Dan Rather: The Bush "Fix" Is In; Voting Victims; Judge Speedy or Slow?; Fineman Conceded Pro-Gore Bias; Harris Hailed on MNF
-- Extra Edition
1) Peter Jennings and Dan
Rather opened their shows Tuesday night by stressing worries about how
time is running out on Al Gore. Rather: "A race against the clock
as time grows shorter."
2) Diabolical GOP plot. CBS hit Jeb Bush with the
Democratic attack line about how he's "pulling strings behind the
scenes." Dan Rather told a State Senator how "some say"
the "fix" is in because of the Republican Governor, state
legislature and Secretary of State, so "there's no way Al Gore
can win this."
3) Democrats "trotted out real people" unable
to handle proper voting and CBS and NBC obligingly showcased the
"victims." CBS highlighted a white teen who attacked Katherine
Harris while NBC showcased a baseless incendiary charge from a black
4) NBC Nightly News spiked its own poll which discovered
three times as many think Bush should be declared the winner as prefer
Gore and a large majority believe Bush has won the election.
5) ABC: Judge Sanders Sauls is "seen by many as
slow and methodical." NBC: He's "known for his speed."
Both networks agree he's "conservative."
6) Bias admitted by Newsweek's Howard Fineman who told
Don Imus that if the situation were reversed the media line would be:
"That George Bush was a crybaby, that he was the spoiled son of a
7) "Ker-Plotz! The Fox factor," an article by
the MRC's Tim Graham posted on National Review Online, about how FNC
has become a target of liberal pundits who can't see bias at ABC, CBS
8) During Monday Night Football this week play-by-play
announcer Al Michaels let slip that he considers Florida Secretary of
State Katherine Harris to be an "American heroine."
certification isn't giving George W. Bush any advantage with the
broadcast networks, judging by how they opened their broadcasts Tuesday
night. ABC and CBS worried about time running out on Gore while NBC gave a
more balanced overview of the day's claims:
-- ABC's World News Tonight. Peter Jennings opened
the show: "We're going to begin this evening with what to do about
time, time to contest and defend the election results in Florida. A court
in Florida allowed Al Gore and George Bush an equal time to deal with any
challenge to certified results. Mr. Gore, as we know, is trying to
overturn Mr. Bush's victory. Mr. Gore and his surrogates have spent the
day saying it can only be done if the court hurries up the normal process.
Mr. Bush's team says don't rush to judgment."
-- CBS Evening News. Dan Rather began: "Vice
President Gore's battle for the White House is coming down to a race
against the clock as time grows shorter."
-- NBC Nightly News. Tom Brokaw led the broadcast:
"As Governor Bush in Texas made a public show today of moving ahead
with his cabinet plans, Vice President Gore continued to insist that
thousands of votes have not been counted, a charge the Governor's legal
team in Florida immediately rejected. All of this is in the courts in
Florida today as part of the Vice President's formal challenge to the
Later, Brokaw introduced a story by seeming to
assume that Bush will be the next President: "NBC's David Gregory
joins me now from his post in Austin, Texas to look at how George W. Bush
spent another day getting ready to become the next President."
soon, the CBS Evening News warned Tuesday night, a diabolical Republican
plot to use the Republican state legislature and Governor to steal the
election from Al Gore.
CBS dedicated a story to Democratic spin about how
Republicans are plotting unfairly behind the scenes. In the piece Jim
Axelrod confronted Jeb Bush with the Democratic attack line about how
he's "publicly recused himself but he's doing nothing but pulling
strings behind the scenes." Dan Rather followed up by hitting a
Republican State Senator with how "some say" the "fix"
is in since "you've got a Republican Governor...a dominant
Republican state legislature and a Republican Secretary of State" so
"there's no way Al Gore can win this."
Axelrod began his November 28 story by warning that
the Florida legislature is plotting its own plan "to end run the
courts" and "with Republicans making up 60 percent of both
Houses, it would be a slam dunk for George W. Bush....In Florida
Republicans control the cabinet, the congressional delegation and the
biggest prize of them all."
Lois Frankel, a Democratic State Representative opined:
"George Bush's brother is our Governor. He has tremendous influence
over our process."
"Democratic Representative Lois Frankel notes Jeb Bush has publicly
removed himself from his position on the state canvassing board. But, she
says, don't be naive."
wants his brother to win. Do I think that he's just sitting in a corner
twiddling his thumbs?"
Bush has kept a low profile, but drew some careful distinctions
Axelrod to Jeb on
the street: "Here's the position the Democrats want to lay out.
Governor Bush has publicly recused himself but he's doing nothing but
pulling strings behind the scenes."
"That's not true but I haven't recused myself from being Governor
of the state. I will do what I think is right."
"And to the people who say he just wants his brother elected and this
is a clear conflict?"
Jeb Bush: "You
guys are all going to leave, a week from now or two weeks from now and all
the satellite trucks are going to be gone and I'm going to still be
Governor of this state and I'm going to have to be part of the healing
process. I love my job, I love this state, I don't like what's going
on and for Al Gore's campaign to suggest anything other than my
motivations are as sincere as they can be is just wrong."
"If legislators convene and pass a law requiring Bush electors, Jeb
Bush would either sign the bill that could make his brother President or
let it pass without his signature to avoid the appearance of conflict.
Either way, his low profile in this story would be raised
Next, Dan Rather ran an excerpt of an interview with
a guy seemingly named after a college in New Hampshire, Daniel Webster.
Now there's an amazing name for a State Senator. Do they have any
elected officials in Florida named George Washington or James Madison?
Rather first asked the Republican whether the
legislature will ultimately decide the presidency. Webster replied only if
they have to because the electors would not be named otherwise. Rather's
second question: "Are you or are you not saying that if the Florida
state courts rule for Vice President Gore and the counting, or if you
prefer to call it recounting, is taken up again and Gore prevails, that
the legislature will let that stand as the legal answer to where
Florida's electoral votes go." Webster maintained that Florida will
follow what voters decided if there's no court ruling pending.
Rather then delivered this loaded inquiry: "Let
me come to a point that I have heard some people express, by no means a
majority of people I've talked to. Some say, listen, quote, 'Is the
fix in in Florida? You've got a Republican Governor, you've got a not
just a majority but a dominant Republican state legislature and a
Republican Secretary of State.' And under those circumstances, so the
quote goes, there's no way Al Gore can win this."
"Some say" inside CBS News and within the
Democratic Party, if those two groups can be differentiated.
"trotted out real people" victims of the Palm Beach County and
Miami-Dade County ballot and CBS and NBC obligingly showcased their
complaints. CBS highlighted a dorky white teen while NBC showcased a
baseless incendiary charge from a black woman.
In a Tuesday night CBS Evening News story John
Roberts showed Al Gore demanding every vote be counted. Roberts picked up:
"To drive that point home, the Democrats today trotted out real
people who claim they were victims of a bad ballot in Palm Beach
"At this time I would like to say to Katherine Harris that I am
19-years-old and I vote and my vote counts just as much as your vote and
Try again next time.
Over on the NBC Nightly News, David Bloom relayed:
"Gore's Tallahassee team today using not lawyers but real voters to
focus attention on Miami-Dade County where some 10,000 ballots, counted by
machine, failed to register a vote in the presidential race. 76-year-old
Efalla Frasier (sp?)."
Frasier, a black
woman, raised the race card: "We do not want to go back to those days
where our vote can't count."
CBS's Roberts, at least noted in segueing into a James Baker soundbite:
"But Bush's point man in Florida argues those aren't votes, those
are non-votes, already counted twice by machine."
Later, Jim Avila highlighted the supposed under vote
problem in Miami-Dade. "My card wouldn't go down in the slot,"
whined a woman. Avila identified her: "Election officials call that
an under vote. Beverly Jones calls it a shame." Jones rued: "If
it didn't count I will be very sad because I voted for Al Gore."
Nightly News suppressed its own poll which discovered three times as many
think Bush should be declared the winner as prefer Gore and a large
majority believe Bush has won the election.
On Tuesday's Today by Matt Lauer outlined the new
NBC News poll which found "50 percent say Bush should be declared the
winner to 16 percent for Al Gore" and when asked "Do you think
that George W. Bush has won the election?" Lauer relayed that
"61 percent of the people said yes, 28 percent said no, 11 percent
But a few hours later, the November 28 NBC Nightly
News provided only a vague reference to the poll as Claire Shipman noted:
"When confronted by questions about poll numbers that show his public
support dropping, Gore also argues that might not matter."
ABC's didn't hint at any poll numbers while CBS
without its own poll actually provided slightly more concrete information
about NBC's than did NBC Nightly News. John Roberts reported: "The
Vice President is in a race against time, not only against a deadline of
December 12th when Florida's electors must be seated, but against new
polls showing the majority of Americans now think the process should
Sanders Sauls "slow and methodical" or "known for his
speed"? Depends if you believe ABC or NBC -- which both agree he's
Monday night, as noted in the November 28 CyberAlert,
ABC reporter Erin Hayes asserted on World News Tonight that the Leon
County judge who will decide the Gore election contest case has been
"on the bench for nearly twenty years, conservative, seen by many as
slow and methodical, he was demoted from a chief judge position."
Tuesday morning on Today, MRC analyst Geoffrey
Dickens noticed, NBC's Claire Shipman offered a contrasting assessment:
"The judge, a conservative Democrat, appointed by a Republican and
known for his speed, gave Gore's lawyers two days and the Bush team until
Friday to put together their witness and exhibits list."
admitted by Newsweek's Howard Fineman. Asked Tuesday by Don Imus
"how would the liberal weenies of the news media be treating this if
the roles were reversed?", Fineman conceded: "That George Bush
was a crybaby, that he was the spoiled son of a failed President. You
know, you could just hear, the personal attacks on Bush would be just
The MRC's Rich Noyes took the exchange taken down
from MSNBC by MRC analyst Paul Smith and turned it into a Campaign 2000
Media Reality Check "Quick Take" distributed by fax Tuesday
afternoon. To view it as fax recipients received it, access the Acrobat
Here's the text:
"THE ATTACKS ON BUSH WOULD BE ABSOLUTELY VICIOUS" NEWSWEEK'S
FINEMAN ADMITS THE MEDIA ARE CODDLING LOSER GORE
Newsweek Washington bureau reporter and MSNBC analyst Howard Fineman
let it slip out this morning: The liberal media's double standard is
benefitting Al Gore as the Democrat tries desperately to spin his way from
defeat to victory.
Fineman was a guest this morning on radio's Imus in the Morning,
simulcast on MSNBC, when host Don Imus asked the question that most
liberal reporters dread: What if the roles were reversed?
"What if Gore had won and Bush, what if the roles were
reversed," Imus wondered. "How would, I wouldn't want to
include you in this, but how would the liberal weenies of the news media
be treating this if the roles were reversed?"
"Oh, my God. Are you kidding?" Fineman truthfully replied.
"That George Bush was a crybaby, that he was the spoiled son of a
failed President. You know, you could just hear, the personal attacks on
Bush would be just absolutely vicious."
But, as Fineman knows, the networks aren't calling Gore a crybaby or
subjecting him to vicious personal attacks. Monday, all of the
broadcast networks interrupted prime time to carry Gore's plea for
patience; Sunday, NBC refused to give the certified winner,
George W. Bush, a similar chance to speak live and unedited to the
Instead, in the Eastern and Central time zones, NBC showed Titanic,
starring Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet. For those who
missed the movie so they could watch the finale of this historic election:
the ship sank.
The Fox factor," an article by MRC Director of Media Analysis Tim
Graham posted on National Review Online, about how the Fox News Channel
has become a popular target of liberal pundits who can't see any liberal
bias at ABC, CBS or NBC but see conservative bias riddled throughout FNC.
To read this piece
online, go to:
Here's the text:
Conservatives have been documenting the liberal bias of the TV networks
for at least three decades. In her book The News Twisters, author Edith
Efron chronicled how the networks favored Hubert Humphrey over Richard
Nixon in the 1968 presidential race. So perhaps we should watch patiently
as liberals attempt the baby steps of complaining about conservative media
bias. The primary liberal target is the Fox News Channel, which is the
hottest phenomenon in cable television, a growing powerhouse that is
crushing MSNBC (which is a film-clip festival of celebrity interview
repeats outside major political crises) and costing jobs at an
increasingly nervous CNN (namely Clinton golfing buddy/ex-CNN president
Fox's founding declaration of difference was to announce the slogan
"We report, you decide." This is a shocking deviation from the
liberal media modus operandi, which is marinated in the impatient belief
that the American people are too politically unreliable to be allowed to
make decisions for themselves. With that slogan in the air, liberal media
critics like the Columbia Journalism Review quickly announced the
discovery of a media-bias problem -- but only at Fox. With the politeness
that only an insular clique can muster, somehow the rest of the media had utterly rejected editorializing, except for
these dastardly Republican-sympathizers
that Rupert Murdoch was bankrolling.
In September, the New York Times noticed, with a story headlined
"The Right Strategy for Fox: Conservative Cable Channel Gains in
Ratings War." The Times later ran a correction that "the
headline exceeded the facts in the article." Reporter James Rutenberg
pointed out that "In critiques of Fox, it is usually noted that [Fox
chief Roger] Ailes was a political consultant to Richard M. Nixon, Ronald
Reagan and George Bush." But later, Rutenberg quoted CNN chairman Tom
Johnson without any mention of his years of service as an aide to Lyndon
The latest silly exercise in tunnel vision comes from Slate's David
Plotz, who writes with characteristic liberal precision: "This
ostentatious fairness is preposterous. The big three networks and CNN
stifle any seeping opinion with a deadening evenhandedness. If you watch
ABC news for 48 hours, you will detect a lefty bias in story choice and
interview subjects. If you watch Fox News for 48 seconds, the righty bias
will stomp you on the head." Plotz offered no specifics, no examples,
no quotes. If the bias is so noticeable, couldn't the man at least tape an
hour or two and give us an example? The
transcripts are on Nexis. How hard could it be? To add to the fun, Plotz
followed up: "TomPaine.com has dubbed Fox 'GOP-TV,' but that's too
crude." Too crude? Cruder than "in 48 seconds, the righty bias
will stomp you on the head"?
Fox takes this guff in part because of who their coverage attracts. Its
convention coverage nearly trumped CNN during the Republican convention in
Philadelphia this summer, but plunged during the Democratic confab in Los
Angeles. The difference is probably hundreds of thousands of conservatives
who wanted to see the Republicans without sneering Dans and Peters, but
couldn't stand to watch the Democrats uncork a week of Old Democrat
rhetoric. Plotz argued that Fox "is targeted not at the entire
country but at the millions of right-leaning Americans skeptical of
mainstream media. It is an assertive conservative tabloid."
Fox's popular evening talk-show lineup does feature feisty
conservatives Bill O'Reilly and Sean Hannity (who is paired nightly with
liberal Alan Colmes.) But these are not the "We report, you
decide" hours of the network. What about its nightly newscast, Fox
Report? What about its reporters, like David Shuster and Carl Cameron, who
in the last few years have broken major stories on the Clinton scandals?
Plotz admitted: "Fox also believes that critics unfairly lump its
news and its commentary together and
that its news deserves more respect, which it probably does."
But how does Plotz's "assertive conservative tabloid" theory
match up with the reality that under Ailes, Fox has consistently hired
away many familiar faces from -- gasp -- the liberal networks? Former ABC
star Brit Hume may have the highest profile, but Ailes has also added
NBC's Jon Scott and Linda Vester, ABC/NPR reporter Jim Angle, former MSNBC
anchors Laurie Dhue and John Gibson, and CBS's Paula Zahn, who hosts her
own nightly hour-long show called The Edge.
As my colleague Brent Baker noticed in reviewing the "conservative
channel" article in the New York Times, Zahn interviewed George W.
Bush that week and asked: "But even members of your own party aren't
crazy about your tax-cut idea. They think it's too big, even some guys
running now in November for new congressional seats. They're abandoning
you. Why?" Does this sound like a "conservative channel" in
action? Plotz didn't ask or answer the question: why did the
"conservative channel" join the other networks in the
"Dewey Defeats Truman" mistake of calling Florida for Al Gore
before the polls closed?
Plotz concluded by phonily applauding the addition of Fox: "Until
now, we've been stuck with three absurdly evenhanded networks and a TV
wire service. Cable has fragmented every other part of the TV market -- we
have a cartoon network, food network, history channel, etc. it's about
time that the news fragmented too....Hooray for media bias -- and for Fox,
whatever dishonest slogan it adopts."
Fox News Channel should be analyzed, scrutinized, and criticized for
how it reports the news. But Fox's critics seem incapable of detecting any
on-air evidence to back up their complaints of overtly right-wing
Republican bias. If liberal skeptics one day offer a real content analysis
of Fox, they could really attempt to gain our respect and acknowledge that
the other networks are not to be dismissed as "absurdly
even-handed." The actual record of network coverage is too littered
with liberal sermonizing to earn Plotz's backhanded compliment.
has a conservative mole and in the ongoing presidential battle he's
revealed his ideology, but he's not with ABC News. He's with ABC
Sports. During Monday Night Football this week play-by-play announcer Al
Michaels let slip that he considers Florida Secretary of State Katherine
Harris to be an "American heroine."
Last week, during the November 20 game, Dennis
Miller recommended Peggy Noonan for President and Michaels conceded her
writing gives him "goose bumps." For details, go to:
The MRC's Tom Johnson again alerted me to this
moment of political comment. Just as the 4th quarter began during the
November 27 Green Bay Packers versus Carolina Panthers game, Michaels
called a play: "Steve Beuerlein hands the ball off to Hoover and he
gets swept under by Bernado Harris. Bernardo the middle linebacker, 6th
year, coming home out of North Carolina."
Fouts picked up on the Harris name of the Packers player: "Katherine
Harris would be proud of that tackle!"
Above accurate spellings of player names made
possible by MRC analyst Geoffrey Dickens.
MRC Webmaster Andy Szul has already posted a
RealPlayer video clip of the above exchange and it will be added to this
item in the posted version of this CyberAlert. For now, go to: http://archive.mrc.org
Too bad Al Michaels isn't in the news division,
but then a lot more people watch Monday Night Football than tune in World
News Tonight or Good Morning America. -- Brent Baker
Support the MRC, an educational foundation dependent upon contributions
which make CyberAlert possible, by providing a tax-deductible
donation. Use the secure donations page set up for CyberAlert
readers and subscribers:
>>>To subscribe to CyberAlert, send a
blank e-mail to:
@topica.com. Or, you can go to:
Either way you will receive a confirmation message titled: "RESPONSE
REQUIRED: Confirm your subscription to firstname.lastname@example.org."
After you reply, either by going to the listed Web page link or by simply
hitting reply, you will receive a message confirming that you have been
added to the MRC CyberAlert list. If you confirm by using the Web page
link you will be given a chance to "register" with Topica. You
NOT have to do this; at that point you are already subscribed to
To unsubscribe, send a blank e-mail to:
Send problems and comments to: email@example.com.
can learn what has been posted each day on the MRC's Web site by
subscribing to the "MRC Web Site News" distributed every weekday
afternoon. To subscribe, send a blank e-mail to: firstname.lastname@example.org.
Or, go to: http://www.mrc.org/newsletters.<<<
Home | News Division
| Bozell Columns | CyberAlerts
Media Reality Check | Notable Quotables | Contact
the MRC | Subscribe