ABC on Court: "Conservative"; Nets Countered Bush Claims of Hand Count Problems; CBS Gave Uncritical Airing to Re-Vote Demands
1) Peter Jennings on the Florida
Supreme Court: "Only one of the judges is considered to be a liberal, the
rest are regarded as moderate to conservative."
2) NBC and CBS ruled the Bush team fouled in claiming any
mischief in the Palm Beach County recount. NBC's Jim Avila contended:
"Individual counters, interviewed before the GOP made those high-profile
charges, told NBC News the system...is working." Avila's expert
witnesses: A Democrat and a Green Party member.
3) Time's Jack White compared Katherine Harris unfavorably
to the guy who leaked the Bush drunk driving story. Newsweek's Eleanor Clift
made herself more partisan than even a Democratic political operative in
dismissing Harris's motives as purely partisan.
4) Al Hunt denounced Bill Bennett on Capital Gang for daring
to criticize Gore's strategy: "Bill Bennett puts on his virtue hat
whether there's not a political election and then he puts on his partisan hat
when we have an election. Bill, you got your talking points from Austin on
this."
5) "Re-vote! Re-vote!" Friday night the CBS Evening
News delivered a one-sided story sympathetic to a few Palm Beach County voters
who were unable to vote or couldn't figure out how to vote.
6) "The Woodstein Myth Is Dead: Corruption is king."
In a piece for National Review Online, the MRC's Tim Graham suggested:
"Those who insist on following the letter of the law are presented as
arbitrary and partisan. Those who insist on changing the rules arbitrarily to
match their advantage are presented as the forces of fairness and
deliberation."
7) NBC's Saturday Night Live: "Among the types of
ballots that will now be counted fore Gore: indented ballots, ballots left
completely blank and ballots marked 'Bush.'"
1
The
Florida Supreme Court is packed with moderates and conservatives, with
just one liberal, ABC's Peter Jennings assured World News Tonight
viewers on Friday night:
"We, by the way, tried to avoid labeling people this week but
here's a quick take up on the make up of the Florida Supreme Court.
There are seven justices. Six were appointed by Democratic Governors. Our
legal analyst in Florida tells us that only one of the judges is
considered to be a liberal, the rest are regarded as moderate to
conservative. The court has been engaged in a running battle with the
Florida legislature, which has a Republican majority, over separation of
powers, judicial versus legislative."
I think his effort to avoid labeling failed last
week.
At another point in Friday's show Jennings passed
along the interesting numbers that if only men voted, Bush would have won
by 437 to 101 electoral votes and if only women voted Gore would have won
by 369 to 163 electoral votes.
2
NBC and
CBS ruled the Bush team fouled in claiming any mischief in the Palm Beach
County recount. On Saturday night, Jim Avila
contended: "Individual counters, interviewed before the GOP made
those high-profile charges, told NBC News the system, while slow, is
working." Avila's expert witnesses: A Democrat and a Green Party
member. The next night, CBS reporter Jim Axelrod assured viewers:
"Bob Lemon is a 71-year-old Texas lawyer who paid his own way here to
be a Democratic observer. If there's truly bad blood or intentional bad
counting, he hasn't seen it."
From Palm Beach County, on the November 18 NBC
Nightly News, Jim Avila portrayed an open process incompatible with the
GOP charges of improprieties and suggested any complaints were a PR stunt:
"TV cameras, even the public watch. Every vote counted in full view.
But today, as if on cue, immediately after that Bush campaign news
conference, Republican observers emerged to make accusations about rampant
human error and worse."
Man: "We have
found Bush votes ready to be counted as Gore votes."
Avila: "But
individual counters, interviewed before the GOP made those high-profile
charges, told NBC News the system, while slow, is working."
Tanya Davis-Johnson,
Democratic counter: "We cannot cause mischief."
Avila: "Tanya
Davis-Johnson, back for her second shift today as a Democratic
counter."
Davis-Johnson:
"There's no room for mischief. Your hands are on top of the table
at all time. There's no objects at our stations to poke through or to
change a vote."
Avila: "In
fact, in Palm Beach County, the actual counters and observers make no
judgment calls at all. Their job: simply look for cleanly punched ballots
with no hanging chads, put those in either a Bush or Gore pile, and move
on. Any ballots with swinging, hanging, dimpled or otherwise controversial
chads are put in a separate pile for the election canvassing board to
decide upon later. Before the Bush campaign allegations, this Republican
counter was asked if she saw opportunities for tampering."
Woman: "Four
people are looking at every single card, front and back."
Avila: "Green
Party observer June Brashares, neither a Gore nor Bush supporter, says she
witnessed no skulduggery."
Brashares: "If
you stand too near a stack of ballots, people will tell you to step back.
So I haven't seen anything as far as tampering."
Sunday night on the CBS Evening News Jim Axelrod
showed how orderly and open things are inside the counting room, but
"outside, the ever-hungry press is being fed a steady diet of
rhetoric that is rapidly turning ugly. Jennifer Garcia is a Republican
observer who says the tension is growing and the counters are
biased."
Garcia: "I know
that my Democrat counter was questioning me on my objections and was the
one responsible for placing Bush ballots in the Gore pile."
Axelrod countered:
"What 'round the clock cameras show inside are two volunteer
counters from different parties watched by two observers from different
parties. Only after everyone agrees on which hole's been punched is a
card placed in a pile that's counted twice, then the pile is held up to
the light to make sure no Bush ballots end up in the Gore pile or vice
versa....Bob Lemon is a 71-year-old Texas lawyer who paid his own way here
to be a Democratic observer. If there's truly bad blood or intentional
bad counting, he hasn't seen it."
Lemon: "I think
this is as near a perfect count as you could have."
Well, if a Democrat committed enough to Gore's
cause to pay his own way from Texas didn't see anything, how could
anyone suggest otherwise?
3
Katherine
Harris came under some fire from pundits on the weekend talk shows.
Time's Jack White declared her more relevant and partisan than the guy
who leaked the Bush drunk driving story and Newsweek's Eleanor Clift
made herself more partisan than even a Democratic political operative in
dismissing her motives as purely partisan.
-- Inside Washington. Time national correspondent
Jack White:
"Republicans
made a big deal when the drunk driving story came out right before the
election, about the connections to the guy up in Maine who supposedly
leaked all that. This woman is a heck of a lot more tied in with the Bush
campaign than that fella ever was. She campaigned for him, she was his
co-chairman in Florida, she expects an ambassadorship, a lot of people
think, or she wants to run for the Senate. Clearly she's a
partisan."
-- McLaughlin Group. John McLaughlin asked:
"Are Harris's motives predominantly partisan or is she
predominantly following the law as she understands it?"
Eleanor Clift answered: "She's a partisan
player and proud of it."
But Lawrence O'Donnell, a veteran aide to
Democrats and a current TV commentator who has never been a journalist,
had more respect for Harris: "In this drama she's been following
the law very carefully and scrupulously. In her life as a politician she
supports George W. Bush. It is impossible to find a politician in America
who doesn't support either Al Gore or George W. Bush. They can't all
vacate their offices."
4
Things
got pretty heated on CNN's special hour-long Capital Gang on Saturday
night when Mark Shields and Al Hunt took umbrage at guest Bill Bennett's
contention that Al Gore's operatives are "stealing" the
election and are employing "thuggish tactics." Hunt pretended to
criticize both sides equally, but his emotional reaction to Bennett's
conservative views betrayed which side his heart truly favors.
Hunt, Executive Washington Editor of the Wall Street
Journal, proposed near the beginning of
the November 18 show: "I'll tell you this, if Al Gore wins the
presidency because he emerges ahead in selective recounts in Florida or if
George Bush wins it because his Florida co-chairman, the now infamous Mrs.
Harris is able to determine who does and doesn't countdown there, it's
going to be an illegitimate prize. And I think what the Florida Supreme
Court may try to do is insist on some sort of statewide recount, which
would give it a little more legitimacy."
Time's Margaret Carlson soon argued that "Al
Gore should have insisted and somehow convinced the Bush campaign to
recount all counties" and "the Bush campaign should have
insisted and begged Katherine Harris to recuse herself, to have the
co-chair of the Bush campaign in the position of trying to call who won
the election, so brazenly hurt the Bush campaign and if they had certified
the election today on the basis of her say so, the legitimacy would have
been undercut from the outset of any Bush presidency."
Moderator Mark Shields piped in: "Last time we
saw Katherine Harris politically she was in New Hampshire campaigning for
George W. Bush."
That prompted Bill Bennett to contend: "You run
for Secretary of State and she won the election. And Republicans and
Democrats run. And if a Republican runs, she has the authority of the
office; if a Democrat runs, he or she has the authority of the office. Her
decision was so arbitrary, it was backed by a Democratic judge. Let me be
frank, even franker than Bob. This may be the worse thing I've ever seen.
I think you know I praise Democrats when I think they do the right thing,
criticize Republicans when I think they do the wrong thing. Al Gore is
trying to steal this election.
"Wednesday
morning, Bill Daley stood up and said the campaign goes on. And that's
what is going on, a campaign. And it's got all the earmarks, not just of
Al Gore but of Clinton-Gore -- personal assassination. You want to talk
about Katherine Harris, Chip Reid on NBC reports that a high-ranking
member of the Gore campaign said if Harris's certification goes ahead, our
case against her will make Whitewater look like a picnic.
"I know you
guys don't like Bush, I know you don't want Republicans to win, but you
have got to call these thug tactics. You can laugh about it. You can say
it's illegitimate if George Bush becomes President, I think it's
illegitimate if Al Gore becomes President because of what he has done. But
if you don't call the kind the thuggish tactics that the Gore campaign is
using now for what they are, the notion of objectivity in the media is
gone."
Shields shot back: "Bill, I just cannot
disagree more strenuously. In the first place, Al Gore as we sit here
leads in the nation, popular vote. Al Gore has more electoral votes than
George W. Bush. There is no question that hand counting is more accurate
than machine counting. There's no question about that."
Bennett: "I'm
sorry. Is that just dogmatic?"
Shields lectured:
"You can sit there from your Olympian perch and issue your moral
thunderbolts, but the fact of the matter is you and I vote in the same
precinct. Do you think the people there are corrupt? Is that what you
think they are? Do you think they're corrupt?"
Bennett: "Your
arguments are ad hominum."
Shields:
"They're not ad hominum."
Bennett: "To
attack me being Olympian...The issue isn't the popular vote, Mark. Maybe
it sounds Olympian to you. The issue is electoral votes. That's the
Constitution. That's the way it works. It's not finished because they
won't let them finish. George Bush won that election in Florida. He won it
on the recount. Now we are going through the multiple hand counting in
different districts and you know what the chaos that that has created, but
don't insult me personally.
Bennett's points were too much for Hunt, who
jumped in to denigrate Bennett: "Listen, Bill Bennett puts on his
virtue hat whether there's not a political election and then he puts on
his partisan hat when we have an election. Bill, you got your talking
points from Austin on this."
Bennett: "I
don't."
Hunt: "I mean,
basically, for you to talk about Mark being ad hominum when you talk about
Al Gore stealing, Al Gore's a thug. I'm sorry. Wait Bob I'm going to
finish."
Bob Novak:
"Let's not insult people."
Bennett: "I can
fend for myself."
Hunt: "I'm
going to basically say that both these guys have exhibited a win at any
cost mindset. And there's no difference and to try to make moral
distinctions here is really hypocritical."
Bennett asked:
"Let me ask you about that. Where is the character assassination on
the part of the Bush campaign? Where is the character assassination?"
Hunt: "Stealing
the election -- thugs stealing the election. If that's not a character
assassination I don't know what it is."
Bennett: "Who
has personally been attacked in the way Katherine Harris has been
attacked?"
The heated argument continued. Later, Carlson
sarcastically remarked: "The character assassination that's going on
towards the Democrats and from the Republicans is that these people sworn
in to count the votes are considered to
be stealing it by, you know, they're thugs, they're fraudulent, they're
stacking the deck. There are more video cameras in that room than in a Las
Vegas casino. You can't cheat."
+++ Watch an enraged Hunt take on Bennett. Late
Monday morning MRC Webmaster Andy Szul will post a RealPlayer video clip
from Capital Gang. Go to: http://archive.mrc.org
5
"Re-vote!
Re-vote!" Friday night the CBS Evening News delivered a one-sided
story sympathetic to a few Palm Beach County voters who were unable to
vote or were too stupid to figure out how to vote. CBS, of course,
withheld any negative judgment about them or allowed any time for anyone
to point out that voter registration list errors or ballot confusion is no
reason to void an election.
Reporter Bobbi
Harley began her piece by reporting how in a Palm Beach County
courtroom "Judge Jorge Labarga faced the issue that many Palm
Beach voters say is the only fair way to find out who won: not a
recount-"
Group of
protestors: "Re-vote! Re-vote!"
Harley picked
up: "But a re-vote. A whole new election here that would almost
certainly give Al Gore a victory in Florida. At the center of the
argument, the legality of the so-called butterfly ballot. At stake:
thousands of votes."
Harley asked some women: "How was the
atmosphere at the polling places, confusion?"
Clara Green:
"Very, very much."
Another piped
up: "Very confusing."
Harley: "For these registered voters, it
was worse than confusing. Clara Green stood in line for two hours,
only to be told her name wasn't on the voter rolls at her precinct. No
one could straighten out her problem because election hot lines were
jammed with questions about the ballot."
Green: "This is my voter registration card,
been having it for, since 1966. I should have been able to vote."
Harley: "Even a veteran Republican poll
worker, who doesn't support a re-vote, admits it was a nearly
unmanageable scene on November 7th."
Eleanor Paules:
"It bothers me. They took the trouble to come out, you know. They
wanted to vote, and I hated them to lose that privilege."
Apparently alluding to the butterfly ballot,
voter Lena Rahming complained: "That type of ballot should have
never, never been produced, never."
Harley: "Do
you think that changed the results of this election?"
Rahming:
"It definitely did."
Harley
concluded: "Next week, the judge will rule on those lawsuits. If
he finds no legal grounds to support a re-vote, he told lawyers today,
it will be the most difficult decision of his life."
6
"The
Woodstein Myth Is Dead: Corruption is king." In a piece for
National Review Online posted on Friday, the MRC's Tim Graham
suggested: "Those who insist on following the letter of the law
are presented as arbitrary and partisan. Those who insist on changing
the rules arbitrarily to match their advantage are presented as the
forces of fairness and deliberation."
Picking up on the same information cited by Bill
Bennett on Capital Gang about how the Gore team plans to destroy
Katherine Harris, Graham outlined how "the media also cannot be
counted on to referee the tone coming out of the Gore campaign."
To read this piece online, go to:
http://www.nationalreview.com/comment/comment111700d.shtml
Now the text of the November 17 posting:
Many of us who grew up in the 1970s had it drubbed into our heads
that journalism is a heroic profession that roots out corruption and
wins the day for democracy. Its popular-culture zenith was the movie
All the President's Men, in which our cinematic heroes Bob Woodward
and Carl Bernstein saved the day for democracy by exposing the corrupt
presidency of Richard Nixon. Unstated in this carefully calibrated
myth is that corruption never roamed the country when John Kennedy was
elected in 1960 with the help of vote fraud in Texas and Illinois, or
when Lyndon Johnson brought his vulgar appetites for power to bear on
a Democrat-dominated Washington. (Grab a dog-eared copy of Victor
Lasky's It Didn't Start with Watergate if you're too young to
remember, like I am.)
In the 1980s, the national media once again celebrated itself as
the slayer of the "sleaze factor," the guardians of the
nation's political ethics. Iran-Contra was to be elevated into a
crisis in which Daniel Inouye and Warren Rudman saved the Constitution
from Ronald Reagan's depredations. But throughout the 1990s and into
the new century, the Woodstein myth is dead, a corpse beaten beyond
recognition. Over the last eight years, the media have downplayed
every scandalous revelation, mangled every corruption allegation into
a morass of moral equivalence, and portrayed undeniably corrupt people
(start with Webster Hubbell or Susan McDougal) as sympathetic victims
of shadowy prosecutors who sing hymns as they jog. Corruption is king,
and the media are a very callous
palace court. Woodward and Bernstein buried this myth themselves
by responding to the Clinton scandals with Carvillesque derision
and lame excuses.
It may dismay us, but it should not surprise us, that the media
have treated this current impasse with this same morally upside-down
interpretation. Those who insist on following the letter of the law
are presented as arbitrary and partisan. Those who insist on changing
the rules arbitrarily to match their advantage are presented as the
forces of fairness and deliberation.
Just this morning, ABC's Charles Gibson was pressing the case of
the dimpled-chad brigades of Palm Beach County as the forces of
fairness. He asked Florida Agricultural Commissioner Bob Crawford:
"To declare that [the race is certified as a Bush victory], but
wouldn't that be terribly awkward if you got into a situation where
these counties produced a different result than you've certified over
the weekend?" Gibson's question doesn't consider that perhaps the
awkward-looking side ought to be the side that's still attempting to
recount Gore into the winner's circle ten days after
the election is over.
Typically, the media also cannot be counted on to referee the tone
coming out of the Gore campaign, even though Gore claimed on Wednesday
night that he wants both sides to calm down. Last night on MSNBC,
reporter Chip Reid told Brian Williams: "If they do not succeed
here, there was some interesting, even chilling talk today, I thought,
from the Gore campaign. I talked to some aides there. One said that if
George Bush does win, and win with the help of Katherine Harris, and
Katherine Harris, they believe, will throw more road blocks in the
way, and will do everything in her power to certify the election in
favor of George Bush, and do everything
in her power to make sure that that happens, they said that if George
Bush does get into office with her help, the investigation into her
role and this entire situation will make Whitewater look like a
picnic. So they are already planning for the possibility that they
lose here, and this turns into some kind of massive investigation
after the fact. The ugliness would continue long after this is
over." This revelation didn't even make the first hour of NBC's
Today Show this morning.
The networks aren't buzzing about what conservatives are buzzing
about: Gore flack Paul Begala's shameful commentary on MSNBC.com suggesting that Bush states are in red
because those are the states where James Byrd was dragged to death,
where the gay men Matthew Shepard and Barry Winchell were beaten to
death, and where "neo-Nazi skinheads murdered two
African-Americans because of their skin color." Is that Gore's
dream of stepping down the rhetoric?
In a typical media laugh line, Ted Koppel began a Nightline last
August by complaining that Clinton's low personal approval ratings
would mar Gore's reputation. "Al Gore has been perhaps the most
active vice president in American history, and there's not a hint of
scandal associated with Gore's personal behavior." If media stars
like Koppel can tell people to ignore the illegal Buddhist Temple
fundraising, the iced-tea toilet excusing, the Warnecke house
pot-smoking, the Vietnam-with-a-bodyguard touring, the Tennessee
tenant-trashing, the Internet-inventor boasting, the Farrakhan
finessing, and the secret Russia-to-Iran arms dealing, to list a few,
certainly they can ignore the Harris trashing and the election
stealing.
END Reprint
The Chip Reid related threat to Harris and Paul
Begala's tirade are not the only examples of bile from the Gore
camp. In their Thursday, November 16 daily e-mail report, National
Review's John J. Miller & Ramesh Ponnuru relayed:
"The
election is over (sort of), but the race baiting never ends. Here's
Gore campaign manager Donna Brazile, in today's New York Post: 'In
disproportionately black areas, people faced dogs, guns and were
required to have three forms of ID. I called the NAACP. They'd already
heard this, and they're now on the case investigating. I mean, one day
before we were ahead in Florida by three points and we lost? It's like
uh-oh, somebody's doing something they shouldn't.'
"People faced dogs and guns? And her evidence
for this is...what?
"Brazile
doesn't have any. At least none that Cindy Adams of the New York Post
shares with readers. It's hard to say who's being more irresponsible:
Brazile, for making such an assertion, or the New York Post, for
letting it appear without any kind of corroboration."
7
Saturday
Night Live comedy writers more perceptive than journalists? Here's
the opening joke from Saturday Night Live's "Weekend
Update" news show, as announced by Jimmy Fallon:
"In Florida tonight the hand count continues and Republicans are
accusing Democrats of changing the rules. Among the types of ballots
that will now be counted for Gore: indented ballots, ballots left
completely blank and ballots marked 'Bush.'"
In reality, possibly more reality than joke. -- Brent Baker
>>>
Support the MRC, an educational foundation dependent upon contributions
which make CyberAlert possible, by providing a tax-deductible
donation. Use the secure donations page set up for CyberAlert
readers and subscribers:
http://www.mrc.org/donate
>>>To subscribe to CyberAlert, send a
blank e-mail to:
mrccyberalert-subscribe
@topica.com. Or, you can go to:
http://www.mrc.org/newsletters.
Either way you will receive a confirmation message titled: "RESPONSE
REQUIRED: Confirm your subscription to mrccyberalert@topica.com."
After you reply, either by going to the listed Web page link or by simply
hitting reply, you will receive a message confirming that you have been
added to the MRC CyberAlert list. If you confirm by using the Web page
link you will be given a chance to "register" with Topica. You
DO
NOT have to do this; at that point you are already subscribed to
CyberAlert.
To unsubscribe, send a blank e-mail to:
cybercomment@mrc.org.
Send problems and comments to: cybercomment@mrc.org.
>>>You
can learn what has been posted each day on the MRC's Web site by
subscribing to the "MRC Web Site News" distributed every weekday
afternoon. To subscribe, send a blank e-mail to: cybercomment@mrc.org.
Or, go to: http://www.mrc.org/newsletters.<<<
Home | News Division
| Bozell Columns | CyberAlerts
Media Reality Check | Notable Quotables | Contact
the MRC | Subscribe
|