For Immediate Release: Katie Wright (703) 683-5004 - Friday, June 4, 2004
Networks Highlight Soldiers Smiling in Prison Abuse Photos, Ignore Those Showing Bravery in Combat
All Abu Ghraib Zeroes,
Not Decorated Heroes
As the networks prepare to cover the 60th anniversary of the heroic American D-Day landing, they ought to reconsider American heroism in this century. In the latest
National Review, Kate O'Beirne found a sad measure of anti-war bias: While the networks have relished making the names of the smiling Abu Ghraib prison abusers famous - their defense lawyers have been all over the tube and Lynndie England even gained an exclusive CBS interview - those fighting men who've won the highest military honors are unknown.
With two notable exceptions - former NFL player Pat Tillman, who earned a posthumous Silver Star for his service in Afghanistan, and P.F.C. Patrick Miller, who earned the Silver Star for saving Jessica Lynch's unit - the TV elite have made few mentions of the Distinguished Service Cross, the Navy Cross, the Silver Star, and other high honors for 130 serving soldiers. Almost all medal mentions touted the decorated bravery of John Kerry. In contrast to hundreds of prison-abuse stories, here's the Iraq rare medal mentions:
ABC. On May 4, Good Morning America aired a segment of tribute to Tillman. Miller's award was mentioned on the July 15, 2003
Nightline. Marine Sgt. Jeffrey Bohr earned a Silver Star, posthumously given to his wife on May 3. She appeared briefly on the June 26, 2003
Nightline. Bohr was also included in Nightline's April 30 summation of "The Fallen." But his medal has yet to be mentioned.
CBS. On April 18, 2003, Early Show co-host Harry Smith mentioned Sgt. Bohr in a story on fallen soldiers. Miller's actions were profiled on the November 9, 2003
60 Minutes. On April 30 of this year, Dan Rather briefly noted Tillman's Silver Star. On May 11, Rather's new "Fallen Heroes" feature noted the posthumous Silver Star of Michael Stack, for "actions that helped save the rest of his team."
NBC. In 2003, NBC had four mentions of Silver Stars: an April 18
Today anchor brief on Lt. Col. Jeff Ingram, a May 26 Nightly News mention of a Silver Star application for Capt. Phil Wolford, and two stories on P.F.C. Miller, an August 1
Dateline profile and a November 11 Nightly News story. This year, news anchor Carl Quintanilla briefly noted Tillman's medal on the May 1
On April 28,
NBC Nightly News took a different approach to medals: instead of noticing the actual medal winners, reporter Chip Reid did a story on people who have conjured up false histories of medal-winning military heroism in previous wars.
CNN's Lou Dobbs has a regular "Heroes" segment which has shown stories of valor that Dan, Tom, and Peter have completely ignored while they've overdosed on prison abuse. On the November 14, 2003
Lou Dobbs Tonight, he recognized Major Mark Mitchell, who won the first Distinguished Service Cross since the Vietnam War for his valor in the battle of Mazar-e-Sharif.
On the May 14
Lou Dobbs Tonight, CNN reporter Casey Wian told the story of Marine Lt. Brian Chontosh, whose "Marine platoon was ambushed by Iraqis firing mortars, rocket-propelled grenades and machine guns. Trapped, Chontosh ordered his driver, Lance Cpl. Armand McCormick, to turn directly into a heavily armed enemy trench." When ammunition ran out, Lt. Chontosh twice picked up discarded enemy rifles until he had cleared over 200 meters of trench and killed 20 enemy soldiers.
Unfortunately, to most network reporters today, American bravery and heroism on the battlefield isn't a fraction as newsworthy as American depravity in a prison.
- Tim Graham
Home | News Division
| Bozell Columns | CyberAlerts
Media Reality Check | Notable Quotables | Contact
the MRC | Subscribe