Connecting $ to Spying; Clinton's Great Week; Nightline Absence
1) Fox's Carl Cameron
related Sunday that documents "connect China's illegal campaign
contributions to...Clinton with specific cases of Beijing's acquisition
of U.S. military technology."
2) The Sunday interview shows
focused on the Cox Report, but it only generated 58 seconds on the only
broadcast show in the evening. Nothing on a Democrat calling for Reno's
3) Newsweek's Eleanor Clift
complained about how the fuss over espionage reflected a plot to
"distract from what was a terrific week" for Clinton and Gore on
4) NBC's Andrea Mitchell
held Presidents Carter, Reagan, Bush and Clinton equally culpable. Tom
Brokaw asked Cox about connections between donations and espionage, but
the question never aired.
5) Charlie Trie pled guilty
Friday to fundraising charges, but CBS ignored it. ABC gave it 11 seconds,
NBC 18. FNC revealed a relative of We Ho Lee is suspected of giving China
6) In the 55 weeknights since
Chinese spying became known ABC's Nightline has dedicated just one show
to the topic.
7) Another reporter called for
a gun ban, CBS argued the Senate did not go far enough and on Today Matt
Lauer tried to get students to advocate gun control, but they refused.
8) Monday night CBS will show
The American President in which Michael Douglas as the President declares:
"You cannot address crime prevention without getting rid of assault
weapons and handguns. I consider them a threat to national security."
>>> Another Gore Gaffe. Hear about
it from an eyewitness. Singer Courtney Love recounted on the May 20 Late
Show with David Letterman how at a Democratic fundraiser in Hollywood Al
Gore told her "I'm a really big fan of yours." When she asked
him to name one of her songs, she relayed how "he couldn't do it, he
couldn't do it!" To watch Love tell about meeting Gore go to this
address, where MRC Webmaster Sean Henry has posted it, and scroll to Gaffe
FNC's Carl Cameron discovered documents which "directly connect
China's illegal campaign contributions to President Clinton with
specific cases of Beijing's acquisition of U.S. military
technology." Usually, only those with the Fox News Channel on their
cable system, which means only about half of those with cable, can see
Cameron's pacesetting exclusives. This one, however, reached a far
greater audience as Cameron appeared at the top of the May 23 Fox News
Sunday shown by Fox broadcast affiliates.
"Fox News has obtained documents for the first time that directly
connect China's illegal campaign contributions to President Clinton with
specific cases of Beijing's acquisition of U.S. military technology.
China had an elaborate scheme to obstruct U.S. Justice Department
investigations into both.
"Now, for the first time, we connect the
dots with the documentation.
"Former Democratic Party fundraiser Johnny
Chung recently told Congress that he felt pressured to keep silent about
taking money from Chinese spies for President Clinton's campaign. Chung
met Liu Chaoying, a lieutenant colonel in the People's Liberation Army
who arranged a rendevous and $300,000 from the head of China's military
"When Chung was eventually charged by the
Justice Department, he was contacted by Robert Luu -- who according to
documents obtained by Fox News was operating on behalf of Chinese
"Chung's orders: Above all protect Loral
Space and Hughes Electronics, U.S. satellite firms whose business deals
with China were arranged by Liu Chaoying. Loral and Hughes launch their
satellites on Chinese rockets. The U.S. firms are under federal
investigation for and accused in a forthcoming congressional report of
helping China improve its missile technology.
"Chung thought receiving money from Chinese
intelligence would be the problem, but FBI surveillance tapes show Luu was
more interested in concealing something else.
"Quote: 'All those things are not
important,' Luu told Chung in a wiretap transcript obtained by Fox News.
'The important part is not to touch Hughes and Loral.... Matters about
Hughes and Loral...they [Chinese superiors] don't want to see any
information that is disadvantageous to them.'"
some comments from an FBI agent's interview with Luu demonstrating Luu
was performing spy work, Cameron concluded:
"Throughout hundreds of pages of transcripts
and wiretaps and various FBI interrogations it becomes clear China had an
elaborate plot to thwart the Justice Department investigation and even
Chinese intelligence had signed off on a cover story designed to explain
the illegal donations. They were to blame them on so-called prince-lings,
the sons of Chinese military leaders working and studying in the United
States. The idea would be that the donations did not come from the Beijing
government but from their offspring in irresponsible, reckless and
China gaining media traction? Well, not really. Every Sunday morning
interview show but CNN's Late Edition devoted a segment to the upcoming
Cox Report, but such network interest has yet to extend to the broadcast
network morning and evening shows.
Not a word about
Chinagate Friday morning on ABC, CBS and NBC or on CBS or ABC on Friday or
Saturday night. Though Tom Brokaw interviewed Cox for Friday's NBC
Nightly News, the set-up story by Andrea Mitchell avoided raising anything
about Clinton administration mishandling, cover-up or dissembling related
to the espionage. Under the heading of "Where did they get it?"
a screen graphic shown by NBC displayed how China obtained the technology
during the presidencies of Carter, Reagan, Bush and Clinton, as if all
were equally culpable. NBC didn't bother reporting how the Justice
Department rejected a FBI request for a wiretap warrant or how the Clinton
team stopped performing background checks on lab visitors. (See item #4
for more on Friday's NBC Nightly News.)
Senators Torricelli and Shelby appeared on CBS's Face the Nation,
ABC's This Week talked with Energy Secretary Bill Richardson,
Congressman Porter Goss came aboard Fox News Sunday and Meet the Press
landed Chris Cox as well as Energy intelligence official Notra Trulock.
Clinton's March 19 dissembling at a press conference, about how no
"espionage" took place in his years, was raised on all the
On Face the Nation
Democratic Senator Robert Torricelli made clear he believed Attorney
General Janet Reno should resign, but neither that or any of the
discussion about Clinton lying to the country about spying, made it onto
Sunday's World News Tonight, the only one of the three broadcast network
shows to air in the ET and CT zones. (Basketball bumped NBC and golf
pushed aside CBS.) The ABC show provided only a 58-second compilation of
three Sunday morning soundbites: Torricelli on Face the Nation calling the
espionage serious, Senator Richard Shelby on the same show calling on Reno
to resign and Richardson on ABC's This Week downplaying the importance
of what was lost.
calls on CBS for Reno's resignation and NBC's Tim Russert nails down
the sequence of reports and briefings to show how Clinton dissembled, and
Brit Hume says it flat out: Clinton was "lying."
-- CBS's Face
the Nation: Bi-partisan agreement, Reno should go for her department's
rejection of a FBI request for a search warrant for Wen Ho Lee.
Republican Senator Richard Shelby asserted:
"It's time for new leadership at the Justice Department. I believe
that the Attorney General ought to resign and she ought to take her top
lieutenants with her and she ought to do it now for the sake of the
Robert Torricelli didn't defend Reno: "I think the failures of
judgment by the Attorney General of the United States are inexplicable. I
do not know how she could explain the failures to provide this wiretap
despite overwhelming evidence that there was probable cause in that the
national security was being compromised....."
When host Bob Schieffer asked "Should Reno
resign?" Torricelli replied: "I think it's time for President
Clinton to have a conversation with the Attorney General about her ability
to perform her duties and whether or not it's in the national interest
for her to continue."
-- Meet the Press.
Tim Russert demonstrated how Clinton officials covered up knowledge of
spying, a theme avoided by NBC Nightly News on Friday night.
Russert: "In July of 1998 you were requested
to brief the House Intelligence Committee."
Trulock: "That's correct."
Russert: "Were you allowed to brief
Trulock: "I was not."
Russert: "Who denied you approval?"
Trulock: "In this case, then-Deputy
Secretary Elizabeth Moeller denied my request to brief chairman Porter
Goss, House Permanent Select Intelligence Committee."
Russert: "What reason did she give?"
Trulock: "At that time, she told me that she
was concerned that they -- and I've said in my open testimony I believe
by they she was referring to the House Permanent Select Committee on
Intelligence -- only wanted to hurt the President on his China policy.
Secretary Richardson, when he came in, reversed that policy immediately.
The first time that I briefed him on this case was the day that I made
some of my initial presentations to the Cox Commission, and his guidance
to me was, You go up there and you tell those people what they need to
Later, Russert ran
through all the times the Clinton team was told about spying and
contrasted it with Clinton's denial:
Russert to Chris Cox: "So Mr. Berger on this
program acknowledged he was briefed by Mr. Trulock in April of '96 and
then briefed the President. He was briefed by Mr. Trulock in July of '97
and briefed the President. And in January of this year, you sent a report
to the White House outlining your findings. Let me put on the screen what
the president of the United States said in March of this year. 'Can you
assure the American people that under your watch, no valuable nuclear
secrets were lost?' President Clinton: 'Can I tell you there has been
no espionage at the labs since I've been president? I can tell you that
no one has reported to me that they suspect such a thing has occurred.'
Later in the press conference, 'To the best of my knowledge, no one has
said anything to me about any espionage which occurred by the Chinese
against the labs during my presidency.' Mr. Cox, that would suggest that
Mr. Berger did not speak to the President ever in '96, '97 or '98,
or the President never saw the report you sent him in January."
Cox: "Well, I would be very concerned if the
latter were the case. On February the 4th, I and the ranking Democrat on
the select committee, Representative Norm Dicks of Washington, wrote to
the president and asked for a private meeting to brief the president on
our findings and our recommendations. That meeting was put off until the
22nd of April, but at that time when we met with the president for, if I
recall correctly, about 90 minutes, we had a very thorough discussion of
not only historical but ongoing problems at the national laboratories and
with PRC espionage, so at least from that point, there is no question that
the administration and our select committee were all on the same
And Russert raised
political retribution with Trulock: "In August of 1998, you were
Trulock: "I was the director of intelligence
until May of 1998, at which point I was removed from that position."
Trulock: "There are bureaucratic reasons
which seem perfectly valid. My sense is that I was simply too aggressive
and too unwilling to back off this issue and let it die."
NBC Nightly News or Today viewers will ever hear of any of this. Two weeks
ago when Russert got Richardson to concede spying took place during
Clinton's years neither show picked up on it.
-- Brit Hume in the roundtable on Fox News
Sunday: "It's also pretty clear, I mean Porter Goss is very
diplomatic about it, but it's pretty clear based on the sequence that we
showed, that was President Clinton answering a question, as it happens
from our Wendell Goler at that news conference, that with even the
lawyerly wording of it, and it was very lawyerly, he was lying."
With Clinton's March 19 denial fresh in your mind, as recited in the
transcribed portions of Meet the Press above, try to follow Eleanor
Clift's "spin" about how Clinton was accurate. On the
McLaughlin Group this past weekend she maintained:
"All of this first of all goes back two
Presidents. Second of all nobody has been charged with espionage and there
is no evidence that Wen Ho Lee is a spy as you as you have indicated and
I'd be real careful."
John McLaughlin: "No evidence?"
Clift: "No evidence, right. And when the
President says that nobody talked to him about espionage he was correct
about no espionage."
A bit later the
Newsweek writer complained about how all the fuss about espionage suggests
a plot by McLaughlin to "distract from what was a terrific week"
for Clinton and Gore on gun control and the election in Israel:
"If security was compromised, both parties
are guilty of inattention. Bureaucratic inertia is the enemy here and the
attempt to make this partisan and distract from what was a terrific week
for this administration -- gun control, Al Gore casting the deciding vote,
an election in Israel that is very positive for Israel and this country.
Why didn't we talk about that?"
Friday night, a day after FNC aired its interview with Cox, NBC's Tom
Brokaw aired his. But while NBC broached the accuracy of Clinton's
denial of spying during his tenure, Brokaw and the set-up piece by Andrea
Mitchell failed to inform viewers about any of the charges of misdeeds
against the Clinton administration -- from preventing Trulock from
testifying, to turning down a FBI warrant request to how the campaign
accepted huge donations from the head of a company granted technology
transfer waivers. Actually, Brokaw did ask Cox about any influence of
Chinese donations, but that question and answer never made it onto the
opened her overview piece over video of Clinton and Zhu Rongji at the
White House: "Bill Clinton entertains China's leader, the full red
carpet treatment. Only four months earlier the President is warned of a
national security nightmare: China suspected of stealing America's
nuclear secrets for decades."
Mitchell played a soundbite of Richardson saying
here is "no doubt" espionage occurred and of Trent Lott calling
the Cox Report "scary" before she relayed how it found China
obtained designs for seven nuclear warheads. She then asked: "Where
did they get it?" Over a graphic with photos of the four Presidents
she cited she declared: "Incredibly, investigators say, from
America's own nuclear weapons labs under Presidents Carter, Reagan, Bush
and Clinton. Two years after learning about the spying Clinton offered
this carefully worded denial."
Clinton: "To the best of my knowledge no one
has said anything to me about any espionage which occurred by the Chinese
against the labs during my presidency."
Mitchell: "Was it a coverup? An Energy
Department official says his warnings about lax security, completely
Notra Trulock: "In short, as we now know,
nothing was done."
implied there should be doubt about Clinton's denial, she failed to make
the connection to how the administration was informed in November, 1998
about the loss of the valuable legacy codes in Clinton's first term.
She then went on
to explain how Cox determined that seven companies also passed along
sensitive information: "Singled out for criticism, Loral Corporation
and Hughes Electronics, both under investigation for allegedly helping
China improve its rockets. Both companies say they broke no laws."
But she failed to
point out how the Chairman of Loral was the biggest single donor to the
DNC in 1995-96.
She concluded by
noting that the "CIA says China accelerated its weapons program by
spying but has not yet built weapons based on the stolen designs."
Next, NBC showed
excepts from Brokaw's interview with Cox. Viewers heard these questions:
-- "How did this happen Congressman?"
Chinese now have access to our most sophisticated nuclear warhead, the
W88, the Trident warhead. How long do you think it will be before they can
deploy that warhead?"
Taiwanese-American scientist, Wen Ho Lee, has lost his job at Los Alamos
because he's suspected of giving intelligence to the Chinese. His
lawyers are thinking of suing the Department of Energy because they say he
lost his job unfairly. Do you think he's lost his job unfairly?"
Brokaw: "Do you think he's a spy?"
Cox: "There is no way that this man should
be working in our national security structure."
President has said that there were no violations of these laboratories
during his administration. Is he lying?"
Cox: "Both I and the ranking Democrat on the
select committee, Norm Dicks, met with the President on April 22, and gave
him a full brief on the major acts of espionage that had been committed
recently. And we didn't have any factual disagreement with the
-- "Is the
Hughes Corporation and Loral going be embarrassed when this report comes
Cox: "Beyond the fact that a great deal of
technical information was illegally shared that will in fact improve the
reliability of military space lift rockets in the PRC, that the way that
this activity was conducted by both Hughes and Loral was illegal."
Brokaw: "Absolutely illegal. Criminally
Cox: "There is no question that it was
deliberate and that it was an intentional avoidance of our export control
"Congressman, do you sleep a little more uneasily at night as a
result of all that you know now?"
Brokaw did twice
raise questions about Clinton misdeeds, the Web-posted transcript shows,
but both ended up on the cutting room floor:
-- "What did President Clinton know and when
did he know it?"
-- "This comes at a time when Charlie Trie,
one of the President's friends, a fundraiser, is on trial in Little
Rock. Is there a connection between this espionage and political donations
that the administration got from Chinese officials?"
To read the
transcript of the entire interview, go to: http://www.msnbc.com/news/272043.asp
Beware that NBC did not play the interview
excerpts in sequence. If you read through the transcript you'll come
across the Nightly News questions listed above in this order: #1, then #5,
then #3, then #4, then #6, and finally #2.
Friday night, May 21, every network but CBS noted the guilty pleas entered
by Charlie Trie, though briefly. World News Tonight viewers heard this
11-second item read by anchor Peter Jennings: "In Little Rock today
the President's friend Charlie Trie pleaded guilty to two charges
stemming from illegal fundraising and he agreed to cooperate with
prosecutors investigating fundraising in the 1996 elections."
NBC Nightly News
gave the development a mere 18 seconds.
Not even CNN's Inside Politics produced a full story as IP allocated 34
seconds to Trie. CNN's The World Today gave him 19 seconds. Only FNC's
Special Report with Brit Hume considered Trie worth some time, leading
with a piece from Carl Cameron who added on another front:
"Sources also say one of Wen Ho Lee's
relatives in now under investigation and surveillance. Sources say that
relative worked at a California weapons lab known to be working on the
stealth bomber and on a recent trip to mainland China allegedly gave
stealth secrets to Beijing."
The Chinagate scandal involves national security, possible administration
malfeasance and a dishonest answer about it from the President. A natural
topic for Nightline's format with its time for lengthy set-up piece
followed by Ted Koppel zooming in on a key figure. But it is not.
In the 55
weeknights since the March 6 New York Times revealed the Chinese espionage
how many nights has Nightline focused on the subject? Hint: it's the
same number of times the three morning shows combined have run an
interview segment about the espionage: Once.
from Monday March 8 through Friday May 21 only the March 12 show looked at
the espionage scandal. MRC analyst Jessica Anderson provided the following
night-by-night topic list:
March 8: Joe DiMaggio
March 9: drugs
March 10: drugs
March 11: drugs
March 12: Chinese espionage
March 15: possible connection b/w autism and pollution
March 16: Megan's Law and privacy rights
March 17: story of a child molester
March 18: Cambodia
March 19: Oscar for Elia Kazan
March 22: Kosovo
March 23: Kosovo
March 24: Kosovo
March 25: Kosovo
March 26: Kosovo
March 29: Kosovo
March 30: Kosovo
March 31: Kosovo
April 1: Kosovo
April 2: Kosovo
April 5: Kosovo
April 6: Kosovo
April 7: Kosovo
April 8: Kosovo
April 9: Kosovo
April 12: Kosovo
April 13: Kosovo
April 14: Kosovo
April 15: Kosovo
April 16: Kosovo
April 19: Kosovo
April 20: Littleton
April 21: Littleton
April 22: Littleton
April 23: Littleton
April 26: Kosovo
April 27: Kosovo
April 28: Kosovo
April 29: Kosovo
April 30: Kosovo
May 3: Kosovo
May 4: Kosovo
May 5: Kosovo
May 6: Kosovo
May 7: Legacy Project. Not the nuclear codes but the project to gather
letters soldiers wrote home during wars
May 10: Campaign against youth violence at the White House
May 11: Gun makers and the NRA
May 12: Kosovo
May 13: Genetic testing in Iceland
May 14: Grandparents raising grandchildren
May 17: Israel
May 18: Farming crisis
May 19: AIDS
May 20: Conyers school shooting
May 21: the oldest guitar-making firm in America
I'm sure the Cox
Report will prod Nightline to give the espionage some attention, finally.
Anti-gun push: A reporter calls for all guns to be banned, CBS came at
safety locks from the left, arguing the Senate did not go far enough, and
NBC's Matt Lauer tried to get some school violence victims to advocate
gun control, but they refused to follow the liberal media line:
-- The Washington
Post's Juan Williams on the May 23 Fox News Sunday: "I don't
understand why we're piddling around. We should talk about getting rid
of guns in this country."
-- Wyatt Andrews
took on gun locks Friday night on the CBS Evening News, contending the
Senate did not go far enough because the law does not mandate their use by
"Which is another loophole. Legally the
buyers can throw the locks away. If the Senate proposal becomes law
thousands of handguns every year will then be sold with these trigger or
safety devices but with no requirement that the gun buyer actually use
them. The Safe Lock Amendment, in other words, won't make guns safe and
doesn't mean the guns will be locked."
-- Friday morning,
MRC analyst Mark Drake noticed, Today co-host Matt Lauer tried to get two
Springfield, Oregon school shooting survivors to back gun control. Check
out this exchange:
Lauer: "Has this experience, Tony, changed
your opinion of guns and gun control issues?"
Survivor Tony Case: "No. Definitely not. I
really don't see the problem as being a gun problem as much as a people
problem, society problem but I don't think [blaming] guns is really the
answer, to regulate guns. I'm a hunter and everything so I'm, I'll all for
freedom to have guns and that sort of thing so."
Lauer: "So this was Kip Kinkel's problem,
not a gun problem in your opinion?"
Lauer: "You feel the same way Teresa?"
Survivor Teresa Miltonberger: "Yeah. Ahuh."
Monday night at 8:30p ET/PT, 7:30pm CT/MT, CBS will broadcast the 1995
movie The American President. It couldn't be more timely for liberals
with its advocacy of gun control.
Read no further if
you plan to watch the movie and don't want to know the plot ahead of
As reported in the
May 14 CyberAlert last year, Rob Reiner directed and produced the film
starring Michael Douglas as Democratic President "Andrew
Shepard," a widow with a teenage daughter. Just like Clinton sans
Hillary. He falls in love with environmental lobbyist "Sydney Ellen
Wade," played by Annette Bening. At one point in the Oval Office
"Wade" lectures "Shepard": "Global warming is a
calamity, the effects of which will be second only to nuclear war..."
President carrying on an affair provides an angle for the Republican
candidate for President to attack. The Republican: Senator "Bob
Rumson" from Kansas. Sound familiar? Richard Dreyfuss plays
"Rumson," an odious man bent on twisting the facts to make
character an issue.
Naturally, by the
end of the movie the wavering "Shepard" comes to his senses and
becomes a forceful liberal. Motivated by losing "Wade" who is
disappointed by his compromises, "Shepard" goes to the press
room and delivers a lecture fulfilling a liberal's dream, denouncing
"Rumson's" character attack on "Wade" for once
having been at a South Africa protest where a U.S. flag was burned,
praising the ACLU, advocating huge cuts in emissions to solve the global
warming problem and demanding the end of gun ownership. Here are some
-- "Yes, I am
a card carrying member of the ACLU, but the more important question is why
aren't you Bob? Now this is an organization whose sole purpose is to
defend the bill of rights, so it naturally begs the question why would a
Senator, his party's most powerful spokesman and a candidate for
President, choose to reject upholding the Constitution?"
-- He announces,
"White House resolution 455, an energy bill requiring a 20 percent
reduction in the emission of fossil fuels over the next ten years. It is
by far the most aggressive stride ever taken in the fight to reverse the
effects of global warming.
"The other piece of legislation is the crime
bill. As of today it no longer exists. I'm throwing it. I'm throwing
it out and writing a law that makes sense. You cannot address crime
prevention without getting rid of assault weapons and handguns. I consider
them a threat to national security and I will go door-to-door if I have to
but I'm going convince Americans that I'm right and I'm going to get
+++ Watch this
Hollywood fantasy scene of the kind of President they can only dream of.
Go to the MRC home page Monday morning where MRC Webmaster Sean Henry will
post a RealPLayer clip from the movie as shown last summer on TBS. Go to: http://www.mrc.org
A little long today, but I felt it was important
to get all the fundraising and China coverage in before the Cox Report is
released on Tuesday, and the CBS movie schedule won't wait. --
Support the MRC, an educational foundation dependent upon contributions
which make CyberAlert possible, by providing a tax-deductible
donation. Use the secure donations page set up for CyberAlert
readers and subscribers:
>>>To subscribe to CyberAlert, send a
blank e-mail to:
@topica.com. Or, you can go to:
Either way you will receive a confirmation message titled: "RESPONSE
REQUIRED: Confirm your subscription to firstname.lastname@example.org."
After you reply, either by going to the listed Web page link or by simply
hitting reply, you will receive a message confirming that you have been
added to the MRC CyberAlert list. If you confirm by using the Web page
link you will be given a chance to "register" with Topica. You
NOT have to do this; at that point you are already subscribed to
To unsubscribe, send a blank e-mail to:
Send problems and comments to: email@example.com.
can learn what has been posted each day on the MRC's Web site by
subscribing to the "MRC Web Site News" distributed every weekday
afternoon. To subscribe, send a blank e-mail to: firstname.lastname@example.org.
Or, go to: http://www.mrc.org/newsletters.<<<
Home | News Division
| Bozell Columns | CyberAlerts
Media Reality Check | Notable Quotables | Contact
the MRC | Subscribe