which could damage
September 23: The Federal Deposit
Insurance Corporation's inspector general concluded that Hillary Clinton
had drafted a real estate document with the intent to "deceive"
federal regulators. That real estate transaction, a sham deal selling a
property named Castle Grande to a straw buyer, later cost taxpayers $4
million in the bailout of Madison Guaranty Savings and Loan.
The Washington Post put the news
on its September 24 front page. Network coverage? Nothing -- until October
4, when NBC's Jim Miklaszewski mentioned it in a Nightly News story on a
speech by independent counsel Ken Starr: "Whitewater prosecutor
Kenneth Starr was invited to appear by outspoken Clinton critic Pat
Robertson and the audience was very conservative. The White House claims
that's proof Starr is out to get Clinton for political reasons, but Starr
says he'll stay the course." (ABC and CNN did report the story last
February 29, when the FDIC released a more favorable assessment,
recommending the FDIC not seek legal recourse against Mrs. Clinton or the
Rose Law Firm.)
September 24: A House committee
held hearings on charges that the administration has let criminals become
citizens. The Washington Times story the next day began: "Immigration
workers yesterday told a House Government Reform and Oversight
subcommittee of rampant abuses in the Citizenship USA program that
apparently let thousands of immigrants with criminal records become
citizens." The networks? Zilch until the October 18 CBS Evening News.
Also on September 24, a federal
jury convicted Sun Diamond Growers, one of the nation's largest producers
of fruits and nuts, of illegally showering former Clinton Agriculture
Secretary Mike Espy with nearly $6,000 in gifts, a conviction for
Independent Counsel Donald Smaltz. The story made The Washington Post
front page the next day. Network coverage? Nothing, but The NewsHour with
Jim Lehrer on PBS did a brief anchor-read item.
September 25: Sen. Orrin Hatch
revealed a six-month gap in the log which listed who at the White House
was accessing FBI background files on Republican White House employees.
The Washington Times bannered the news across page one the next day.
Coverage? A CNN World Today story and a mention on ABC's Good Morning
Also on the 25th, the Times
reported that Rep. John Mica (R.-Fla.) sent a letter to Clinton's
"drug czar" demanding release of a four-month-old Institute for
Defense Analysis report that concluded Bush's interdiction policy was far
more effective than Clinton's emphasis on drug treatment. Network
coverage? Nothing until a story by David Martin on the October 15 CBS
September 26: Three days after
President Clinton refused to rule out pardons for Whitewater figures on
The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer, 170 members of Congress, including three
Democrats, sent a letter to the White House demanding Clinton promise not
to pardon anyone. The September 29 Washington Times reported that House
Democrats were prepared to shut down the government if Republicans
demanded a vote on a resolution calling for President Clinton to renounce
pardons. Network coverage? With the exception of one general question on
the 29th about pardons from CBS Evening News Sunday anchor John Roberts to
commentator Laura Ingraham, absolutely nothing until Dole raised the
October 1: The White House
claimed executive privilege to withhold from House investigators a memo to
President Clinton from FBI Director Louis Freeh said to be highly critical
of federal drug policy. Network response? Zero.
October 4: Sen. Orrin Hatch
released the deposition of White House aide Mari Anderson before the
Senate Judiciary Committee. Anderson verified that pages of the log used
to record the taking of FBI files were missing. Anderson also asserted, in
contradiction to White House aide Craig Livingstone's assurances, that he
knew they were procuring the FBI files of Republicans. Even The Washington
Post put this story on its front page the next day. Network coverage? Only
CNN, in two Linden Soles anchor-briefs on The World Today, mentioned the
news. (ABC's World News Tonight didn't report it, but the revelations were
raised in an interview on the October 6 This Week.)
Also on October 4, former FBI
Special Agent Dennis Sculimbrene, who was the senior agent assigned to the
White House from 1986 to April 1996, told The Wall Street Journal:
"There were senior people as well, senior aides and advisers to the
President who used drugs recently -- people in policy positions, or say,
the director of an office...Some senior people even said they had used
drugs as recently as the Inaugural." Sculimbrene estimated that
"about 25 percent of the incoming administration, about one out of
four cases, had a problem with illegal drugs. Not just casual
experimentation, but a pattern of usage." Network coverage? Zero.
October 10: A House panel
investigating the Clinton administration's secret foreign policy
initiative to encourage the Iranian government to arm the Bosnian Muslims
asked the Justice Department to probe administration officials for
possible criminal charges for false statements. Since the Iran-Bosnia
secret foreign policy emerged in the Los Angeles Times April 5, CBS and
NBC have aired absolutely nothing on the evening news about the story. CNN
and ABC aired only anchor briefs, only in the first days of the story.
Network coverage for the latest development? Zero.
On CNN's Crossfire Sept. 20,
Chicago Tribune reporter Ellen Warren declared: "Reporters want
nothing more, this year and four years ago, to have a horse race. That's
what we're in love with, is the fight, the close call....So it's in our
interest to make it look close, to make Bob Dole look good."
The omissions documented here
Home | News Division
| Bozell Columns | CyberAlerts
Media Reality Check | Notable Quotables | Contact
the MRC | Subscribe