Tragedy Overkill; Koppel's Idea of "Objective"; PBS on Y2K
1) The day care center
shooting in suburban Los Angeles dominated the morning shows yesterday,
especially NBC's Today.
2) Good Morning America's
hosts considered getting federal agents more heavily involved in domestic
3) Monday's and Tuesday's
Nightline shows on health care and gun control demonstrated Ted Koppel's
skewed idea of "objective reality."
4) Liberal-dominated PBS is
represented by the NewsHour's discussion with four regular essayists on
what issues should be front and center in the 2000 campaign.
5) Washington Post TV critic
Tom Shales jokes about the synchronicity of Charlton Heston's ideological
Forget the old local news motto "If it bleeds, it leads." If it
bleeds, it can take the whole show. The day care center shooting in
suburban Los Angeles dominated yesterday's morning shows. Take a look at
the Today lineup MRC analyst Mark Drake witnessed yesterday. Clearly, the
new title ought to be "America's Most Wanted":
1. Day care shooting news report.
2. Day care shooting interview.
3. Day care shooting interview.
4. Day care shooting news report.
5. Day care shooting interview.
6. Day care shooting interview.
1. Day care shooting anchor brief.
2. Something different? A Columbine High School anchor brief.
3. Eclipse anchor brief.
4. Day care shooting interview: Do the media overcover day care shootings?
5. Columbine High School newsreport.
6. Eclipse interview.
1. Day care shooting news report.
2. Columbine High School anchor brief.
3. Report on school shooting perpetrator in Conyers, Georgia.
4. Anchor brief on New York City shooting of a bank robber by police.
5. Eclipse anchor brief.
6. Day care shooting interview.
7. News report on beating death of gay soldier Barry Winchell.
8. Interview on beating death of gay soldier Barry Winchell.
1. Interview on kid who sings at major league baseball games.
2. Dick Clark interview.
3. Interview on auction of vintage cars.
Perhaps Today is
an acronym for Tragedy Overkill Designed to Attract Yuppies.
On ABC's "Good Morning America," anchors Antonio Mora and Nancy
Snyderman used the day care shooting as an occasion to advocate more
government intervention. Mora asked Los Angeles mayor Richard Riordan:
"People all across the country, especially parents, were horrified at
seeing this kind of thing happen. You-Never would you think this kind of
thing would happen at a day care center or at a camp where little, little
kids are that this kind of thing could occur. You yesterday had said that
you thought there is a need for stricter gun control laws. Exactly what do
you think should be done?"
Later in the 7
o'clock hour, Snyderman advocated that federal agents get heavily involved
in domestic surveillance of the Internet: "With so much of the focus
now on splinter groups and use of the web and people being able to isolate
themselves into these little pockets of hatred and I know this will not be
popular with civil libertarians but in my not very technical mind it
raises to me, the role of the FBI, being able to monitor the hate web
sites and keep track of who logs into those so you get some idea. Even if
it's a loner whose accessing this stuff and then profiling people. They
can profile people--"
"Maybe they should do that. It is obviously a constantly balancing
act. This is the coutry that is probably the freest on the earth and we
value that tremendously."
Snyderman: "But we profile people that do
Mora: "Right. So maybe there should be
stronger efforts made to make sure this kind of thing doesn't happen in
the future, The groups that preach this kind of hatred."
Snyderman: "The continuing attempt to put
some reason into this absolute insanity."
Webmaster Sean Henry will post this video clip later today at www.mrc.org.
Just in case you
thought all these proposed crackdowns would result in tougher punishment
of criminals, check out Tuesday night's "Rivera Live" on CNBC,
where substitute host David Gregoryasked defense lawyer Larry Pozner about
Conyers shooter T.J. Solomon: "Larry, is there not anybody who should
be willing, especially on the government side, a prosecutor, to say and to
recognize that maybe this is someone who needs help and doesn't need to be
MRC analyst Jessica Anderson noticed that "Nightline" used its
air time on Monday and Tuesday nights to promote liberal agendas on health
care and gun control. She prepared this report:
dealt with the dueling television ads on the "Patients' Bill of
Rights," beginning with a report by Chris Bury about the messages
contained in ads by both sides, and the accuracy of them, featuring
professor Kathleen Hall Jamieson. The show slipped downward from there,
though, when Ted Koppel nnounced after Bury's report, "In our search
tonight for objective reality, if not truth, we'll be talking with two
experts on HMO reform, including ABC's own medical editor, Dr. Tim
Johnson, when we come back."
Johnson has proven himself in the past to be infamously left-leaning in
the health care debate, especially during the days of the "Clinton
Care." Some examples, pulled from our Notable Quotables archive:
In 1993: "I
say the Clintons are almost heroes in my ind for finally facing up to the
terrible problems we have with our current health care system and bringing
it to the attention of the public....Most people, I think, will be better
off." -- ABC Medical Editor Dr. Tim Johnson, September 24 20/20.
"Everyone is applauding, I think, in the health care community, the
emphasis on universal access, because they know that unless they're going
to let some people just die in the streets, it makes sense to get medical
care early, when it's going to be more effective and less costly....the
insurance companies are the focal point for the dynamics of denial that
are part of our present for-profit system." -- ABC medical editor Dr.
Tim Johnson, January 26, 1994 World News Tonight.
expert on the "truth" about HMO reform that night: Dr. Robert
Blendon, a professor at Harvard's School of Public Health, and a former
pollster for First Lady Hillary Clinton's health care team. Examples of
some of his past work:
June 12, 1993: The
Hartford Courant reports that a poll by Harvard's Robert Blendon, funded
by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, finds the yearning for security
"will be a powerful factor in shaping public attitudes during the
forthcoming national debate...to the extent that Americans see that sense
of security threatened by a deepening health care crisis, they will be far
more likely to endorse significant actions to reform the health care
system." Security became a major part of Clinton's health appeal.
1993: The Washington Post reports on polls used by the Clinton
administration to sell their health plan to the public. "In tests he
conducted as part of a survey he directed for the Robert Wood Johnson
Foundation, Blendon's team 'found that once people are told that the
uninsured were working people, people just like them, support for a health
reform plan increased dramatically, it no longer is just an abstract moral
issue; it becomes personalized.'"
Koppel opened and
closed the segment by asking both Blendon and Johnson about their views on
the uninsured: "Dr. Blendon, I'm going to start with something that I
know concerns both you and Tim greatly, and that is the issue of the 43,
45 million people in this country who have no health coverage
To Johnson, Koppel
urged: "And to bring things back to where we began, and Tim you get
the last word on this, what you're really worried about is those 43
million people without any kind of insurance."
"Absolutely. That not only is a moral outrage, it actually, in the
long run, raises costs because these people don't get care early on when
they could be more easily treated. They wait till they really get sick,
then it's more difficult and costs more. Ultimately, though, the most
important point is it's morally wrong."
Dr. Robert Blendon
immediately chimed in to repeat his support of Johnson's statement:
Tuesday's shooting at the North Valley Jewish Community Center in Los
Angeles, Koppel immediately opened his show that night by touting the
usual statistics often used by gun control advocates: "We will get to
this morning's sad incident in Los Angeles in a moment. I'd just like to
have you have a little context, something that suggests that it doesn't
have to be this way. In 1996, handguns were used to murder two people in
New Zealand, 15 in Japan, 30 in Great Britain, 106 in Canada, 213 in
Germany and 9,390 here in the United States. And those, mind you, are just
the murders involving the use of handguns."
After a review of
the day's events by correspondent Brian Rooney, Koppel hosted his second
left-leaning panel of the week: Chief Norm Stamper of the Seattle Police
Department and Deputy Chief Constable Gary Greer of the Vancouver Police
Department, both strong advocates of gun control. The discussion centered
mainly around the differences between U.S. and Canadian laws concerning
gus, since Canada views firearms ownership as a privilege, not a right,
and toward the end, Koppel was beginning to sound as if he wanted to go
the Canadian route: "We have, and I think I've got this number right,
we have roughly 190 million guns in this country, here in the United
States. So the idea of ever getting to the kind of level at which Canada
is operating is probably too late. I mean, can you foresee any kind of
conditions, Chief Stamper, under which we might put that genie back in the
bottle again or need to?"
editorial agenda, according to Nightline's web site, was on training in
the U.S. military, so perhaps we shall find a respite from the liberal
agendas of the past 2 nights.
To give viewers a chance to see just how unanimously slanted their cast of
essayists is, PBS's NewsHour with Jim Lehrer brought them on as a group
August 10 to discuss issues they'd like to see addressed during the 2000
campaign. MRC intern Ken Shepherd noticed they all had a liberal point to
columnist Clarence Page complained: "If candidates and their
pollsters and advisers say, 'What's the biggest bloc we can get?' So they
go for like suburban middle class swing voters, right? Who does that leave
out? It leaves out people who need government the most: children, needy
children, urban poor, rural poor, folks who are the victims of a
multi-tiered educational system. We're the only industrial country I know
of that says you buy your school when you buy your house, you know. If you
live in a really good neighborhood you get great schools. If you live in a
not-so-great neighborhood where you really need an education the most,
your schools are not as good as other schools are, where you really need
an education the most, your schools are not as good as other schools
Anne Taylor Fleming chimed in by pushing one of the Democrats' favorite
initiatives, school construction: "I would love to se them talk
obviously about education. I don't know if any of you go to your local
public schools, I mean, they are a shambles. Public parks, infrastructure,
health care, all of the gut level issues. And the terrible tragedy to me
is we've sat atop this economic boom time. Crime is down, we're at peace,
never was there a better opportunity to try and look ahead and say, gee,
what do we want to do. And even we're seeing it with this surplus
discussion. I mean it's not breaking free. I mean, Clinton's talking his
usual cliches about yeah I'm going to veto this giving all the surplus
back in tax breaks but we're not really saying, what do we want to do with
this surplus, where should it go, how should it be spent?"
Former top U.S.
News editor Roger Rosenblatt stayed on his Johnny One-Note call for a gun
ban: "I think the candidate that comes the closest not to gun control
but to gun elimination is going to garner a surprising number of votes.
Not just Columbine, not just the terrible incidents in Alabama and Atlanta
recently but going back over 30 years and no more than 30 years, this has
been the most destructive force and the most dramatically, sometimes
melodramatically destructive force in the news."
Service columnist Richard Rodriguez declared that social issues like
homosexuality have no place in the debate, and conservatives should be
properly assigned more acceptable topics: "There is a conversation
that America needs to have and it is not going to come during this
presidential campaign. It is a conversation that does or does not take
place in the American house between parents and children. And the
conversation that we have at the political level, that we have on Meet the
Press on a Sunday morning with these self -appointed chaplains like Bill
Bennett or Trent Lott talking about my homosexuality or Dianne Feinstein
talking about gun control. These people are properly talking, or what
should I say, they should be properly assigned certainissues to discuss
but we should not be confused about the relationship of our own lives to
more intimate, more personal issues and conversations that the politicians
have no right to intrude in."
On a lighter note, in the wake of all these news reports pushing gun
control, the MRC's Tom Johnson notes that Washington Post TV critic Tom
Shales reviewed a Showtime film by Barry Levinson titled "Yesterday's
Tomorrows." Among the featured speakers in the film, Shales found
"Perennial nuisance Charlton Heston pops up to declare that there are
'too many people on Earth as it is' and one realizes instantly that as
president of the National Rifle Association, he is doing his best to
The last time Shales was this animated, he was
lamenting what he called the "high-tech crucifixion" of Bill
Support the MRC, an educational foundation dependent upon contributions
which make CyberAlert possible, by providing a tax-deductible
donation. Use the secure donations page set up for CyberAlert
readers and subscribers:
>>>To subscribe to CyberAlert, send a
blank e-mail to:
@topica.com. Or, you can go to:
Either way you will receive a confirmation message titled: "RESPONSE
REQUIRED: Confirm your subscription to firstname.lastname@example.org."
After you reply, either by going to the listed Web page link or by simply
hitting reply, you will receive a message confirming that you have been
added to the MRC CyberAlert list. If you confirm by using the Web page
link you will be given a chance to "register" with Topica. You
NOT have to do this; at that point you are already subscribed to
To unsubscribe, send a blank e-mail to:
Send problems and comments to: email@example.com.
can learn what has been posted each day on the MRC's Web site by
subscribing to the "MRC Web Site News" distributed every weekday
afternoon. To subscribe, send a blank e-mail to: firstname.lastname@example.org.
Or, go to: http://www.mrc.org/newsletters.<<<
Home | News Division
| Bozell Columns | CyberAlerts
Media Reality Check | Notable Quotables | Contact
the MRC | Subscribe