6/02: NBC Suggests Bill O'Reilly Fueled Murder of Dr. George Tiller
  6/01: NBC's Williams Cues Up Obama: 'That's One She'd Rather Have Back'
  5/29: Nets Push 'Abortion Rights' Advocates' Concerns on Sotomayor
  5/28: CBS on Sotomayor: 'Can't Be Easily Defined by Political Labels'

  Home
  Notable Quotables
  Media Reality Check
  Press Releases
  Media Bias Videos
  Special Reports
  30-Day Archive
  Entertainment
  News
  Take Action
  Gala and DisHonors
  Best of NQ Archive
  The Watchdog
  About the MRC
  MRC in the News
  Support the MRC
  Planned Giving
  What Others Say
MRC Resources
  Site Search
  Links
  Media Addresses
  Contact MRC
  MRC Bookstore
  Job Openings
  Internships
  News Division
  NewsBusters Blog
  Business & Media Institute
  CNSNews.com
  TimesWatch.org
  Eyeblast.tv

Support the MRC



www.TimesWatch.org


 CyberAlert Weekend Edition

The 1,690th CyberAlert. Tracking Liberal Media Bias Since 1996
Friday April 2, 2004 (Vol. Nine; No. 53)

 
Printer Firendly Version

Tell a friend about this site


1. CBS: Job Slump Driving People to Accept Dangerous Jobs in Iraq
"The long job slump," in George Bush's America, "has left many Americans desperate enough to risk everything for a decent paycheck," CBS's Dan Rather suggested Wednesday night, so some end up paying "the ultimate price." Rather asked: "What drives American civilians to risk death in Iraq? In this economy, it may be, for some, the only job they can find." In Delaware, with 3.4 percent unemployment?

2. Jennings Admits TV Focus on Violence "Overshadows" Gains in Iraq
ABC's Peter Jennings conceded on Thursday night that the media's "focus on the loss of American soldiers and now civilians on a sometimes almost daily basis...overshadows" how "life is improving for people in Iraq in many, many ways." The night before, MSNBC's Keith Olbermann saw the big picture and the deleterious impact of television war coverage as he asked whether TV showing the horrific images of the four American civilians mutilated in Iraq "may be a bad thing for this country, that policy could be unduly influenced by what is, no matter how horrific it is, an event that is counterbalanced by many successes and much progress in Iraq?"

3. NBC Wonders If Liberals "Too Nuanced" to Succeed in Talk Radio
Boring equals "nuanced"? In a Wednesday NBC Nightly News story hyping the debut of the left-wing "Air America" radio network on small stations in a few cities, reporter Carl Quintanilla distorted a point made by conservative talk host Michael Reagan as he channeled liberal denigration of conservatives by contending that liberal talk radio has not yet succeeded because, unlike bombastic conservatives, liberals are "nuanced."

4. CNN's Cafferty & NBC's Leno Mock Idea Media Lack Liberals
CNN's Jack Cafferty and NBC's Jay Leno this week mocked the idea that a liberal talk radio network is needed to give liberal views a forum in the media. On Wednesday's American Morning, Cafferty wondered "whether we really need another liberal media outlet. I mean, if you don't like the New York Times or CBS News, or Peter Jennings, this might be just the ticket for you." When co-host Bill Hemmer inquired "why hasn't a liberal radio station or TV network never taken off before?", Cafferty pointed out: "We have them. Are you, did you just get off a vegetable truck from the South Bronx? They're everywhere!" Cafferty soon reminded his colleagues: "What do they call this joint? The Clinton News Network."

5. Most Say U.S. Safer Than Before 9-11, But WashPost Flips Finding
The Washington Post's false headline. "Americans feel increasingly safe and secure," read the subhead over a section of a report, from the Council for Excellence in Government, about a poll which determined that "nearly half (47%) of all Americans say that the United States is safer today than it was on September 11, 2001," compared to 38 percent a year after 9-11, and a piddling 18 percent said they now feel less safe than before 9-11. The Washington Post's April 1 headline for a story about the findings: "Most Say They Are Less Safe Since 9/11."

6. Moyers Rants Over Bush "Deception," Urges Gore for Bush Cabinet
There are only a few months to go before Bill Moyers retires from PBS, but he's not going quietly. Last week on his Friday night show, he delivered a another left wing "commentary" in which he claimed President Bush's "credibility has been shredded" because of his "deception" over Iraq, warned that "there will come a time when the President will have no one to rely on except his most rabid allies in the right wing media," lamented how privates in Afghanistan and Iraq earn less than $16,000 dollars a year "while here at home the rich get their tax cuts" and recommended "a wartime cabinet to serve a wartime nation" with "Al Gore as head of Homeland Security" and John McCain as Secretary of State.

7. "Top Ten Questions You're Afraid to Ask Condoleezza Rice"
Letterman's "Top Ten Questions You're Afraid to Ask Condoleezza Rice." Plus, CNN/Letterman feud on the yawning kid behind President Bush.


 

CBS: Job Slump Driving People to Accept
Dangerous Jobs in Iraq

CBS's Dan Rather     "The long job slump," in George Bush's America, "has left many Americans desperate enough to risk everything for a decent paycheck," CBS's Dan Rather suggested Wednesday night. So, that is driving people to "risk death in Iraq" by accepting dangerous civilian jobs over there where some end up paying "the ultimate price."

     That man who was killed opposed Bush's war with Iraq, reporter Bob McNamara emphasized as he asked the widow: "Was he for this war?" McNamara insisted that the man's "desperation for work" led him to take the job in Iraq, but he was from Delaware where the unemployment rate is well below the national average.

     After Rather teased the lead March 31 story on the gruesome murder of four U.S. civilian contractors in Fallujah, in which the bodies where burned, hacked apart, dragged and hung up, Rather asked, over the "Risking Death" heading on screen with video of people in a job application line: "What drives American civilians to risk death in Iraq? In this economy, it may be, for some, the only job they can find. [jump to picture of American family] This family paid the ultimate price."

     Setting up the subsequent story after a piece on the gruesome murders, Rather intoned: "Given such risks, it may be hard to see why any civilian would agree to work in Iraq. But as CBS's Bob McNamara reports, among other reasons, the long job slump has left many Americans desperate enough to risk everything for a decent paycheck."

     Over video of a crowd of people, at what turned out to be a Halliburton job hiring session, McNamara began: "The line is hundreds long, job hunters in Houston applying for work as cooks, truck drivers and construction workers in the chaos of Iraq."
     A Man declared: "I'm not afraid. Some of these days I have to go anyway."
     McNamara cautioned: "They're warned the work demands long days and little time off."
     Clark Dunlap, Halliburton recuiter, to those gathered: "It will be living in Hades. Daily air temperature, ambient air temperature, can be 125, 135 degrees.
     McNamara: "Still, the Texas unemployment rate is higher than it is nationwide. And lured by potential tax-free, six-figure incomes, some hadn't even told families they were here."

     In fact, while unemployment in Texas in February stood at 6.1 percent, when it's at 5.6 percent nationwide, that's down from 6.3 percent in January, and in February Texas was amongst the "states that had the largest hiring gains," according to an AP dispatch, gaining 9,600 positions. See this March 31 article: news.yahoo.com

     For state-by-state unemployment rates: news.yahoo.com

     McNamara moved on to the tragic death of a civilian contractor in Iraq: "One thousand miles from Houston and a world apart from Iraq, here in Middletown, Delaware, one family learned ever so tragically where the desperation for work can lead when the job is in the middle of a war."
     Mrs. Linda Linderman, wife of man who was killed: "He said, 'I'm made of steel. I went through Vietnam. I can, you know, I can do this, too.'"
     McNamara: "Fifty-eight-year-old Art Linderman was ambushed by Iraqi insurgents at the wheel of his supply truck, so critically wounded he was on life support before dying in late January."
     McNamara to the man's wife: "Was he for this war?"
     Mrs. Linderman: "No, I don't think he was."
     McNamara: "He was over there to make a living?"
     Mrs. Linderman: "He was over there to make a living, and that's all there was to it."
     McNamara: "Art Linderman had been out of steady work for over two years. In Iraq, he wore a helmet, flak jacket and carried a gun. Any brushes with danger he did have he never let on to his family."
     Art Linderman's son: "You could just basically hear it in his voice that, you know, things weren't good."
     McNamara: "Researchers tracking Iraq's rebuilding estimate at least 30 civilian contract workers have been killed since major hostilities were declared over last may."
     Son: "It's not worth it in the long run."
     Mrs. Linderman: "Money's not everything."
     Son: "No."
     McNamara: "Art Linderman risked his life for a financial nest egg he and his wife could retire on."
     Mrs. Linderman: "Sometimes I feel like the phone's going to ring and it'll be him or he'll come walking through the door."
     McNamara concluded: "And tonight four more Americans also won't be coming home. Bob McNamara, CBS News, Middletown, Delaware."

     Undermining CBS's case that high unemployment is forcing people to risk death in Iraq: The current unemployment rate in Delaware stands at a mere 3.4 percent, much lower than the national average or the rate in Texas.

 

Jennings Admits TV Focus on Violence
"Overshadows" Gains in Iraq

     ABC's Peter Jennings conceded on Thursday night that the media's "focus on the loss of American soldiers and now civilians on a sometimes almost daily basis...overshadows" how "life is improving for people in Iraq in many, many ways." The night before, MSNBC's Keith Olbermann saw the big picture and the deleterious impact of television war coverage as he asked whether TV showing the horrific images of the four American civilians mutilated in Iraq "may be a bad thing for this country, that policy could be unduly influenced by what is, no matter how horrific it is, an event that is counterbalanced by many successes and much progress in Iraq?"
    
     Toward the end of Thursday's Larry King Live on CNN, on which Jennings appeared to plug his Thursday night special about Ecstasy and three-hour Monday night special, Jesus and Paul, King asked him about his impressions of Iraq after returning there a few weeks ago. Jennings replied:
     "One of the really strong impressions I had, having been there for only 10 days, is this strange ambiguity because life is improving for people in Iraq in many, many ways, and the U.S. influence in Iraq is having, in many ways, a very significant influence. Our focus on the loss of American soldiers and now civilians on a sometimes almost daily basis, it gets so intense, somewhat I think overshadows what has been happening, in more general terms, in restructuring or structuring the country."

     For a preview of Jennings' Monday night marathon: abcnews.go.com

     The MRC's Brad Wilmouth caught this question, on the March 31 Countdown on MSNBC, from Olbermann to New Mexico Governor Bill Richardson, who was Bill Clinton's Ambassador to the UN:
     "History now agrees that American policy in Vietnam changed when television began to show what was happening there. We've already talked about its influence in Somalia, it's possible influence regarding Iraq. Can it be argued, shouldn't it be argued that this may be a bad thing for this country, that policy could be unduly influenced by what is, no matter how horrific it is, an event that is counterbalanced by many successes and much progress in Iraq?"

 

NBC Wonders If Liberals "Too Nuanced"
to Succeed in Talk Radio

     Boring equals "nuanced"? In a Wednesday NBC Nightly News story hyping the debut of the left-wing "Air America" radio network on small stations in a few cities, reporter Carl Quintanilla distorted a point made by conservative talk host Michael Reagan as he channeled liberal denigration of conservatives by contending that liberal talk radio has not yet succeeded because, unlike bombastic conservatives, liberals are "too-nuanced."

     Quintanilla recalled in his March 31 story: "Liberals' attempts at radio -- Mario Cuomo, Jerry Brown -- haven't gone very far. Conservative talk show host Michael Reagan says that's because liberals are too-nuanced in their views to be provocative to listeners."
     Michael Reagan: "They listen to us because we're not boring. And liberal radio has a tendency to be boring, if you will."

     Where in Reagan's 20 words did he say that liberals are "too-nuanced"?

 

CNN's Cafferty & NBC's Leno Mock Idea
Media Lack Liberals

     CNN's Jack Cafferty and NBC's Jay Leno this week mocked the idea that a liberal talk radio network is needed to give liberal views a forum in the media.

     On Wednesday's American Morning, Cafferty, a New York City TV station veteran, noted the launch of the "Air America" radio network set for later in the day and then described his "Cafferty File" question of the day: "We'll talk about what that means, and whether we really need another liberal media outlet. I mean, if you don't like the New York Times or CBS News, or Peter Jennings, this might be just the ticket for you."

     Later, when co-host Bill Hemmer wondered "why hasn't a liberal radio station or TV network never taken off before?", Cafferty pointed out: "We have them. Are you, did you just get off a vegetable truck from the South Bronx? They're everywhere!" Cafferty soon reminded his colleagues: "What do they call this joint? The Clinton News Network."

     In the same vein as Cafferty, Leno joked on Monday's Tonight Show: "They say the purpose of Air America will be to balance out all the conservatives in the media, except, of course for NPR, CNN, ABC, CBS, NBC, and the New York Times. Other than that."

     Now, full recitations of the remarks by Cafferty and Leno, starting with Cafferty, whose comments were brought to my attention by Keith Appell of Creative Response Concepts:

     -- CNN's American Morning, March 31. At 7am EST, at the top of the show down from CNN's street-side Manhattan studio, as the three-person hosting team of Cafferty, Soledad O'Brien and Bill Hemmer greeted each other, Cafferty asserted: "How you doing? It's a red-letter day here in America. Air America, that communist radio network, starts broadcasting in a little while."
     O'Brien, who last year jumped to CNN from NBC, interjected: "It's not communist."
     Cafferty: "It's not?"
     O'Brien: "No."
     Cafferty: "Oh."
     O'Brien: "Liberal."
     Cafferty: "Well. Aren't they synonymous? We'll talk about what that means, and whether we really need another liberal media outlet. I mean, if you don't like the New York Times or CBS News, or Peter Jennings, this might be just the ticket for you."
     As Hemmer could be heard saying "Oh my gosh," O'Brien tried to move on: "We're only a minute thirty seconds in."
     Cafferty: "Well, Bill just said let's have a good Wednesday. I'm trying to do my part over here."
     Hemmer: "That's right, you make it very up close and personal."
     O'Brien: "I should have called in sick today..."

     Later, at about 7:26am EST, after Andy Serwer had joined the team on the couches to make a foursome, Cafferty outlined his "Cafferty File" question of the day for viewers to e-mail him with their comments: "If the New York Times and Peter Jennings and perhaps CBS News aren't enough for you, then you're going to love this. The New York Observer reports former Vice President Al Gore is close to the sealing the deal to buy a cable TV channel. Gore's team says they will make the station a, quote, 'youth oriented public affairs channel.' Yes, that should sell pretty well.
     "Can you say liberal? And the liberal talk radio station Air America debuts today. They kick things off at noon. I guess they don't like to get up early over there. Comedian Al Franken is the lead off hitter and he's calling his show 'The O'Franken Factor.' Clever, no? His guests today will include filmmaker Michael Moore, never been interviewed I guess before, that's not exactly a big gamble.
     "Anyway, the question is, does America need additional 'liberal' media outlets? And as Soledad so rightly pointed out to me, that is not synonymous with communist -- they are quite different."
     O'Brien chipped in: "That's right before I said I wish I'd taken the day off. Because we kept going on in that vein and it started getting-"
     Hemmer: "I think it's a good question -- I think there's a another good question here, too. Why hasn't a liberal radio station or TV network never taken off before?"
     Cafferty explained: "We have them. Are you, did you just get off a vegetable truck from the South Bronx? They're everywhere."
     Hemmer: "It is quite obvious the intent of the message from Al Franken, but there's a business decision in here too that goes back to this theory about why people -- advertisers -- why they'd link themselves with certain people and why certain others."
     Cafferty: "The New York Times is making a few bucks for a few years; they're not exactly a right-wing fascist propaganda sheet."
     O'Brien: "You all can debate in the commercial because I've got things to do."
     Cafferty: "What do they call this joint? The Clinton News Network?"
     O'Brien: "It's hard for me to focus. Still to come this morning, still to come this morning. Planning a big summer vacation this year? Start saving for it right now. We've got some tips coming up on American Morning. Stay with us."

     O'Brien certainly didn't feel comfortable with the subject.

     For CNN's page for American Morning: www.cnn.com

     For a picture and bio of Cafferty: www.cnn.com

     -- NBC's The Tonight Show with Jay Leno on March 29. A Leno opening monologue joke, as taken down by the MRC's Geoff Dickens after some e-mailers alerted us to it:
     "This week, our friend Al Franken is launching a new all liberal radio network called Air America. They say the purpose of Air America will be to balance out all the conservatives in the media, except, of course for NPR, CNN, ABC, CBS, NBC, and the New York Times. Other than that. [Audience laughter] You know everyone is waiting to see if this left wing radio thing will be successful. See I think it's a good idea. I think we should consider different points of view. Like me, I like to hear both sides of an issue. That's why I listen to John Kerry. I know sooner or later I'll get both sides of the issue." [Applause and laughter]

     That liberal media joke is a repeat from Leno's joke vault. On the June 19 Tonight Show last year, he quipped: "And former Vice President Al Gore says he's looking to develop a liberal cable TV and radio network to counteract Fox and all the conservative shows. Gore says there's no outlet in this country for the liberal viewpoint. You know except ABC, NBC, CBS, HBO, Bravo, BET, Showtime, Lifetime, MTV, Oxygen, National Public Radio and IFC. Other than that, there's nothing!"

     That Leno knows he'll get a laugh, for mocking the idea that liberals don't control the media, shows that he knows how ludicrous most find the claim that liberal voices are missing from the media.

 

Most Say U.S. Safer Than Before 9-11,
But WashPost Flips Finding

     The Washington Post's false headline. "Americans feel increasingly safe and secure," read the subhead over a section of a report, from the Council for Excellence in Government, about a poll which determined that "nearly half (47%) of all Americans say that the United States is safer today than it was on September 11, 2001," compared to 38 percent a year after 9-11, and a piddling 18 percent said they now feel less safe than before 9-11. The Washington Post's April 1 headline for a story about the findings: "Most Say They Are Less Safe Since 9/11."

     But it wasn't an April Fools joke. The April 2 Post has this correction:
     "A headline on an April 1 article about a survey on homeland security incorrectly stated that most Americans say they are less safe since Sept. 11, 2001. According to the poll, 47 percent said the United States is safer today than 9/11; 34 percent said it is 'about as safe'; and 18 percent said it is 'less safe.'"

     Yet the online version for the April 1 story by Christopher Lee, which ran on page A-3 of the hard copy, remains unchanged and uncorrected as of 9:30am EST today. See: www.washingtonpost.com

     For the report from the Council for Excellence in Government about the poll conducted for them by Harris/Teeter, see (in PDF): www.excelgov.org

     Scroll down to page 14 for the "Americans feel increasingly safe and secure" section with a pie chart headed: "Public Is Feeling More Safe Today."

 

Moyers Rants Over Bush "Deception," Urges
Gore for Bush Cabinet

     There are only a few months to go before Bill Moyers retires from PBS, but he's not going quietly. Last week on his Friday night show, he delivered a another left wing "commentary" in which he claimed President Bush's "credibility has been shredded" because of his "deception" over Iraq, warned that "there will come a time when the President will have no one to rely on except his most rabid allies in the right wing media," lamented how privates in Afghanistan and Iraq earn less than $16,000 dollars a year "while here at home the rich get their tax cuts" and recommended "a wartime cabinet to serve a wartime nation" with "Al Gore as head of Homeland Security" and John McCain as Secretary of State.

     Sounds like a quote in the MRC's April Fools edition of Notable Quotables, but he really said it.

     An excerpt from Moyers' commentary at the end of the March 26 Now with Bill Moyers on PBS. The MRC's Brian Boyd checked the tape against PBS's transcript:

President Bush spoke eloquently the other day about what the war on terror requires of us. Here's the main point he made:

President Bush: "The war on terror is not a figure of speech. It is an inescapable calling of our generation."

Those words ring true. Whatever drives them, whatever grieves them, Islamic fanatics have declared war and seem willing to wage it to the death. If they prevail our children will grow up in a world where fear governs the imagination and determines the rules of life. Mr. Bush clearly believes what he said: The war on terror is an inescapable calling of the generation now in charge.

Like many of you, I want to support him in that work; I want to do my part. But the President makes it hard. He confused us by going after Saddam Hussein when the villain behind the mass murders of 9/11 was Osama bin Laden. He seems not to realize how his credibility has been shredded by all the false and misleading reasons put forth to justify invading Iraq; Lyndon Johnson never recovered from using the dubious events at the Gulf of Tonkin as an excuse to go to war in Vietnam, and even if Mr. Bush wins reelection this November, he, too, will eventually be dragged down by the powerful undertow that inevitably accompanies public deception.

The public will grow intolerant of partisan predators and crony capitalists indulging in a frenzy of feeding at the troughs in Baghdad and Washington. And there will come a time when the President will have no one to rely on except his most rabid allies in the right wing media; he will discover too late that you cannot win the hearts and minds of the public at large in a nation polarized and pulverized by endless propaganda in defiance of reality.

So what to do? How to assure we win this war?

Well, the 9/11 hearings in Washington suggest a start. It is clear now that the Bush White House bungled the warnings about Al Qaeda, but it's also clear that the Democrats under Bill Clinton made plenty of mistakes, too. Why can't both parties come clean, apologize, and start over?

Either party could lose this war but both parties together just might win it. Why not a wartime cabinet to serve a wartime nation? Al Gore as head of Homeland Security. Gary Hart at Defense. The John McCain or the independent Warren Rudman at State....

Surely, too, there are ways to subject all of us to a draft....

But so far sacrifice has been asked only of the men and women in uniform and their families. Nearly 600 dead since the war began over 400 of them since the President landed on that aircraft carrier under a banner reading 'Mission Accomplished.'

Even now the privates patrolling the mean streets of Baghdad and the wilds of Afghanistan make less than $16,000 dollars a year in base pay, their lives and limbs are constantly at risk. While here at home the rich get their tax cuts -- what Vice President Cheney calls "their due." Favored corporations get their contracts, subsidies and offshore loopholes. And even as he praises sacrifice the President happily passes the huge bills that are piling up on to children not yet born....

     END of Excerpt

     For the Moyers diatribe in full: www.pbs.org

     Home page for Now: www.pbs.org

     The featured guest tonight: John Dean, author of Worse Than Watergate: The Secret Presidency of George W. Bush.

 

"Top Ten Questions You're Afraid to Ask
Condoleezza Rice"

     From the April 1 Late Show with David Letterman, the "Top Ten Questions You're Afraid to Ask Condoleezza Rice." Late Show Web site: www.cbs.com

10. "Did Bush ever hurt himself trying to pronounce your name?"

9. "At cabinet meetings, who besides you and Cheney wear lipstick?"

8. "Do you know Leeza Gibbons?"

7. "Do you own a condo?"

6. "Did you ever try the 'Condoleezza Rice' at Chi-Chi's?"

5. "As a souvenir, did you keep any of Saddam's beard lice?"

4. "Hey, where'd you get that cool Halliburton sweatshirt?"

3. "Who told CNN that Letterman faked the footage of the bored kid next to Bush?"

2. "About those Iraqi weapons of mass destruction -- did you check Baghdad Mini-Storage?"

1. "What kind of job will you and Bush be looking for in January 2005?"

     Tonight, Friday, on the Late Show: Tyler Crotty, the 13-year-old son of the Chairman of Orange County, Florida who, as he was in camera-range behind President Bush, yawned, fidgeted stretched and looked at his watch during a Bush campaign speech.

     The incident generated some notice when Letterman on Monday night edited the tape to jump from instance to instance of Crotty fidgeting and yawning and then CNN's Daryn Kagan on Tuesday inaccurately reported that the White House told CNN that the Late Show staff had digitally inserted the kid into the video, a claim CNN had to retract, conceding on Thursday that the White House never told them any such thing and that the video was unaltered.

     I'm sure Letterman will play his compilation clip tonight. It's pretty funny. But if you can't wait, from this address, which DrudgeReport highlighted on Thursday, you can play a RealPlayer clip of a WKMG-TV in Orlando story about the kid and the incident, a story which includes what Letterman played (as well as some still shots and the text of an AP story outlining what Letterman showed and what CNN reported): www.local6.com

     In Friday's Washington Post, Lisa de Moraes has an article about the White House trying to spin its way out of the reality of the tired kid as well as CNN's embarrassing backtracking and apology to Letterman: www.washingtonpost.com

-- Brent Baker

 


 


Home | News Division | Bozell Columns | CyberAlerts 
Media Reality Check | Notable Quotables | Contact the MRC | Subscribe

Founded in 1987, the MRC is a 501(c) (3) non-profit research and education foundation
 that does not support or oppose any political party or candidate for office.

Privacy Statement

Media Research Center
325 S. Patrick Street
Alexandria, VA 22314